The Argonaut

An arts education, advocacy database for teachers, parents, students and business

    President Bush Proposes Slashing Afterschool Programs by 40%, Leaving Half a Million Children Behind

Feb. 3 - Today the Bush Administration released its Fiscal Year '04 budget, which recommends slashing the appropriation for 21st Century Community Learning Centers, the federal afterschool program, from $1 billion to $600 million. This 40% cut will deny access to afterschool programs to some 571,000 children.

This federal afterschool program is vital to children and families across America. It was designed to provide safe, enriching environments for students after school and to help working families.

If Congress goes along with President Bush's cut, more than half a million children will be denied access to the afterschool programs that keep them safe, help them learn and relieve their families of child care worries during the afternoon hours. Children and families in every state and community will be affected.

Two years ago, the No Child Left Behind Act created a roadmap for expanding the 21st Century program and for federal funding that would better meet the widespread, compelling need for afterschool. Last year the Administration reneged on the funding commitment it made in that bill. Now, President Bush is backtracking even further. The No Child Left Behind Act called for $1.75 billion for the 21st Century Community Learning Centers in 2004. Cutting the program to $600 million instead means that 1.65 million youth lose the opportunity to learn and grow after school.

Click here to send a message to President Bush and your representatives that you want more, not less, afterschool in your community.

The rationale for this cut -- that afterschool programs do not improve academics or behavior -- is based on a federal study with significant limitations, serious methodological problems and an obvious bias. Dozens of other respected, independent studies, some of them going into greater depth and conducted over many years, tell us that afterschool programs keep children safe, improve learning and help working families. (See story and links above.)

Response to Proposed Budget Slash by Afterschool Alliance Director Judy Samelson

Closing the Doors on Afterschool Programs: An Analysis of How the Proposed Cut to the 21st Century Community Learning Centers Program Will Affect Children and Families in Every State

To assess the impact of a $400 million cut to the 21st Century Community Learning Centers program proposed by President Bush for fiscal year 2004, the Afterschool Alliance has issued a new report called, Closing the Doors on Afterschool Programs: An Analysis of How the Proposed Cut to the 21st Century Community Learning Centers Program Will Affect Children and Families in Every State.

The report illustrates the effect the proposed cut would have on the availability of afterschool programs in each of the 50 states and the District of Columbia. Where available, analysis of the state's ability to meet the current demand for afterschool program grants is also provided.

A review of the data shows that the demand for 21st Century afterschool programs far exceeds the resources available. In fact, among the 31 states reporting 2002 grant data, 75 percent of applicants' funding requests had to be denied. Without doubt, the 40 percent budget cut proposed by President Bush would widen this gap significantly. At the proposed $600 million budget level, program growth would halt, and many 21st Century afterschool programs across all 50 states would be forced to close their doors. More than 550,000 children would lose access to afterschool programs.

PDF of Full Report


New Poll: Voters See Afterschool Programs As Key to Keeping Kids Safe, Helping Them Learn

Voters Disagree with Bush Plan for No Increase in Federal Afterschool Funds

Washington, DC - Even with new concerns about the economy, terrorism and war, American voters overwhelmingly support the afterschool programs that keep kids safe and healthy, help working families and improve academic achievement. They see afterschool programs as key to keeping children safe during the sometimes-perilous afternoon hours, and want government to provide more adequate funds for these programs. Those are among the findings of a telephone survey of registered voters age 18 and older conducted for the Afterschool Alliance by Lake Snell Perry & Associates and The Tarrance Group from August 13 to 21.

Nine in ten voters agree that there should be some type of organized activity or place for children to go after school every day that provides opportunities for them to learn, the survey found. By a two-to-one margin (59 to 28 percent), voters disagree with President Bush's decision, as reflected in his 2003 budget, to "not increase funding for afterschool programs beyond their current level." The "No Child Left Behind Act," passed by Congress last December and signed by President Bush this January, authorized $1.5 billion for the federal 21st Century Community Learning Centers program in Fiscal Year 2003 - but President Bush's budget called for just $1 billion. Nearly two-thirds of voters (63 percent) are concerned that existing afterschool programs may have to reduce services or close their doors because no new funds are available. Click here to read more


Disappointing Federal Afterschool Study Released

Feb. 3 - The U.S. Department of Education released a disappointing afterschool report late in the day, following an announcement by the administration that the 21st Century Community Learning Centers afterschool program would be cut by 40% due to the study's findings.

Based on one year of data, the report states that little gains were made at the programs studied. A review of the full study, however, reveals that the report diminished several positive findings, including gains among African American and Hispanic students and increased parent involvement. (Click here for analysis of study.)

"The study released yesterday by the U.S. Department of Education and Mathematica Policy Research, Inc. underscores the great promise of afterschool - so it is terribly disappointing that the report highlights only negative findings and that the Bush Administration is using this study to justify a deep, indefensible cut in the federal afterschool program," stated Judy Samelson, Afterschool Alliance Executive Director.

The Bush plan to slash funding from $1 billion to $600 million in Fiscal Year '04 would deny afterschool programs to more than 571,000 children.

The report comes out at a time when dozens of other respected, independent studies tell us that afterschool programs keep children safe, improve academic achievement and help working families. Although the Mathematica study challenges the benefits afterschool programs provide in terms of keeping kids safe, two recent evaluations of afterschool show clear evidence of increased safety. Among the findings:

An about-to-be-released multi-year study by Policy Study Associates evaluated a sample of 96 programs run by The After-School Corporation (TASC) in New York City and found that students reported certain risky behaviors, including alcohol use and sexual activity, were less common in their lives than they had been before they began participating in the TASC program.

In a recent report to the U.S. Department of Justice, UCLA's independent evaluation of LA's BEST afterschool program found that children reported feeling significantly safer at an LA's BEST program than in their neighborhoods.

To see the full Mathematica report, go to

For a backgrounder reviewing evaluations of afterschool programs click here.


     

Advocacy Books to Ponder