Abby Hutchinson Patton

Hutchinson Family Singers Web Site

[great Abby Hutchinson Patton photo]

Abby Patton

The Hutchinson brothers, in the fall of 1841, started on their first short concert tour; but they quickly got a sense that something was missing from their trio's vocal sound. Half a century later, John told a reporter that their sister Rhoda traveled with them to the towns nearest the family home in Milford, New Hampshire; and there is some reason to think that, on those occasions, they may have experimented with quartet performances. Unfortunately, Rhoda's health would not permit extensive traveling.

Soon after the new year came, on their way to a concert in Lynn, Massachusetts, the trio picked up their twelve-year-old sister Abby and brought her along for a visit to their older brother Jesse, Jr., who lived in that city. And since she just happened to be with them anyway - out from under their mother's protective wing - they arranged for her to sing with them at old Lyceum Hall on Wednesday, January 19, 1842. "Abby sang from her heart," said the Book of Brothers, "and her artless melodies, enhanced by the indescribable charm of her manner, found their way direct to the hearts of her auditors."

Since the Lynn concert with Abby worked out very well, the Hutchinson brothers took her along for the rest of the tour. Later, with some difficulty, they managed to gain parental permission - after the fact, of course - for adding their little sister to their company.

John and probably Jesse had heard the Rainer Family, a popular vocal group whose Boston concerts, late in the year 1840, were all the rage. And now, in their imaginations, Jesse and John could hear Abby's voice, blended with those of her brothers, creating an effect quite similar to the sound of these "Tyrolese Minstrels." Joshua, speaking of Abby's importance to the group's ensemble performances, said, "[S]he modulated her voice in the harmony perfected by her own sweet contralto. . . . "

The group's quartet singing was unusual for the day, with Judson generally taking the air and Abby singing above him. The Hutchinsons sang in close harmony, and they learned to achieve a remarkable balance between the four voices. The interplay between the singing of Judson and Abby seems to have been particularly important, and the quartet's press notices often focused on their vocal efforts.

It must have been tremendously exciting for Abby, a twelve-year-old farm girl, as she toured around the Northeast singing for popular audiences. Abby made the acquaintance of people from all different backgrounds; and in New York City in the spring of 1843, she met the love of her life, Ludlow Patton.

Abby was greatly admired for several of her solo numbers, "The May Queen" being a notable example; but much of her reputation was based on her performances of her brother Jesse's song, "The Slave's Appeal." Once the quartet started singing antislavery songs in their concerts, some audience members became unruly; and on several occasions when the Hutchinsons sang at antislavery conventions, mobs tried to break up the meetings. The group often faced unfriendly behavior, ranging from a little hissing all the way to serious threats of violence. Frank Carpenter, the artist and writer, knew Abby well. He said that, when she and her brothers sang their songs of freedom, Abby "would look directly into the eyes of the mob leaders, invariably with the effect of subduing the unruly spirits."

It may not be mere coincidence that Abby's time in the quartet corresponded almost exactly with the period of the group's greatest popularity.

In 1849, Abby married Ludlow Patton. A few months later, she became severely ill, and her condition was thought to be life-threatening. Abby's recovery was very slow; and a year later, she stopped going on concert tours mostly because of fragile health. She was down, but not out. We do not know exactly when Abby first learned of the movement cure, but it may have been shortly after it was introduced to the United States in the late 1850s. She had great faith in this innovative form of medical treatment, and we may guess with reasonable confidence that the movement cure was largely responsible for getting her back into various public activities.

Abby Circa 1860

Sister Abby composed her most popular music during her years of retirement from concert tours. Her song, "Kind Words Can Never Die," was perhaps the Hutchinson Family's most beloved and enduring original production.

In 1860, Abby traveled as part of John's company, and they campaigned for Abraham Lincoln throughout New York State. It is a tribute to how good Abby's health was, when it was at its best, that she did not falter even at this tiring pace. In 1863, she founded a kindergarten in Orange, New Jersey. After the war, Abby served on the Executive Committee of the American Equal Rights Association, and Ludlow was the Treasurer.

