| WON BY | WON FROM | LOCATION | DATE | COMMENTS |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wahoo McDaniel | R.C. Luv'n | 4/11/96 | Hillsville, VA | |
| Vladimir Koloff | Ricky Morton | 6/13/96 | Hillsville, VA | Tourny final. Title was held up 4/12. |
| Ricky Morton | Vladimir Koloff | 10/24/96 | Richmond, VA | |
| Roger Anderson | Jon Masters | 2/24/97 | Christiansburg, VA | Title held up that evening. Morton unable to defend. |
| Ricky Morton | Roger Anderson | 3/7/97 | Woodberry Forest, VA | |
| Vladimir Koloff | Ricky Morton | 6/22/97 | Fredericksburg, VA | |
| Demolition Ax | Vladimir Koloff | 2/19/98 | Fredericksburg, VA | |
| Lord Everett DeVore | Demolition Ax | 5/1/99 | Lynchburg, VA | |
| Honky Tonk Man | Lord Everett DeVore | 9/30/99 | Richmond, VA | |
| Mr. Big Stuff | Honky Tonk Man | 10/10/99 | Suffolk, VA | |
| Billy McCoy | Mr. Big Stuff | 11/6/99 | Elkhorn City, KY | The retired McCoy vacated the title after the match. |
| Mr. Big Stuff | Doink The Clown | 11/6/99 | Elkhorn City, KY | A Battle Royal determined the UCW champ.Stuff regained the title. |
| Honky Tonk Man | Mr. Big Stuff | 3/24/00 | Bealton, VA | |
| Sexsisto The Latin Lover | Honky Tonk Man | 3/25/00 | Mechanicsville, VA | |
| The Stro | Sexsisto The Latin Lover | 8/2/01 | Fredericksburg, VA | |
| Rev. Franklin V. Goode | The Stro | 10/7/01 | Suffolk, VA | |
| Neil Sharkey | Rev. Franklin V. Goode | 10/5/02 | Fredericksburg, VA | Goode put up the title in a Battle Royal. His manager Sharkey won. |
| Fatty McNasty | Neil Sharkey | 10/13/02 | Suffolk, VA | |
| Brock Singleton | Fatty McNasty | 7/24/03 | Richmond, VA | |
| Joey Matthews | Brock Singleton | 8/5/03 | Front Royal, VA | |
| Shane Shadows | Joey Matthews | 10/4/03 | Fredericksburg, VA | |
| The Barbarian | Shane Shadows | 10/11/03 | Amelia, VA | |
| Brock Singleton | The Barbarian | 10/12/03 | Massaponax, VA | |
| Elon Hull | Brock Singleton | 8/6/05 | Fredericksburg, VA | |
| Danny Waylon | Lion Woods | 8/10/06 | Front Royal, VA | Title vacated due to an injury to Elon Hull. |