|
There are dozens of different commodities, everything from food products
to financial instruments. They come in different delivery months (the contract’s
expiration date); amounts (bushels, pounds, ounces, dollars, etc.); minimum
price (which moves between trades); and daily trading limits (it can only
go up or down a certain amount each trading day).
How did all
this get started?
Futures contracts were originally used by farmers and buyers of farm products
to even out the big price swings in the underlying commodity. Futures contracts
satisfied both sides. Companies needed to lock in the price for the corn
they used to make corn flakes. At the same time, the farmer slept better
knowing what he’d get for his corn before it even sprouted.
Over time, investors developed hundreds of complex trading strategies that
have nothing to do with farming or food. There are now contracts for more
than 400 different products or financial instruments trading on some 60
exchanges around the world. Everything — from the price of Japanese yen
to the interest rate on a 30-year Treasury bond to the S&P 500 stock
index — is traded. If it goes up and down in price, you can probably find
someone who can trade it.
Can I afford this?
Good question: Commodities trading is not where you want to put the rent
money or your kid’s college savings. Due the relatively low initial capital
requirement, it can make or break you in a relatively shorter time than
other place such as the New York Stock Exchange. Unless you can afford
to lose it all, stay away from futures. And even if you’re wealthy, most
financial advisers suggest limiting Commodity Futures market investment
to 10 percent of your net worth.
Once you’ve decided how much you can wager, you need to look at the margin
requirement, which is the amount of cash you actually have to come up with
for a given investment. Part of what makes this such a high-performance
investment is “leverage” — with a small bet, you control a lot of an investment,
but you still have to keep a minimum balance to stay in the game. If your
investments go down, you may have to put up more money to stay in the game.
Or be forced to sell off everything at a loss.
One more time: leverage
Leverage is what happens when one side of the seesaw is longer than the
other: A small move on one side makes a big move on the other. In futures
trading, the lever is the small amount of money you need to control big
price moves of the underlaying makrets you’re investing in.
Example: As a stock investor, you can buy $10,000 worth of stock with only
$5,000 in cash, and the rest on margin, in the form of a loan from your
broker. If your stock doubles in value to $20,000, you make four times
your $5,000 investment (minus any amounts you owe your broker).
Leverage in the futures market is even bigger. Say you bought $10,000 worth
of gold futures for, say, $500. If the value of that gold doubles to $20,000,
now you’ve made 40 times your $500 investment (minus any money you owe
your broker).
That’s why commodities traders can lose so many times and still keep coming
back for more. Even if you bet right only 30 percent of the time, as long
as those bets are big enough, you’ll make back your money and then some.
But that leverage comes with a price. With stocks, the worst you can lose
is your initial investment. But if you buy a futures contract, you’re agreeing
to buy a certain amount of the underlying commodity or financial instrument
at a fixed price, no matter what. If you buy a contract to purchase $10,000
worth of gold and gold prices drop in half, you’ve got to come up with
the difference (that’s called “marking to market”). So you will have lost
10 times your initial $500 investment.
Why consider such risky things?
One reason is the old saw about not keeping all your eggs in one basket.
Stocks and commodities usually march to different drummers, so many investors
use them as a hedge. In 1987, for example, when the stock market struggled
to stay in positive territory, managed futures accounts rose 57 percent.
Second, some investors like the relative simplicity of the factors that
affect futures prices. Commodities tend to move on big market forces, like
weather, inflation or political upheaval. While unpredictable, these trends
are sometimes easier to spot than trouble in a corporate balance sheet
or troubling legalese in a bond covenant. And, unlike stocks, where everyone
loses, there’s always a winner in futures contracts.
Just you and a quote machine?
You don’t have to be attached by the hip to a quote machine, because not
all commodities have the same volatility. Unless you are a day trader,
moving in and out of contracts in a matter of hours, you’ll want to look
for commodities where prices tend to swing over time. Bond futures, for
example, have plenty of short-term ups and downs, but over the longer term,
they track trends in interest rates. Look at recent trading patterns of
various commodities before you invest. The contracts with smaller price
swings may have a lower payoff, but they are easier to keep an eye on outside
the trading pits.
For starters, stick to one or two contracts. It’s hard to keep up with
more than one commodity at a time. And if you want to test the waters,
try “paper trading” a few contracts and see how you do.
If you are not a guy to shot from the hip...
If you prefer to invest in something you can research, there’s plenty
of opportunity to study commodities investments, even if many of the forces
that move prices are unpredictable. There are two basic methods for deciding
when to buy and sell — technical and fundamental.