The Pattons were friends with fellow reformer Henry B. Blackwell, the husband of famed 19th-century feminist leader Lucy Stone. It's strange to say - and not at all a happy thing to say - that a biographer of Stone has reported that in 1869 Blackwell was romantically pursuing a "Mrs. P." The biographer went on to speculate that this Mrs. P may have been Abby Patton. Less cautious writers have since taken this thought and run with it, turning Blackwell's known pursuit of some unidentified Mrs. P into a consummated extramarital affair with Abby. That Blackwell had romantic intentions toward a woman other than his own wife seems beyond doubt, but how far his overtures got him is unknown. The identity of Mrs. P is also unknown. It is necessary to address this question because it came out in an important biographical work, but we mustn't get carried away with speculation based on evidence which is circumstantial at best.

Ludlow Patton retired from the New York Stock Exchange in 1873. After that, Abby and Ludlow became world travelers, a pursuit that lasted about ten years. "During that time," wrote Henry Whittemore in his Founders and Builders of the Oranges, "they visited nearly every portion of their own country, including the whole Pacific coast, from San Diego, to Sitka, Alaska; also every country in Europe except Lapland and Portugal, making, also, an extended tour of the whole north coast of Africa and up the river Nile to and above the first cataract, to the island of Philæ. They also visited Palestine, Syria and Asia Minor."  "Her husband," wrote artist, author, and friend Frank Carpenter, "was always a great lover of music, with a good tenor voice, and together they often entertained their many friends at their own home, or during their travels, with the old songs."

Ludlow Patton

Abby's last two public appearances came in 1892. That August when a statue of John P. Hale was unveiled in Concord, New Hampshire, the Hutchinsons were unexpectedly called on to sing a program of their songs of freedom. The impromptu and unrehearsed quartet that formed on that occasion was made up of John Hutchinson, Abby & Ludlow Patton, and their distinguished friend, Frederick Douglass. The last time Abby sang in public was in September at the funeral of the poet, John G. Whittier.

A few months later, Abby Hutchinson Patton died. According to the Milford Farmers' Cabinet, "[D]uring an acquaintance of years, we do not recall an instance where she gave utterance to a harsh criticism, or spoke an unkind word of any human being."

The Pattons' marriage did not produce any children. Yet, Abby and Ludlow were very supportive and nurturing, and they had many young people in their lives. Some of these children had stronger claims than others to being part of Abby's and Ludlow's family. Possibly no one had a stronger claim than Ludlow's adopted daughter, Helen Patton.

-- Alan Lewis, Revised October 23, 2002

* Abby's actual name was Abigail Jemima [née Hutchinson] Patton.


In the fall of 2004, The Revels, an acclaimed Boston musical and theatrical organization (best known for its annual Christmas Revels), started giving public performances of its latest and quite wonderful production, There's a Meeting Here Tonight!, which is based on the lives and careers of the Hutchinson Family singers. Follow this link for a review of the second-ever public staging of There's a Meeting Here Tonight! which took place right here in Brattleboro, Vermont:

Hutchinson Family

Since writing this profile, a great deal more information about Abby Hutchinson Patton, her family, and their descendants has come to light from census records as well as from a variety of other sources. My own research has concentrated mostly on members of the famous Hutchinson vocal group and their descendants, the singers' brothers and sisters and their descendants, and a number of the singers' friends, social reform colleagues, and even neighbors. It's doubtful, though, that I'll be posting my research findings on these pages anytime soon. It would be a huge undertaking, time is tight, and anyway I'm not sure just yet how I want to go about it.

What I've done so far includes adding the names of many people and places to the index that corresponds to individual Web pages. If your Internet search brought you to this Web site but you haven't found information you want, that could be why. Chances are excellent, though, that I'm interested in your topic and have at least some information about it but just haven't yet posted what I do have. I'm in contact with numerous other researchers, and some of them could be following the same lines of inquiry as you. Also, many Hutchinson family descendants have been in touch lately. So, if you've got questions or are interested in swapping information back and forth, please drop me a note by way of the Web page at

