UNIVERSITY OF THE
College of the
Faculty of Law
LA
30B - EMPLOYMENT LAW
Worksheet No.
1
Who is an Employee? The Tests of Employment
THE CONTRACT OF SERVICE AND THE CONTRACT FOR SERVICES
The Control Test
Yewens v Noakes (1880) QBD 530
Gibb v. United Steel Co. [1957] 2 All E.R. 110
Inadequacy of the Control Test
Walter v Crystal Palace Football Club [1910] 1 KB 87
Short v Henderson [1946] 174 LT 417
Organisation Test
Stevenson...v MacDonald [1952] 1 LR 101
Smith v Griffith [1974] 22 WIR 5.
Multiple Test
Ready Mixed Concrete v Minister of Pensions (1968) 2 QB 497
Economic Reality Test
Market Investigations v Ministry of Social Security [1969] 2 QB 173
Wieting and Richter v Paul (unrep) Civ. App. No. 120 of 1968
(
Rudder v Dallaway (1984) 38 WIR 56
Lee v Chung [1990] IRLR 236
Lane v Shire Roofing Co. [1995] IRLR 493
McMeechan v Secretary of State [1997] ICR 549
Elementary Law Approach
American Life v N.A. B. (Unrep.) Case No. 21 of 1983 (
Withers v Flackwell [1981] IRLR 307
-2-
Intention Approach
Ferguson v Dawson [1976] 1 WLR 1213
Massey v Crown Life Ins. [1978] ICR 590
Obligation Test
O’Kelly v Trusthouse Forte [1983] IRLR 369
Wickens v Champion [1984] ICR 365
Nethermere v Taverna [1984] ICR 612
Cheng v Royal Hong Kong Club [1998] ICR 131
Clarke v Oxfordshire Health Authority [1998] IRLR 125
Express v Tanton [1999] ICR 693
Costain Bldg. v. Smith [2000] 215
MONOGRAPH
R.L. Chaudhary Contract
of Service and the Worker in a
ARTICLES
bacchus, rahim “Distinguishing the Contract of Service from the Contract
for Services: from control to economic reality”.
Commonwealth
and P.K. Menon
bacchus, rahim “Globalisation and the Labour Agenda” 9(2) Carib LR 163 (1999)
bacchus, rahim “The Control Test” WILJ (25th Anniv. Issue), 106 (1998)
bacchus, rahim “The Mutuality of Obligations Test” WILJ (25th Anniv. Issue), 110 (1998)
Collins, H. Market Power, Bureaucracy and the Contract of Employment
(1986) 15 ILJ 1.
Hepple, B. Restructuring Employment Rights (1986) 15 ILJ 69
-3-
Khan - Frennd, O. “Servants and Independent Contractors” (1951) 14 MLR 504
Rear, J. Self employment in the Building Industry (1972) 2 (2) Hong Kong L.J. 150.
Russell, Peter “The Lump and Safety” (1977) 40 MLR 479
Winder, W.H.D. “The Contract of Service” (1964) 80 LQR 160
TOPIC FOR DISCUSSION
Given the nature of modern employment relationship, which of the tests, if any, is best suited in determining whether one is an employee or is self employed?
September, 2002
UNIVERSITY OF THE
College of the
Faculty of Law
LA 30B - EMPLOYMENT LAW Worksheet No. 2
SEMESTER I
- 2001/2002
Who is an Employee? - Special employment
situations
APPRENTICES
Dunk v Waller (1970) 2 QB 163
North East Coast Ship Repairers v Sect. Of State [1978] IRLR
149
Wallace v
Edmunds v Lawson (2000) IRLR 391
OFFICE HOLDERS
Great Western Railway Co. v. Bater (1920) 3 KB 268
102 Social Club v. Bickerton (1977) ICR 911
Police
AG for New South Wales v Perpetual Trustee [1955] AC 457
Ridge v
Teachers
University Council of the Vidyodaya University of Ceylon v Silva [1965] 1 WLR 77 CPC
Mallock v Aberdeen Corp. [1971] 1 WLR 1578
Judge
Rees v Crane (1994) 43 WIR 444
General Civil Servant
Kodeeswaran v AG of
Thomas v AG [182] Ac 113 (PC)
AG of T & T v Toby 27 WIR 266
Rent Officer
Johnson v Ryan [2000] ICR 236
-2-
CLERK
President of the Methodist Conference v Parfitt (1984) ICR 177 (CA)
Davies v Presbyterian Church (1986) ICR 280 (HL)
Samtokh Singh v Guru Namak Gurdware (1990) ICR 309 (CA)
Gatherer v Gomez (1992) 41 WIR 68 (PC)
Diocese of Southwark v. Coker [1998] ICR 142
COMPANY DIRECTORS
Lee v Lee’s Air Farming (196l) AC 12 PC
Parsons v Albert Parsons [1979] ICR 271
Eaton v Robert Easton [1988] ICR 302
NIB v Walke (1992) 45 WIR 35
Sect. of State.... Trade v. Bottrill [1999] ICR 593 (CA)
Smith v Sect. of State .... [2000] ICR 69
PARTNERS
Cowell v Goodison [1989] IRLR 392
Eastdown v Cobb [1940] 1 ALL ER 49 CHL
CO-OPERATIVES
Drym Fabricators Ltd. v. Johnson [1981] ICR 274
TOPICS FOR DISCUSSION
(1) To what extent and under what circumstances may office holders be regarded as employees?
