Governor Mike Huckabee
of Arkansas believes the arts must play an essential role in the K-12
education of every child. It is this understanding of the
transformative power of the arts that led Governor Huckabee to choose
the arts in education as the focus of his ECS 2004-06
chairmanship.
"The research tells us what
parents and education policymakers have known all along but haven't
been able to prioritize on a national level," says Governor Huckabee.
"The arts are critical, not only as a link to student productivity
but also as a key to a competitive workforce."
It's a truism that
"accountability" and "No Child Left Behind" are the watchwords of the
current era of education reform. And at a time when many states are
tightening their belts, every dollar counts. So where does this leave
the arts in the greater scheme of the K-12 curriculum? It is not
clear at this time the extent to which the arts have been
marginalized in the K-12 curriculum, or the extent to which quality
arts programs are flourishing. It is Governor Huckabee's conviction,
however, that the arts must be an indispensable component of every
child's schooling. Research on the powerful effects of arts in
education supports this view:
Academic:
- Music serves as a catalyst for
development in young children. Music develops intellectual and
social and emotional skills, as well as motor, language and
overall literacy abilities. In fact, "music is a great organizer
that helps the body and the mind work together." Music likewise
builds memory skills, serves as an introduction to "the sounds and
meanings of words," and provides a venue for interaction. (Zero to
Three, Getting in Tune: The Powerful Influence of Music on Young
Children's Development, 2002)
- Arts instruction enhances
overall neurological development. The motor skills and
sensory-motor capabilities necessary in all walks of life are
developed through arts instruction. Robert Sylwester, professor
emeritus of education at the University of Oregon provides a
succinct, eloquent description of these processes in the November
1998 issue of Educational Leadership.
- Arts education improves
academic performance, problem-solving skills, creativity and
self-expression. Research has shown that children who receive arts
instruction demonstrate greater skills in creativity and other
related competencies. The Center for Arts Education Research at
Columbia University has conducted numerous studies evaluating the
influence of the arts on academic performance.
In fact, a large body of evidence
suggests that well-constructed programs in dance, theater, music and
visual arts can have a significant impact on reading skills,
including early readers and remedial readers. What is more, research
indicates time and again that students who take part in arts
education programs exhibit greater facility in spoken and written
self-expression. Learning in and Through the Arts: Curriculum
Implications by the Center for Arts Education Research at Columbia
University's Teachers College offers an example of these findings.
Student engagement:
- The arts assist in
rehabilitating at-risk youth and juvenile offenders. Studies have
found that the behavior, social skills and academic achievement of
both at-risk and incarcerated youth who participated in arts-based
delinquency prevention programs showed measurable and marked
improvement in relation to comparison groups. One of the most
notable of these studies is the YouthARTS Development Project, a
collaborative effort launched in 1995 by the U.S. Department of
Justice's Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention
and the National Endowment for the Arts. Participants demonstrated
both positive "intermediate effects" (better communication skills,
stronger resistance to peer pressure and healthier attitudes
towards drugs, to name just a few) and "long-term outcomes" (fewer
court referrals and improved academic performance).
http://www.ncjrs.org/html/ojjdp/2001_5_2/contents.html
http://ojjdp.ncjrs.org/grants/grantprograms/discr14.html
Also, another study conducted from
1987 to 1998 found similar positive results among urban youth
involved in nonschool arts activities.
- Student involvement in the
arts improves students' school attendance. A great deal of
research drives home the fact that the arts make school a place
where children, particularly struggling and at-risk students, want
to be. According to one study of students in after-school arts
programs, participating students were three times more likely to
be awarded for high school attendance rates than nonparticipating
students, despite the fact that participating students were twice
as likely to come from troubled homes or attend schools with high
incidences of violence. (from Americans for the Arts Monographs,
vol. 2, no. 7, November 1998)
Social and civic
development:
- The arts help students build
positive self-image. Numerous reports point to the power of the
arts in education to help students improve their self-image, which
research indicates is a powerful component in helping students
improve academic performance.
- The arts help students improve
cooperative and positive socialization skills. Research indicates
that well-designed and well-implemented arts in education programs
have a positive impact on students' ability to work cooperatively
and interact with other students. Examples of such research
include the artists-in-residence program operated by Music Center
of Los Angeles' County, Education Division. (from Schools,
Communities and the Arts: A Research Compendium)
- The arts help students develop
multicultural understanding. In an age where American society is
becoming ever more diverse, the value of assisting young people in
understanding those from other cultures cannot be overemphasized.
A wide variety of arts in education programs are helping students
build cultural bridges as well as understand their own cultures.
Economic development:
- The arts prepare students for
the economy of the 21st century. As phrased in Ann Galligan's
December 2001 report Creativity, Culture, Education, and the
Workforce, "Providing all students with a complete education in
the arts and humanities can help them cope with, and master,
fast-paced technological advances, forces of globalization, and
major demographic and societal shifts that characterize today's
world. The abilities to think creatively, to communicate
effectively and to work collaboratively are increasingly
identified as necessary skills, along with the fundamental
abilities to read, write and use numbers."
- The arts are an engine for
economy-building at the state and local level. A growing body of
research indicates the large and ever-increasing dollar amounts
that the arts generate, both for private ventures as well as state
and local governments. As the NGA Center for Best Practices
reports in The Role of the Arts in Economic Development, the arts
produce $849 million in annual business revenues in Virginia,
while nonprofit arts organizations alone contributed nearly 2,500
to Louisiana's economy.
Quality of life:
- The arts improve quality of
life for individuals and communities. Various studies confirm the
role of the arts in contributing to individual enjoyment and
healthy communities. Two studies by the Performing Arts Research
Coalition (PARC) surveyed residents of the greater metropolitan
areas in Alaska, Cincinnati, Denver, Pittsburgh, Seattle, Austin,
Boston, Minneapolis-St. Paul, Sarasota/Manatee and Washington,
D.C. Three-fourths of survey respondents "strongly agreed or
agreed that the arts were enjoyable," while respondents placed an
even greater emphasis on the value of the arts to the community at
large: over 80% of respondents "strongly agreed or agreed that the
performing arts improve the quality of life in their community."
(see the summary of the research or the full reports, The Value of
the Performing Arts in Five Communities and The Value of the
Performing Arts in Five Communities 2)