August 15, 2006 -- OUR reform strategy, which we call "Children First,"
is premised on the core belief that strong school-level leadership will
result in high-functioning schools. Our aim is to accomplish three
fundamental cultural shifts:
* First, moving from a culture of excuses - where we blame our failure
on the kids, their parents or a lack of resources - to a culture of
accountability, where we take responsibility for the work we were hired
to do: educate all children in our charge.
Accountability starts at the top, with the mayor and me. In many ways,
placing the ultimate accountability at the top was a necessary first
step toward building an entire system that becomes infused with
accountability.
This September, all schools in our system will receive an annual
progress report with a grade of A, B, C, D or F based on student
progress as well as absolute achievement. In addition, all of our
schools will receive a qualitative review. Based on how well a school
does on these evaluations, we will make tough-minded decisions about
both replacing principals and closing schools.
* Second, moving from a culture of compliance to a culture of
performance: We recently had a group of 321 of our principals
voluntarily sign documents even though their own union told them not
to. These principals accepted the challenge and signed performance
agreements, taking responsibility for student performance outcomes.
Recognizing that real empowerment for school leaders involves providing
them with real resources and the authority to spend them as they see
fit, we are putting our money where our mouth is. Each empowerment
school has received for the upcoming school year an average of $250,000
more in discretionary spending.
In return, of course, our empowerment principals will be held to
demanding accountability standards. We will carefully monitor what's
going on at their schools and take action where necessary to be
successful.
* Third, moving from a culture of uniformity to a culture of
differentiation: We cannot continue to treat our employees as if they
were all the same. We need to start differentiating based on employee
talent and organizational need.
The civil-service system that forms the basis of public employment is
deeply entrenched and resistant to change. The basic pillars of that
system - life tenure, lock-step pay and seniority - essentially mean
that, whether you are good or bad or whether you work in a more
challenging or less challenging school or whether your are qualified to
teach in a hard-to-fill position like math or science, you get paid the
same, with differentiation based on length of service.
This structure means that talent tends to gravitate toward the
higher-performing schools and away from the more challenging ones. The
resulting maldistribution of human resources has real consequences for
our students.
Fortunately, we are beginning to change the culture of employee
uniformity. Our most recent agreement with the teachers' union puts an
end to the practice of teachers being able to insist on transferring
from one school to another based solely on their seniority.
In addition, we have begun the process of using pay to differentiate
our employees based on need and talent. We have a bonus program for
principals and assistant principals based on student performance. And
now, for the first time, we are able to offer generous signing bonuses
for experienced math, science and special education teachers.
These are important first steps toward work-force differentiation. But
make no mistake about it: We have a long road ahead of us. We need to
create a real meritocracy to replace the civil-service culture of
uniformity in public education. We need substantial merit pay, based on
student performance, and a system that enables us to remove
unsatisfactory employees.
The structures we are putting in place right now, and the culture
changes that are well under way, will, I believe, unleash the power and
potential of our public-education system.
Joel Klein is New York City schools chancellor. Adapted from a speech
at the Academy of Management in Atlanta on Sunday.