(2) Should apprentices and priests be categorized as employees, given their current methods of “Employment”?
September, 2002
UNIVERSITY OF THE
College of the
Faculty of Law
LA 30B - EMPLOYMENT LAW Worksheet No. 3
IMPLIED TERMS
METHODOLOGY OF IMPLYING TERMS
The Moorcock (1889) 14 PD 64
Shirlaw v Southern Foundaries Ltd. (1939) 2 KB 206
Luxor v Cooper [1941] AC 108
Mears v Safecar Security [1982] IRLR 183
Sagar v Ridehalgh [1931] 1
EMPLOYER’S DUTIES
Duty to pay wages
Mears v Safecar [1982] IRLR 183
Haley v Pease & Partners Ltd. [1915] 1 KB 698
Devonald v Rosser [1906] 2 KB 728
Browning v Crumlin Valley Colleriers [1926] 1 KB 522
Duty to provide work ?
Turner v Sawdon [1901] 2 KB 653
Collier v Sunday Referee Publishing Co. [1940] 2 KB 647
Breach v Epsylon Industries [1976] IRLR 180
Langston v AUEW [1974] IRLR 182
Duty of Care
Johnstone v Bloombury Health Authority [1991] IRLR 118
Spring v Guardian Assurance [1994] IRLR 460
Bartholomew v
Walker v Northumberland CC [1995] ICR 702
Scally v Southern Health ... Board [1999] ICR 771
University of Nottingham v Eyett [1999] ICR 721
TSB Bank v Harris [2000] IRLR 157
Duty to Cooperate
Isle of Wright Tourist Board v. Coombes [1976] IRLR 413
-2-
EMPLOYEE’S DUTIES
Duty to Obey Reasonable Orders
Laws v.
O’Brian v Associated Fire Alarms [1968] 1 WLR 1916
Morrish v Henlys [1973] 2 Al E.R. 137
Cresswell v Board of Inland Revenue [1989] ICR 508
Macari v Celtic Football [1999] IRLR 787
Duty of Fidelity
Reading v A.G. [1951] AC 507
Bell v Lever Brothers Ltd. [1932] AC 161
Sybron Corp. V. Rochem [1983] IRLR 253
Hivac Ltd. V Park Royal [1946] 1 Ch 169
Wessex Dairies v Smith [1935] 2 KB 80
Robb v Green [1895] 2 QB 315
Faccenda Chicken v Fowler [1986] IRLR 69
Littlewoods Organisation v Harris [1977] 1 WLR 1472
FSS Travel v Johnson (1998) IRLR 445
Sect. of State... V A.S.R. E. F. (No.2) [1972] 2 QB 455
British Telecommunication v Ticehurst [1992] ICR 383
Duty of Care
Lister v Romford Ice [1957] AC 555
Mutual Duty to Maintain Trust and Confidence
Robinson v Crompton Parkinson [1978] ICR 40
Post Office v Roberts [1980] ICR 347
Woods v W M Car Services [1981] ICR 666
Lewis v Motorworld Garages [1986] ICR 157
Malik v Bank of Credit.... [1997] 3 WLR 95
Nottingham University v Eyett [1999] ICR 721
Neary & Neary v Westminister [1999] IRLR 288
Bank of Credit.. V Ali [1999] ICR 1068
TSB Bank v Haris [2000] IRLR 157
Macari v Celtic Football [1999] IRLR 787
Johnson v Unisys [1999] IRLR 90
UNIVERSITY OF THE
College of the
Faculty of Law
EMPLOYMENT LAW Worksheet No. 4
COLLECTIVE AGREEMENT AS A TERM OF THE
CONTRACT
Legal Effect of a Collective Agreement Generally
Loman & Henderson v Merseyside Transport Services Ltd.
