| PLAYER | CAREER | GOALS | GAMES |
| Rick Davies | 1970 - 1985 | 635 | 317 |
| Malcom Greenslade | 1966 - 1977 | 614 | 215 |
| Bo Morton | 1930 - 1940 | 561 | 138 |
| Michael Graham | 1971 - 1985 | 455 | 282 |
| Ken Whelan | 1971 - 1980 | 441 | 126 |
| Ian Wilmott | 1983 - 1989 | 401 | 111 |
| Ted Biggs | 1934 - 1950 | 349 | 156 |
| Gil Langley | 1939 - 1950 | 341 | 160 |
| Paul Hollis | 1980 - 1986 | 283 | 145 |
| Michael Nunan | 1966 - 1977 | 258 | 188 |
| Paul Bagshaw | 1964 - 1980 | 258 | 360 |
| Alby Wundersitz | 1929 - 1938 | 254 | 113 |
| John Halbert | 1955 - 1968 | 253 | 243 |
| Roger Rigney | 1959 - 1971 | 250 | 211 |
| John Paynter | 1983 - 1992 | 249 | 246 |
| Julian Burton | 1995 - today | 243 | 103 |
| Frank Golding | 1909 - 1927 | 240 | 207 |
| Clayton Thompson | 1948 - 1961 | 236 | 151 |
| Jim Derrington | 1977 - 1987 | 232 | 188 |
| Phil Heinrich | 1975 - 1984 | 215 | 184 |
| Malcom "Emmy" Jones | 1965 - 1968 | 205 | 58 |
| Gordon Scrutton | 1922 - 1929 | 201 | 87 |
| Len Fitzgerald | 1951 - 1961 | 201 | 125 |
| Paul Caust | 1950 - 1961 | 200 | 110 |
| Roger Dunn | 1957 - 1968 | 200 | 139 |
| Daryl Hicks | 1960 - 1972 | 190 | 212 |
| John Tilbrook | 1965 - 1970 | 179 | 128 |
| Dean Ottens | 1966 - 1974 | 178 | 116 |
| Keith Chessell | 1964 - 1974 | 177 | 181 |
| Robert Klomp | 1973 - 1987 | 173 | 205 |
| Robert Barton | 1972 - 1978 | 166 | 133 |
| Damian Kitschke | 1986 - 1994 | 162 | 132 |
| Stephen White | 1994 - today | 158 | 100 |
| Alf Longmore | 1932 - 1938 | 158 | 100 |
| Greg Wild | 1968 - 1977 | 152 | 163 |
| Rick Schoff | 1959 -1971 | 151 | 214 |
| Gordon Green | 1929 - 1933, 1937 | 146 | 83 |
| Norm Barron | 1919 - 1928, 1930 - 31 | 146 | 132 |
| Keith Jackson | 1919 - 1926 | 135 | 54 |
| Colin Whitehead | 1924 - 1931, 1933 - 1934 | 134 | 124 |
| Peter Friedrichs | 1970 - 1975, 1977, 1979 - 1981 | 131 | 138 |
| Tony Goodchild | 1953 - 1962 | 128 | 132 |
| Scott Field | 1987 - 1992 | 127 | 125 |
| Jamie Stevenson | 1991 - 1993 | 123 | 55 |
| Ross Reynolds | 1939 - 1947 | 123 | 90 |
| Tony Burgan | 1969 -1979 | 122 | 244 |
| Horrie Riley | 1922 - 1930 | 121 | 122 |
| Jody Arnol | 1992 - 1994 | 115 | 55 |
| Eddie Fry | 1980 - 1987 | 111 | 153 |
| Tony Clarkson | 1959, 1963 - 1968 | 106 | 110 |
| Peter Motley | 1982 - 1985 | 104 | 92 |
| Lance Leake | 1922 - 1925, 1930 - 1933 | 104 | 102 |