Join Tokyo
counter
Best of Tokyo



 Best of Tokyo's Administration

Tokyo Ezine








Best of Bests
Criteria
Application
Help
FAQ

Best of Tokyo Mock Review Report


Instructions:

  • This form is for your personal use only. Be as objective as you can. Or you are only fooling yourself!
  • Clicking [SUBMIT] button will not send this form to the Best of Tokyo Steering Committee, but rather to a summary of the data you have chosen
  • A similar form is also used by the Best of Tokyo Theme Reviewers for the actual Review Report.
  • View the BOT Help Pages.

I. Site Details

Applicant's GeoName :
Applicant's E-mail:
Topic or Theme:
URL :

II. Site Status

Summarize your review here and provide general comments with regard to the overall impact of the site.

III. Review Criteria

Content |  Graphics |  Design/Layout |  Requirements |  Guidelines

  • Please select your vote from the choices for each criteria, and subcriteria.
  • Check out the rules under each criteria and sub-criteria before voting.

A. CONTENT : 50%

Go to Graphics |  Design/Layout |  Requirements |  Guidelines

A.1. Originality

Maximum Score: 20% Site's Score:

A.2. Accuracy of Information

Maximum Score: 10% Site's Score:

A.3. Central Theme

Maximum Score: 5% Site's Score:

A.4. Grammar / Syntax

Maximum Score: 5% Site's Score:

A.5. Completeness

Maximum Score: 5% Site's Score:

A.6. Appropriateness of External Links

Maximum Score: 5% Site's Score:

B. GRAPHICAL DESIGN 25%

Go to Content |  Design/Layout |  Requirements |  Guidelines

B.1. Graphics/Images

Maximum Score: 10% Site's Score:

B.2. Background vs Text Fonts

Maximum Score: 5% Site's Score:

B.3. Consistency of Fonts Used

Maximum Score: 5% Site's Score:

B.4. Consistency of Links Fonts

Maximum Score: 5% Site's Score:

C. DESIGN / LAYOUT 25%

Go to Content |  Graphics |  Requirements |  Guidelines

C.1. Layout.

C.1.1. Menu Positioning

Maximum Score: 5% Site's Score:

C.1.2. Frames / Screen

Maximum Score: 3% Site's Score:

C.2. User-Friendliness.

C.2.1. Download Time
Standard: 14.4 KB Modem; 40-60 KB

Maximum Score: 4% Site's Score:

C.2.2. <ALT> Usage

Maximum Score: 3% Site's Score:

C.2.3. Plug-in Required

Maximum Score: 2% Site's Score:

C.3. Navigation.

C.3.1. Redundancy of Links

Maximum Score: 2% Site's Score:

C.3.2. Validity of Links

Maximum Score: 2% Site's Score:

C.3.3. Javascript Navigation

Maximum Score: 2% Site's Score:

C.3.4. Color Attributes of Link

Maximum Score: 2% Site's Score:

IV. Adherence to Page Requirements

Go to Content |  Graphics |  Design/Layout |  Guidelines

Note: GeoGuides and GeoLinks are not required to BOT applicants but if they do exist, they are given additional points for their effort in helping GeoCities promotional activities.

A. Use of GeoGuide


Bonus Points for GeoGuide:

B. Use of GeoLinks


Bonus Points for GeoLinks:

C. Right Neighborhood

Site's theme appropriate to Tokyo Neighborhood?
Yes No . If NO, suggest move to

V. Adherence to Page Contents Guidelines

Go to Content |  Graphics |  Design/Layout |  Requirements

Violations found for the following guidelines:
Commercial Purposes: Banner / Counter / Sponsors
Defaming any person or group;
Exploitation of children under 18.
Illegal activities /Physical harm / Injury
Intellectual property infringement
Grossly Offensive Materials
Hyperlinks to Illegal Content
Multiple GeoCities addresses
Nudity and Pornographic Materials
Restricted or password access pages
Storage / Signpost to other homepage
Violating Internet standards for HP Promotion

Please review your entries before clicking




[Main] [Best Lists] [Criteria] [Application] [Help] [FAQ]



© 1998 Best of Tokyo
All rights reserved. Disclaimer