Due in part to the large number of responses on fansubs.net ml, I figured we're rapidly going no-where with this discussion. Hence this page. It may look simplistic and rough but wht do you expect for something I slapped together in a hour or two.  ^_^
There are already several sites that actually call themselves the Anime Oscars Sites, so to make this simple, this is going to be the Fansub Mailing List Anime Oscars

Rules

Let's keep this simple. I'll put up some categories and you send in your titles/series that you think should be in it. No more than 5 entries per categories per person I'm a full time student with not enough time to do all this data collection if you overload me.
Email me at: bodac@mailcityasia.com
Do not use the Fansubs Mailing List to send it to me. The above address has  got an 8MB capacity so it should be able to handle the flow of emails (If any)

And now on to the categories
If you think more categories need to be needed, drop me a line and I'll add it in as well. I think the website can probably be done better. So
a) If anybody has a nice Anime picture which can be used let me know as well.
b) Any additional help on this site is welcome.
c) Feedback and comments are also appreciated

Open Category (Commerical Titles and Fansubs)

1. Best Anime OAV Series
    a) Geobreeders
    b) Rurouni Kenshin Memorial Arc
    c) Gundam 0080: War in the pocket
    d) Gunbuster
    e) Gundam 0083: Stardust Memories

2. Best Anime TV Series
    a) Rurouni Kenshin
    b) You're Under Arrest
    c) Flames of Recca
    d) Kare Kano
    e) Child's Toy

3. Best Anime Movie
    a) You're Under Arrest Movie
    b) Mahojin Guru Guru Movie
    c) Perfect Blue
    d) Spriggan
    e) Prince of Darkness

4. Best Hentai Anime
    a) Cool Devices

5. Best Shojo Anime
    a) Card Captor Sakura
    b) Child's Toy
    c) Magic Knights Rayearth
    d) Fushigi Yuugi
    e) Marmalade Boy

6. Best New Anime Series (Anything after 1998)
    a) Cowboy Bebop
    b) Blue Submarine 6
    c) Tenshi No Narumon
 

7. Best Background Music in an Anime Series
    a) Flames of Recca
    b) Card Captor Sakura
    c) Cowboy Bebop
    d) Vision of Escaflowne
    e) Brain Powerd

8. Best Opening Song in an Anime Series
    a) Card Captor Sakura 1st Season OP
    b) Berserk OP
    c) Flames of Recca OP
    d) Tenshi No Narumon Op
    e) Bubblegum Crisis OAV 1 OP

9. Best Ending Song in an Anime Series
    a) Flames of Recca Season 2 ED
    b) Yawara ED
    c) Rurouni Kenshin 2nd ED
    d) Rurouni Kenshin 4th ED
    e) Rurouni Kenshin 5th ED

10. Most Violent Anime
    a) Berserk
    b) Ninja Scroll
    c) Ninja Ressurction
    d) Legend of the Overfiend
 

11. Most Under-rated Anime
    a) Patlabor
 
12. Most Over-rated Anime

13. Best Anime adaptation off a Manga Series
    a) Rurouni Kenshin
    b) Flames of Recca
    c) Berserk
   

14. Best Anime adaptation off a Console Game (SNES/PSX/DC/Etc)
    a) Ys I
    b) Ys II

15. Most Powerful Character
(Keep this simple, characters who can destory planets and universes do not count. If you can destroy a planet you're already to powerful :P )
    a) Himura Kenshin
    b) Recca Hanabishi
    c) Gatts
    d) Vargas
    e) Lina Inverse

16. Coolest Character in an Anime
    a) Spike Lee
    b) Aoshi Shinomori
    c) Priss (BGC OAVs)

17. Cutest Character in an Anime
    a) Sakura
 

18. Best Fight Scene in an Anime
    a) Keshin Vs Aoshi
    b) Keshin Vs Shishio
    c) Gatts Vs The Black Baron
    d) Fuko Vs Gashakura
    e) Spike Vs Vicious

19. Best Mecha Fight Scene in an Anime
    a) Gato Vs Uraki - Gundam 0083
    b) Van Vs Dragon Slayers - Vision of Escaflowne
 

20. Best Mecha Design in an Anime
    a) Gunbuster
    b) Gundam Wing
    c) Gundam 0083
    d) Vision of Escaflowne
 

Fansub Category

1. Best Fansubber
    a) Sachi's Distribution
    b) Odyssey
    c) SAHA
    d) Kodocha
    e) Newtype

2. Best Distributor
    a) Bugrom
    b) Sachi's Distribution
    c)

3. Best Fan-translated Anime
    a) Fushigi Yuugi
    b) Berserk
    c) Tenshi No Narumon
    d)

4. Best Fan-edited Anime