Graphic of the edge of a newspaper
Graphic of a newspaper
Submitted to The Cincinnati Enquirer

Editorial Page

Graphic of a newspaper
Friday, May 15, 1997

Not "just" a theory

(Click graphic for larger version and hyperlinks)
Artwork by Ray Troll - Click graphic for larger version and hyperlinks Samuel J. Fenn claims that evolution is "only a theory" ["Darwinism nothing more than a theory", May 13]. To arrive at this conclusion, he substituted the ordinary/prescientific meaning of the term (speculative and not well established) with the scientific meaning (the ability to explain and make predictions from data). A theory is the end product of scientific endeavor. The colloquial meaning of "theory" is more or less equivalent to the scientific term "hypothesis." Scientific theories can and do become established beyond a reasonable doubt;  examples include the germ theory of disease, cell theory, theory of gravitation, quantum theory, special relativity, and transmission genetics. 

Mr. Fenn has provided an excellent example of Columnist Tom Teepen’s original point ["Views on creation 'science' haven't evolved very far", April 16] that creationism contributes to declining science skills. 

I do agree with Mr. Fenn’s statement "...science is merely discovering the laws of nature that God put into motion at creation." Religion deals with the "why" of physical existence, and science deals with the "how". It appears that evolution is the "how" of creation, and the various religious faiths attempt to answer why. As long as each discipline respects these boundaries, they should not come into conflict. 

Todd Brennan
Clifton
Submitted to the Cincinnati Enquirer, but not published
May 15, 1998
(201 words)

Top of Next Column. Back to Editorial/letters Menu
Return to Creationism/Evolution Menu
Graphic of the edge of a newspaper