(1968) 3 ITR 108
Ford Motor Co. Ltd. V. AUEFW
(1969) I WLR 339
Shipping Association v Hayden [1976] 22 WIR 135
Methods of Incorporating the Collective Agreement into the Contract of
Employment
Expressed Incorporation
Robertson v British Gas [1983] ICR 315
Marley v Forward Trust [1986] ICR 891
Cadoux v Central Regional Council [1986] IRLR 131
Trade Union as Agent of the Employee
Burton Group v Smith [1977] ITR 351
Lee v GEC Plessy [1993] IRLR 383
Singh v British Steel [1974] IRLR 31
London Transport v Moserop [1942] AC 332
Land & Wilson v West Yorkshire [1979] IRLR 174
Implied Incorporation
Joel v Cammel Laird [1969] ITR 206
Hamilton v Fuura Floors [1990 IRLR 478
Mordear v Jacob Beatus [1975] IRLR 170
Nelson v Post Office [1978] IRLR 548
-2-
Challenges to Enforceability once Incorporated
Consideration
Lee v GEC Plessy [1993] IRLR 383
Intention
Young v Canadian Northern Railway (1931) AC 83 P.C.
Edwards v Skyways [1964] 1 WLR 349
Conflicting Agreements
Cift v West Ridging cc [1964] Times 10
Apal Gas Col. Conversion v Merces [1974] ICR 420
Date of Agreement
Leyland Vehicles v Peston [1981] IRLR 19
What Terms are Incorporated
Sewell v Neptune Concrete [1975] IRLR 245
Lack of Clarity of Terms
Inappropriateness of Terms
Associated Newspaper v Wade [1979] IRLR 664 CA
Gallagher v The Post Office [1970 3 All ER 712
British Leyalnd v McQuilken [1978] IRLR 245
Tadd v Eastwood [1983] IRLR 320
National Coal Board v NUM [1986] IRLR 439
Griffiths v Buckinghamshire cc [1994] ICR 265 cf
Grant v South-West Trains Ltd. [1998] 188
Wandsworth London Borough Council v D’Silva [1998] IRLR 193
September, 2002
UNIVERSITY OF THE
College of the
Faculty of Law
LA 30B - EMPLOYMENT LAW Worksheet No. 5
STATUTORY TERMS AND CONDITIONS
This Act repealed the Employment of Women, Young Persons and Children Act and provides for the conditions under which such person may be employed in an undertaking as defined by the Act.
Occupational Training Act - Cap
42
This Act established a body corporation, the National Training Board (now called the vocational Training Board) which in part regulates the terms of contracts of apprentices.
Recruiting of Workers Act - Cap 354
This Act provides for the licensing of person who recruits workers and states that certain obligations are binding on the person so recruiting.
Civil Establishment Act - Cap 21
This Act empowers the Minister to establish “offices” in
the public service.
Casual Employees Pensions Ac -
Cap 21
This act provides for the payment of pensions and gratuities to persons employed in the public service on a casual basis.
Employment of Women (Maternity Leave) Act Cap 345A
This Act states that women are entitled to maternity leave under certain conditions.
National Insurance and Social
Security Act - Cap 47
This Act provides for compulsory contribution by employer and employee to a Insurance Scheme and provides certain benefits to employees such as sickness benefit, maternity benefit, etc.
Domestic Employees Act - Cap 344
This Act provides for the minimum wage payable and maximum number of hours of work of domestic employees.
Protection of Wages Act - Cap 351
This Act provides the form, manner, time and place where wages may or may not be paid to employees, and prohibits contractual deductions for bad work among other things.
Sugar Workers (Minimum Wage and Guaranteed Employment) Act - Cap 359
This Act empowers Cabinet to prescribe the minimum wage for sugar workers and guaranteed number of hours work to be provided. I also provides that an apprentice shall not be required to pay a premium.
Trade Union Act - Cap 361
Section 40 A of this Act protects an employee from dismissal due to lawful trade union membership or activities.
Better Security Act - Cap 160
This Act restricts workers employed in water, gas and electricity services from wilfully and maliciously breaking their contracts.
Severance payment Act - Cap 355 A
This Act provides for workers who are made redundant to receive severance payments. Section 45 of the Act also provides for the measure of damage to be applied in a wrongful dismissal decision by a court.
Public Holidays Act - Cap 352
This Act prohibits the opening of business on Public holidays but also provides for exemptions
Shop - Act - Cap 356 A
This Act provides in part for the number of working hours for shop assistants, mealtime leave and overtime pay and for other conditions of employment in respect of comfort and safety.
Radiation Protection Act -
Cap 353 A
This Act provides for the safety of workers from ionizing radiation.
Quarries Act - Cap 353 A
This Act provides in part of the safety of workers in quarries
Accident and Occupational Disease (Notification) Act - Cap 338
This Act provides for the employer reporting accidents arising out of the course of employment
Factories Act - Cap 347
This Act provides for the safety, health and welfare of factory workers.