Technical analysis of the market is based on trading patterns over time
that seem to repeat themselves. So technical analysts spend a great deal
of time analyzing charts, looking for patterns that may indicate which
way the market is headed.
Fundamental analysis deals with news events or forces that affect supply
and demand, like weather, inflation, political turmoil, etc. Prices also
tend to trade in ranges — sometimes as a result of seasonal factors.
One key piece of fundamental data: government reports. The USDA, for example,
puts out volumes of data on the size of the nation’s cattle herds or how
many hogs are headed to market in a given week. All of this ultimately
affects how much ground round will cost at the supermarket and how much
your beef is worth.
Time to unload
OK, so you get your hands on the Hogs and Pigs Report and you’ve been
“paper trading” like I suggested. You just made $40,000 in 23 minutes.
Where do you unload all these pork bellies?
Good question. It’s one you’ll care a lot more about when you start using
real money. First, you want to sell your contract before it expires.
To be sure you can get out, you want to be in a market with plenty of “liquidity”
— plenty of active buyers and sellers. Because even if you have a winning
hand on paper, if you can’t find a buyer — before the market moves against
you — you’ll have only bragging rights and no profits. To find a liquid
market, look in the paper at the number of contracts outstanding for a
particular contract. Usually, the more volume in a given contract, the
greater the liquidity.
Quick! My broker’s on the phone
Now what do you do? Take a deep breath. Decide which commodity you want
to trade; whether you want to buy or sell (do you think the price is going
up or down?); how many contracts you want; at what price you want to trade;
and how long you want to give your broker to fill the order. Some common
types of orders are:
Market order: (or “at the market”) means you’ll buy or sell at the
current price. It’s a good way to make a quick trade, but it may not be
the most reliable — especially in a fast-moving market.
Limit order: means you’ll buy or sell only at a specific price. While
you have a better idea what you’re getting into, the trade won’t go through
if the market never reaches the price you specify.
Stop limit order: This allows you to specify a range of prices that
you’d like to execute for a trade. If the trade doesn’t go through at the
specified stop price, your broker will keep trying as long as the market
stays within the specified range.
Spread order: This is a popular hedging strategy that involves simultaneously
buying one contract and selling another, with a given range of prices between
them. Here you care only whether the spread widens or narrows the way you
want, regardless of the underlying prices.
For example, you might buy a November wheat contract and sell a July wheat
contract, hoping that the spread narrows over time. As long as you gain
more on one transaction than you lose on the other, you’re ahead of the
game. Traders look for all kinds of spreads “ between contract dates, between
one market and another, between a currency and interest rates, etc.
Fill or kill: Just like it sounds: Fill it right away or not at all.
In a fast-moving market, this limits the risk that the trade will go through
at a vastly different price than you wanted.
Can I trust the pit?
You’re wondering about all that shouting and arm-waving in the trading
pits, and the possibility that someone will make a mistake, causing your
order to go awry. Don’t worry too much. Orders over the phone are almost
always tape recorded, so later if there’s a dispute, there’s a record.
If the trade isn’t what you asked for, you can dispute it. The exact procedure
is spelled out in the agreement you sign when you open an account.
Pros and cons of commodity funds and pools.
You may want to look into a commodity fund, a kind of mutual fund for commodities
investors. As in mutual funds, you’re buying the expertise of the manager
or managers who are making specific buy and sell decisions. And, from most
of the larger brokerage houses, you’ll get a monthly statement showing
where your money is going. But there are important differences: One is
that the fees for commodity funds are typically higher than for mutual
funds.
One big benefit is that only the money you’ve invested is at risk. Even
if your fund is completely wiped out, you won’t hear from a broker looking
for you to put up more money.
Commodity pools are similar to funds, but there are key differences. One
is the price of entry: Usually you need a minimum of $10,000 or $25,000
to get into a pool. Another is fees: On a percentage basis, fees tend to
be lower for commodity funds than pools.
Let the broker do the work
Can’t I just find a broker and let her trade for me? Sure, but you’ll
probably have to play with the high rollers.
Most advisers are looking for accounts of $100,000 or more. You’ll pay
a fee for each trade, much like a commission on stock transactions, and
an advisory fee based on how well your account performs. And unlike with
a fund, you’re at risk for more than just your investment: If the market
turns against you, you have to come up with more than you originally put
up. (Obviously, that’s not what your adviser has in mind, so many accounts
stay less than fully invested to provide a cash cushion for market downturns.)
You’ll also want to make sure the adviser is registered with the Commodities
Futures Trading Commission, the federal agency that regulates the commodities
markets.
|
|