Top 10 Desert island Discs:

Pet Sounds -- Beach Boys
Rubber Soul -- Beatles
20 -- Harry Connick, Jr.
Severe Tire Damage -- They Might Be Giants
Little Earthquakes -- Tori Amos
Blood and Chocolate -- Elvis Costello
Brahms: Cello Sonatas -- Jacueline du Pré and Daniel Barenboim
Grace -- Jeff Buckley
Surfacing -- Sarah McLachlan
Parallel Lines -- Blondie

*I have no affiliation with amazon.com, they are merely a good reference tool.