I have these cards sorted in levels, 1-6, in the order in which I want them, 1 being highest priority to me and 6 being the lowest. This does not imply similar values! All cards should be in at least Nm- condition or I won't accept it, unless it's a level 1 or 2 card, then I might accept it. Beta and Black Bordered Foreign versions are always preferred, no Alphas unless in a very good deal, please!
Level #1
Ancestral Recall
Beta Timetwister
Black Lotus
Juzam Djinn
Mox (any)
Timewalk
Level #2
Beta Armageddon
Beta Balance
Beta Nevinyrral's Disk
Beta Psionic Blast
Beta Wrath of God
Timetwister
Level #3
Ali from Cairo
Beta Berserk
Beta Duals
Beta Ice Storm
Beta Serra Angel
Candelabra of Tawnos
City of Brass (Arabian BB)
Diamond Valley
Drop of Honey
Ernham Djinn (Arabian BB)
Gauntlet of Might
Guardian Beast
Mirror Universe
Mishra's Workshop
Moat
Nether Void
Psionic Blast
Level #4
Argivian Archaeologist
Asian BB Rares (anything cool)
Berserk
Beta Stuff (anything cool)
Beta Sinkhole
Chains of Mephistopheles
Hammer of Bogarden
Ice Storm
Ifh-Biff Efreet
Serendib Djinn
Serendib Efreet (Arabian BB)
Thawing Glaciers
Thunder Spirit
Level #5
Arena Disenchant
Arena Fireball
City of Solitude
Duals (any)
Jade Statue
Khabal Ghoul
Kjeldoran Outpost
Land Equilibrium
Living Plane
Vampiric Tutor
Level #6
Armageddon
Any Cool OOP's not listed above
Ball Lightning
City of Brass
Desertion
Elvish Archers
Mana Crypt
Millstone (Antiquities BB)
Nevinyrral's Disk
Rainbow Efreet
Relentless Assault
Sacred Mesa
Sealed Packs (especially old stuff)
Shivan Dragon
Signed Cards (anything cool)
Wrath of God