September 2002
UNIVERSITY OF THE WEST INDIES
College of the Bahamas
Faculty of Law
LA 30B - EMPLOYMENT LAW Worksheet No. 6
TERMINATION OF THE CONTRACT OF EMPLOYMENT
Implied Notice
Warren v Super Drug Markets [1966] 54 DLR (2d) 183
BG Credit Corp. V. Da Silva (
) 7 WIR 530
Fuller v Rever Jamaica Alumina (1980) 31 WIR 304
Waite v Caribbean Int. Airways (1987) 39 WIR 61
T & K Home Improvements v. Hilton [2000] IRLR 593
Reasonable Notice vs Just Cause
Barbados Plastics v Taylor (1981) 16 Bar LR 79 (CA)
Andre Scholar v Hess Oil St. Lucia, Unreported H.C., St. Lucia, Suit No. 149 of 1984.
Decided 03-07-87
Grosvenor v Advocate Co. Unreported, Barbados H.C. No. 29 of
199.
Decided Sept 93 - Dec. 94
Correia Jewllery v Forde Unreported. C.A. Barbados. Decided 19-09-92
Clarke v Nathu C. A. Barbados No. 16 of 1992. Decided 07-09-92
From Year to Year
Henderson v Henderson (1959) 1 WIR 337
Frustration - Sickness
Morgan v Mauser [1947] 2 All ER 666
Williams v Wason.. [1990] IRLR 164
Villela v MFI Furniture {1999] IRLR 468
Frustration - imprisonment
Shepherd Ltd. v Jerron [1986] IRLR
Suspension
Gogay v Herfordshire cc [1999] IRLR 703
-2-
Mutual Agreement
Birch v University of Liverpool [1985] IRLR 165
Igbo v Johnson Matthey Chemical [1986] IRLR 215
Hellyer Ltd. V Atkinson & Dickinson [1994] IRLR 88
Fixed term, contingent and ‘task’ contracts
Wilshire L.C. v Natfhe [1980] IRLR 198
Brown v Knowsley BC [1986] IRLR 102
Dixon v BBC [1979] ICR 281 CA
Constructive Dismissal
Western Excavating v Sharp [1978] QB 761
Sovereign House Security v Savage [1989] IRLR 115 CA
Tanner v Kean [1978] IRLR 160
Woods v W M Car Services [1981] ICR 666
Edwards v Survey Police [1997] IRLR 456
Conduct justifying resignation
Bracebridge Engineering v Darby [1990] IRLR 3
Hilton Int. V Protopapa [1990] IRLR 316
Palmanor v Cedron [1978] IRLR 303
United Bank Ltd. v Akhtar [1989] IRLR 507
White v Reflecting Road Study [1991] IRLR 331
Dryden v Greater Glasgo HB (1992) IRLR 469
Acceptance of repudiation?
Thomas Marshall v Guinle [1979] Ch 277
London Transp. v Clarke [1981] ICR 335 (CA)
Rigby v Ferodo [1988] ICR 29 (HL)
Lewis v Motorworld [1986] ICR 157
-3-
Misconduct justifying dismissal
Pepper v Web [1969] 2 All ER 216
Wilson v Racher [1974] IRL 114 (CA)
Denco Ltd. V Joinson (1991) IRLR 63
Rouse v Mendoza (1968 12 WIR 1
Lashley v Bayley (1992) 44 WIR 44
Gulstone v Anchor Life (1976) 27 WIR 68
Neary & Neary v Dean of Westminister (1999) IRLR 288
Montserrat Electricity v Latour (1989) 33 WIR 108 cf. With
Continent Biscuits v Shanks (1977) 24 WIR 267
Skinner Drilling v Hill (1962) 4 WIR 267
Harris v DaCosta & Musson (1979) 34 WIR 55
Damages
Bliss v South East Thomas RHA (1987) ICR 700 (CA)
Shove v Downs Surgical [1984 ICR 532
Cererns Software v Rowley (1999) IRLR 690
EMI Group v Coldicott [1999] IRLR 630
Raspn v Limited News [1999] IRLR 9
Johnson v Unisys (1999) IRLR 90
Injunction & Specific Performance
Irani v. Southhampton. [1985] IRLR 203
Power v Brent LBC [1988] ICR 176 CA
Wadcock v London Borough of .. [1990] IRLR 223
Robb v London Borough of... [1991] IRLR 72
ICS v Hart [2000] IRLR 227
Hollis & Co. v Stocks [2000] IRLR 712
Wincanton Ltd. Granny [200] IRLR 716
Peace v City of Edinburg Council [1999] IRLR 417
William Hill Org. v Tucker [1999] ICR 291
Judicial Review
R v East Berkshire HA [1984] IRLR 27
R v Broxtowe Borough Council [2000] IRLR 329
September, 2002