With Positive Calls to Love and Freedom
Introduction
During a U.S. House of Representatives session in 1999, members of Congress were arguing the merits of allowing schools to post a copy of the Ten Commandments in public school classrooms. During the argument, one Representative demanded to know "whose Ten Commandments" would be posted: the Catholic, Protestant, or Jewish? While all three agree on the Scriptures involved, there are minor differences in grouping. This page does not take a position on whether the commandments should be posted or judge who is following them. They are merely posted with a few thoughts on each.
The Ten Commandments (also called the Decalogue) were given to Moses, the great leader of the Hebrews, over 3,000 years ago after the Hebrews were delivered from slavery in Egypt. While the Law of Moses is made up of over 600 rules, the Ten Commandments were a succinct list of rules from which the others were developed. They are recorded in two chapters of the Hebrew Scriptures (specifically the Pentateuch): Exodus 20 and Deuteronomy 5.
When Jesus was asked, "What must I do to inherit eternal life?", he replied: "You know the Commandments, keep these and you will live." For now, just notice that Jesus attests to the importance of the Ten Commandments. This is why Christians and Jews accept them.
The Jewish tradition (according to Scripture) viewed the Law as a gift from God, not an option or curse. Christian tradition views sin as enslavement rather than something fun we are denied. To accept salvation is to be freed from slavery to sin and raised to a new life. In the table below, you can see the commandments and how they free us from sin and free us for a new life.
Catholic Version
The Commandment |
The Call |
Action |
|
1 |
I am the LORD your God, you shall have no other gods before me. | Faith (Trust in God) |
All faith in God, freedom from lesser gods: wealth, sex, power, popularity. |
2 |
You shall not take the Name of the LORD your God in vain. | Respect Holiness |
Respect for God and the things of God: prayer, worship, religion. |
3 |
Keep holy the Sabbath day. | Renewal |
Not just the Sabbath rest, but setting aside time for prayer, good recreation, quiet reflection. |
4 |
Honor your father and your mother. | Family |
Loving care and respect for all family members, elders and younger siblings, too. Respect for elders in general. |
5 |
You shall not kill. | Respect For Life |
Courtesy to all, speaking respectfully to all, seeking the best for all. Respecting others' freedom while still defending all human life. |
6 |
You shall not commit adultery. | Chastity Faithfulness (Fidelity) |
Faithful actions beyond just abstaining from sexual contact outside of marriage. Respect for sex and marriage. |
7 |
You shall not steal. | Justice (Honesty) |
Concern for the rights of others, especially when they get in the way of what we desire. A commitment to fairness and a willingness to suffer loss rather than depriving another. |
8 |
You shall not bear false witness. | Truth |
A dedication to what is real and true, even if that reality is against our interests. |
9 |
You shall not covet your neighbor's wife. | Purity |
A desire to want only what God wills. A single-hearted devotion to God's way. |
10 |
You shall not covet your neighbor's goods. | Generosity |
A cooperation in God's own generosity that sees all goods as belonging to God and freely given for the good of all. |
The Ten Commandments are found in the Catechism of the Catholic Church in the section on living the Christian life (2052 - 2557).
Protestant Version
The Commandment |
The Call |
Action |
|
1 |
I am the LORD your God, you shall have no other gods before me. | Faith (Trust in God) |
All faith in God, freedom from lesser gods: wealth, sex, power, popularity. |
2 |
You shall not make and worship any graven images. | Faith |
Worship God in Spirit and Truth who has bodily parts
and passions, instead of worshiping creations of man and God. |
3 |
You shall not take the Name of the LORD your God in vain. | Respect Holiness |
Respect for God and the things of God: prayer, worship, religion. |
4 |
Keep holy the Sabbath day. | Renewal |
Not just the Sabbath rest, but setting aside time for prayer, good recreation, quiet reflection. |
5 |
Honor your father and your mother. | Family |
Loving care and respect for all family members, elders and younger siblings, too. Respect for elders in general. |
6 |
You shall not kill. | Respect For Life |
Courtesy to all, speaking respectfully to all, seeking the best for all. Respecting others' freedom while still defending all human life. |
7 |
You shall not commit adultery. | Chastity Faithfulness (Fidelity) |
Faithful actions beyond just abstaining from sexual contact outside of marriage. Respect for sex and marriage. |
8 |
You shall not steal. | Justice (Honesty) |
Concern for the rights of others, especially when they get in the way of what we desire. A commitment to fairness and a willingness to suffer loss rather than depriving another. |
9 |
You shall not bear false witness. | Truth |
A dedication to what is real and true, even if that reality is against our interests. |
10 |
You shall not covet. | Gratitude |
A desire to want only what God wills. A single-hearted devotion to God's way. A cooperation in God's own generosity that sees all goods as belonging to God and freely given for the good of all. |
When Jesus was asked, "What is the greatest commandment?" he responded with two:
Love God and love your neighbor. (cf. Mark 12:28-31)
In accord with this, we see the first three commandments as directed toward the first of these (love of God), and the last seven as relating to the second: love of neighbor.
Exodus 20:2-17
Deuteronomy 5:6-21
Matthew 5; 12:1-13
Mark 2:23 - 3:5; 7:8-13; 10:17-22; 12:28-31
Luke 18:18-23
John 13:34-35
The Ten Commandments in Hebrew - http://bible.ort.org
The Ten Commandments: Sounds of Love from Sinai, by Fr. Alfred
McBride, O.Praem.
This book expresses the Ten Commandments as "values for
loving," rather than laws.