Alan Lewis,  July 20, 2004

I had finished and sealed my letter to you and was about to mail it, when Ludlow brought me a package from England. On opening it, my heart bounded, you may well believe. What do you suppose came before my eyes? The water color painting of the Hutchinson Family made by Margaret Gillies in her studio for our dear Mary Howitt in 1846. Some time ago I wrote Mary Howitt to know what had become of the painting, and now she has been so good as to send it to me. There we are, just as we stood in 1846, for our pictures. Our names are all written in our own handwriting, directly beneath the figures. The card is a little torn, but I think can be mended. I shall have it mounted at once, and put in complete order for framing. This will complete my list of pictures, which I am having prepared for printing. Cheer up; we will have a book yet.
Abby Patton to John Hutchinson, February 16, 1892, in John Hutchinson, Story of the Hutchinsons, 2 Vols. (Boston: Lee and Shepard, 1896), Volume 2 Page 385

So then, what became of the watercolor painting of the Hutchinson Family quartet? What became of Sister Abby's list of pictures? I, for one, have no idea. When one considers the vast amount of Hutchinson Family written material and memorabilia that has been preserved, it's startling to discover how much belonging to Abby has been lost or stolen.

A collection of Abby's letters to John's son, Henry J. Hutchinson, for instance, was stolen - not for the letters, but for the bag they were in. Later, Abby was collaborating with John on a project that, sadly, she did not live to see completed. She called it the "Hutchinson family memorial.' The final product is known today as Story of the Hutchinsons, and her contribution to it was substantial. The problem, though, concerns the main text. Abby and John had been working on the book together. Then in 1891, John discovered that much of the work - evidently hundreds of manuscript pages - could not be found.

The Frank Carpenter painting of Abby seems to be the only commonly-known likeness of her when she was in her twenties. Were there others? If there were, where are they?

There are, unfortunately, many more examples of Abby's documents and artifacts that have been lost or stolen. Some could be in private hands still; and this is the main reason I have tried hard to learn what became of Ludlow's step-daughter, Helen Patton. Meanwhile, if you can place any of the items listed here, or any other materials for that matter, please get in touch.

-- Alan Lewis, October 23, 2002

[earliest Hutchinson Family publicity likeness]
A navigation bar appears at or near the bottoms of pages.
New England Music Scrapbook

Copyright © 2000, 2002, 2004 by Alan Lewis.
All rights reserved.

