

| Week #5 Player Picks and Results | ||||||||||||||||||||
| Player | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | Tie | Survivor | Déjà vu | Score |
| Todd Anderson | Cardinals | Titans | Saints | Patriots | Redskins | Jaguars | Texans | Giants | Steelers | Colts | Ravens | Chargers | Bears | Cowboys | 32-17-49 | Out | Out | 13 | ||
| Erinn Maher | Cardinals | Titans | Saints | Patriots | Redskins | Jaguars | Texans | Giants | Steelers | Colts | Ravens | Chargers | Packers | Cowboys | 35-14-49 | Cardinals | Out | 12 | ||
| Laurie Kos | Cardinals | Titans | Panthers | Patriots | Redskins | Jaguars | Texans | Giants | Steelers | Colts | Ravens | Broncos | Packers | Cowboys | 28-17-45 | Out | Patriots | 12 | ||
| Sherry Slossar | Cardinals | Titans | Saints | Patriots | Redskins | Jaguars | Texans | Giants | Steelers | Colts | Ravens | Chargers | Packers | Cowboys | 28-17-45 | Out | Patriots | 12 | ||
| Tom Slossar | Rams | Titans | Panthers | Patriots | Redskins | Chiefs | Texans | Giants | Steelers | Colts | Ravens | Broncos | Bears | Cowboys | 31-13-44 | Out | Patriots | 11 | ||
| Sandy Slossar | Cardinals | Titans | Saints | Patriots | Redskins | Jaguars | Texans | Giants | Steelers | Colts | Ravens | Broncos | Packers | Cowboys | 27-17-44 | Out | Patriots | 11 | ||
| Kevin Williams | Cardinals | Titans | Saints | Patriots | Redskins | Jaguars | Texans | Giants | Seahawks | Colts | Ravens | Chargers | Packers | Cowboys | 34-13-47 | Out | Out | 11 | ||
| Chris Watt | Cardinals | Titans | Panthers | Patriots | Redskins | Jaguars | Texans | Giants | Seahawks | Colts | Ravens | Broncos | Packers | Cowboys | 24-14-38 | Cowboys | Patriots | 11 | ||
| Matt Criss | Cardinals | Titans | Saints | Patriots | Redskins | Jaguars | Texans | Giants | Steelers | Colts | Ravens | Broncos | Packers | Cowboys | 35-24-59 | Out | Out | 11 | ||
| Dick Iman | Cardinals | Titans | Saints | Patriots | Redskins | Chiefs | Texans | Giants | Steelers | Colts | Ravens | Chargers | Packers | Cowboys | 33-24-57 | Colts | Out | 11 | ||
| Cindy Iman | Cardinals | Titans | Saints | Patriots | Redskins | Chiefs | Texans | Giants | Steelers | Colts | Ravens | Chargers | Packers | Cowboys | 25-15-40 | Out | Packers | 11 | ||
| Steve Roll | Cardinals | Titans | Saints | Patriots | Redskins | Chiefs | Texans | Giants | Steelers | Colts | Ravens | Chargers | Packers | Cowboys | 42-14-56 | Titans | Cowboys | 11 | ||
| Mark Carlson | Cardinals | Titans | Saints | Patriots | Redskins | Jaguars | Texans | Giants | Seahawks | Colts | Ravens | Chargers | Packers | Cowboys | 38-18-56 | Out | Out | 11 | ||
| Kevin Slossar | Cardinals | Titans | Saints | Patriots | Redskins | Chiefs | Texans | Jets | Steelers | Colts | Ravens | Broncos | Bears | Cowboys | 21-17-38 | Out | Colts | 10 | ||
| Tom Shaddock | Cardinals | Titans | Saints | Patriots | Redskins | Jaguars | Texans | Giants | Seahawks | Colts | Ravens | Broncos | Packers | Cowboys | 41-13-54 | Texans | Out | 10 | ||
| Linda Shaddock | Cardinals | Titans | Saints | Patriots | Redskins | Chiefs | Texans | Giants | Steelers | Colts | 49ers | Chargers | Packers | Cowboys | 27-21-48 | Out | Cowboys | 10 | ||
| Mary Post | Cardinals | Titans | Saints | Patriots | Redskins | Jaguars | Texans | Giants | Steelers | Colts | 49ers | Broncos | Packers | Cowboys | 36-24-60 | Out | Colts | 10 | ||
| Scott Nevius | Rams | Titans | Saints | Patriots | Redskins | Chiefs | Texans | Giants | Steelers | Colts | Ravens | Broncos | Packers | Cowboys | 35-10-45 | Out | Out | 9 | ||
| Shirley Shaddock | Cardinals | Titans | Saints | Patriots | Lions | Jaguars | Texans | Giants | Seahawks | Buccaneers | Ravens | Chargers | Packers | Cowboys | 31-23-54 | Packers | Out | 9 | ||
| Kevin Sullivan | Rams | Titans | Saints | Patriots | Redskins | Jaguars | Texans | Giants | Seahawks | Colts | Ravens | Broncos | Packers | Cowboys | 31-21-52 | Titans | Patriots | 9 | ||
| Ray Kos | Rams | Falcons | Saints | Patriots | Redskins | Chiefs | Texans | Giants | Steelers | Colts | 49ers | Chargers | Packers | Cowboys | 24-17-41 | Out | Out | 8 | ||
| Sue Nevius | Rams | Falcons | Saints | Patriots | Lions | Chiefs | Texans | Giants | Seahawks | Colts | Ravens | Broncos | Bears | Cowboys | 28-17-45 | Out | Patriots | 7 | ||
| Visitor | Cardinals | Falcons | Panthers | Browns | Lions | Jaguars | Dolphins | Jets | Seahawks | Buccaneers | Ravens | Chargers | Bears | Cowboys | 7 | |||||
| Home | Rams | Titans | Saints | Patriots | Redskins | Chiefs | Texans | Giants | Steelers | Colts | 49ers | Broncos | Packers | Bills | 7 | |||||
| Winner | Cardinals | Titans | Panthers | Patriots | Redskins | Jaguars | Texans | Giants | Steelers | Colts | Ravens | Chargers | Bears | Cowboys | ? | ? | 25-24-49 | 14 | ||