E-Mail Us
Hutchinson Family Singers Home Page
Massachusetts, MA, Mass.; Minnesota, Minn., MN; New Hampshire, N. H., NH; New Jersey, N.J., NJ. Essex County, Hillsboro County, Hillsborough County, McLeod County. Lynn Massachusetts, Hutchinson Minnesota, Amherst New Hampshire, Milford New Hampshire, Mont Vernon New Hampshire, Orange New Jersey, City of New York City. Cellist, cello, fiddle, fiddler, melodeon player, violin, violinist, violoncello. Baptist, Christian Science, Christian Scientist, Congregational, Congregationalist, Methodist, Unitarian Universalist. The Book of Brothers, Carol Brink Harps in the Wind: The Story of the Singing Hutchinsons, Carol Ryrie Brink, Carol R Brink, Dale Cockrell Excelsior: Journals of the Hutchinson Family Singers 1842-1846, John Wallace Hutchinson Story of the Hutchinsons (Tribe of Jesse), Joshua Hutchinson A Brief Narrative of the Hutchinson Family, Philip Jordan, Philip Dillon Jordan, Philip D Jordan Singin Yankees, Phil Jordan, Ludlow Patton The Hutchinson Family Scrapbook. Index: Singing Yankees. LUDLOW PATTON FAMILY (extended): Treasurer of the History of Science Society (Wilson Ludlow Scott), Henry Loveridge of the Maryland Coal Company, Marietta Loveridge, Marietta Gray Loveridge, Marietta G Loveridge, Helen McKeever, Marion McKeever, Marion L McKeever, Marion Loveridge McKeever, William McKeever, William D McKeever, Neale Watson Academic Publications Inc. (Wilson Ludlow Scott), Abby Patton, Abigail Jemima Hutchinson Patton, Marion Patton, Marion Loveridge Patton, Marion L Patton, Betsy Saunders, Betsy Hobson Scott Saunders, Betsy Scott Saunders, Annie Scott, Annie L Scott (evidently 2nd Mrs. Henry Wilson Scott), Daniel Scott, Ethelind Scott, Ethelind Wade Scott (1st Mrs Wilson Ludlow Scott), Henry Scott, Henry Wilson Scott, Henry W Scott, H W Scott, John Scott, John Ludlow Patton Scott, John Ludlow Scott, John Patton Scott, John L P Scott, John P Scott, John W L Scott, John Wilson Scott, John L Scott, John W Scott, Lucian Scott, Lucius Scott, Margaret Scott, Margaret Koehler Scott (2nd Mrs Wilson Ludlow Scott), Wilson Scott, Wilson Ludlow Patton Scott, Wilson L P Scott, Wilson Ludlow Scott, Wilson L Scott, Arthur Taylor, Arthur Wellesley Taylor, Arthur W Taylor, Helen Patton Taylor, Washington Times-Herald newspaper (Wilson Ludlow Scott). HARRIET WILSON: Harriet Adams, Harriet Eveline Adams, Harriet E Adams, Mrs Harriet Adams Wilson, Mrs Harriet A Wilson, Mrs Harriet E Wilson. "Our Nig; or, Sketches From the Life of a Free Black in a Two-Story White House, North. Showing That Slavery's Shadows Fall Even There." By "Our Nig." Boston: Geo. C. Rand and Avery, 1859. Index: Abraham Avery, Calvin Dascomb Sr, Calvin Dascomb Senior, Nancy Hayward, Nancy A Hayward, George Rand, George Curtis Rand, George C Rand. Laura Gordon, Laura de Force Gordon, Laura Deforce Gordon, Laura D Gordon, Rowena Steele, Rowena Granice Steele, Rowena G Steele. 45 Linden Place, Orange, New Jersey 45 Linden Pl, Orange, NJ 31 West 16th Street, New York City 31 W 16th St, New York, NY 31 West Sixteenth Street, New York City 33 West 16th Street, New York City 33 W 16th St, New York, NY 33 West Sixteenth Street, New York City Theodore Marsh, Theodore McCurdy Marsh, Theodore McC Marsh, Theodore M Marsh, T M Marsh. Elaine Strunk, Elaine Taylor Strunk, Elaine T Strunk, F Thelma Taylor, Thelma O Taylor. 1825, 1829, 1860, 1870, 1880, 1890, 1892, 1900, 1906. Birth, born, death, died, divorce, divorced, maiden, marriage, married, single, unmarried. Ancestry,, the Boston Globe, family history, genealogy. Abolition, abolitionism, abolitionist, anniversary, anti-slavery, antislavery, audience, band, biography, chorus, church, the Civil War, company, compose, composer, composition, concert, convention, entertain, entertainment, folk music, folk songs, folksongs, group, harmony, Hutchison, instrument, instrumental, lyricist, lyrics, meeting, musician, N E, NE, NEMS, New England Music Scrapbook, Northeast, Northeastern, the Old Granite State, practice, profile, program, quartet, rehearsal, rehearse, religious left, repertoire, research, the Revels' Circle of Song, show, singer, social reform, social reformer, song writer, songwriter, stage, equal suffrage, suffragette, equal suffragist, impartial suffrage, impartial suffragist, temperance, tour, the Tribe of Jesse, trio, troupe, verse, vocal, vocalist, woman's rights, women's rights, words. Henry Blackwell, Henry Brown Blackwell, Francis Carpenter, Francis B Carpenter, Francis Bicknell Carpenter, Frank B Carpenter, Abby Hutchinson, Abby J Hutchinson, Abigail J Hutchinson, Henry J Hutchinson, Nashua New Hampshire, New England Music Scrapbook, New York N Y NY, New York City N Y C NYC, Abby Hutchinson Patton (1829-1892), Charles Prew, Charles H Prew, Charles Prue, Charles H Prue, the Revels' Circle of Song, Roseville New Jersey, Swedish Movement Cure, Dr Taylor's Movement Cure Institute, Dr Taylor's Improved Movement Cure Institute, Dr George Henry Taylor, Dr George Taylor, Dr George Herbert Taylor, Dr George H Taylor, John Whittier, John Greenleaf Whittier, John G Whittier. Abby Hutchinson Patton