XANADU:A Merger
Of Media
Part One:
Robert Greenburg
Joel Silver, XANADU's producer initially contracted our studio
to design an opening for his them-current project, entitled THE
WARRIORS. However, the film was too far along in it's production
schedule for our company to create anything unique. Specifically,
Silver was looking for the kind of original approach to his film
that proved to be so successful in our feature work to date.
The Greenburg studio was becoming well known for it's utilization
of consistent visual design elements for teaser trailers, television
spots and film openings. Campaigns for features such as ALIEN,
SUPERMAN and ALL THAT JAZZ are examples of such projects (created
by Frankfurt Communications). Since time did not allow for this
type of visual development on THE WARRIORS, it was decided Silver's
next film would involve the Greenburg's right from the beginning.
In it's early stages, XANADU was to be a roller disco movie,
so we were soon going to roller discos to soak up atmosphere
and trying out different concepts in storyboards. Since the lead
character, played by Olivia Newton-John, was a "muse",
early discussions hit upon the idea of the opening the film with
a wall painting, from which nine muses, including Olivia, would
magically materialize.
It seemed wise to tackle this scene as early as possible, since
it was going to entail elaborate use of a complex blue screen
technique: each of the nine women would have to be photographed
separately against Universal's huge blue screen and the nine
takes would then be composed, with each muse bursting to life
at a different time.
Also, since the women had to appear to come out of a wall painting,
a composite clip featuring the women in their various frozen,
or "come-alive", positions had to be projected against
the wall so an artist could duplicate their position life-sized.
(Since they were being photographed from subtly keystoned angles,
a special projector had to be designed to accommodate the lens
through which they were filmed, assuring that focal length and
keystone distortion remained constant).
With the projected images as a guide, as artist rendered the
nine muses on "skin" which could be removed from the
wall one at a time; the wall was then filmed ten times, with
one "skin" removed for each take. Still keeping the
keystoning consistent, a complicated series of dissolving from
the "painted ladies" to the live dancers brought our
nine muses to life.
Change of direction
Something happened early in XANADU's production period that
made us stop and change direction--two other roller disco movies
were announced. Since it was clear that both SKATETOWN, U.S.A.
and ROLLER BOOGIE were going to be released ahead of Universal's
project, it was decided to emphasize the musical aspects of XANADU
and, ultimately, to launch a full-blown musical fantasy.
With Olivia still in the lead role, Gene Kelly was recruited
for another principal role, thus drawing on his unique identification
with the American musical. (The final XANADU script tells of
a muse who comes to Earth to grant a California artist a wish.
He requests the ultimate disco palace, called Xanadu, which he
obtains through millionaire Gene Kelly's help).
With the fantasy element now being emphasized, special effects
became increasingly important to XANADU, and R/Greenberg Associates
was involved in it's first full feature assignment. It was a
logical progression. We had seen the feature in optical effects
and control of effects, so the plunge into feature work was probably
inevitable. Since we are designers, we have the means to design
a sequence and see it to completion, without worrying about going
from specialist to specialist to specialist.
Our production capabilities are fairly vast--beside our own set-up,
we have an on-going close relationship with two other optical
houses in New York, EFX and Computer Opticals. Because of this
flexibility, we were able to produce, design and often oversee
the direction of special effects with Silver, director Robert
Greenburg and cinematographer Victor Kemper; this, I think, was
of major importance on XANADU. In fact, using their production
crew, my brother Richard would often act as consultant, overseeing
the effects so the uncomposited elements were shot in a way that
allowed us to work with each element as preoptical. They would
then be sent to our New York studio for composing.
Unfortunately, this was not possible in all cases. A great deal
of footage was shot before XANADU had become an effects film,
and many times we'd try to integrate the effects into live action,
by retroscoping, various optical effects or by transitional devises,
such as the many complicated computer generated wipes that were
used. But working with standard live footage was not that unusual
and, in fact, we're sort of used to it, having experience along
these lines from much our prior work.
We would often work on the opening of a feature project that
may have been shot by the most gifted cinematographer in the
business, but still was not shot with an effects team in mind.
You just devise techniques for working with this situations,
such as using supplied live footage as a background plate for
the purpose of further optical composing with graphic animation
or optical effects.
By way of example, there is a moment in XANADU in which multitudinous
Gene Kelly as observed coming through a series of doors simultaneously,
executing a brief dance step and exiting. This was conceived
and filmed as an effects sequence, and was, in fact, some more
of blue screen photography that is quite a precedent in XANADU.
What is tricky about this scene is that Kelly is photographed
in a full-body shot, something that is usually avoided since
it's hard to pull mattes from a blue screen floor and it's even
more difficult to pull mattes on feet (a similar problem with
hair).
In another scene, the muses are dancing on a kaleidoscope platform
when suddenly they turn into streak of light and vanish through
the ceiling. Since were given footage of women dancing, we couldn't
fall back on a blue screen background and had to diverse another
method of getting rid of the muses. We did have the film of the
same scene without the dancers present, and the method we chose
was basically to dissolve from the platform with the dancers
to the platform without dancers. Rotoscoping was done by means
of a precision print that was made of the scene, and the streaking
effect was created on the animation stand and composed on an
optical printer.
Blue screen process sparse on East Coast
Before it begins to sound as though blue screen is a nice easy
device to fall back on when you're looking for an impressive
effect, I should remind that R/Greenberg Associates never had
produced blue screen mattes before. In fact, nobody on the East
Coast dose any major work in this area, owing to the incredible
complexity in the lighting and separations. Furthermore, it is
generally used several seconds at a time in an individual take
(even the wall painting sequence is filmed in cuts from two to
three separate angles, which was in part Victor Kemper's idea
to keep the scenes from looking like a standard process shot.
So there was an added challenge to a musical scene in XANADU
in which Olivia, now in heaven, sings the song 'Suspended In
Time' in a single 300-foot take while the camera dollies in for
a eventual medium close-up. Additionally, while Olivia sings,
she stands on the "floor" of glowing color beams done
in a series of "tube streaks". (Described most simply
"tube streaks" are a series of backlit dots photographed
in time exposed zooms.)
It sometimes seems ironic that elaborate blue screen process
shots rather closely resemble the television device by which
weathermen appear to be superimposed on their maps, or newsmen
in front of videotaped graphics. The difference is that on TV
all you have to do is chroma key; film can't use this video matting
process, because you can't project video with quality resolution
one can achieve on film. In fact, a lot of the effects techniques
in XANADU are based on ideas and tricks that have appeared in
one form or another in network broadcasting (such as the opening
graphics of TV movie shows), special effects commercials and
even our own feature promos. But although they are based on the
same technology, the use to which they're being put in XANADU
is often quite new and original for feature films.
We used slit wipes quite often in the film in order to execute
visually interesting transitions from one scene to the next;
the action dissolves (disintegrates might be a better word) into
a series of slits that reorganize into the next sequence. This
is something we used most recently in out trailers for THE EMPIRE
STRIKE BACK, but the wipes were executed on still photographs
of the starts of the film and not on actual live footage, as
in XANADU.
Elevating the technique
The very first live-action slit wipes were done for an industrial
film for Champion Paper, but the feature film resources of a
project like XANADU elevates the whole technique to something
unique. (A more outstanding example of a commercial effects would
be lettering that we used for the credits for SUPERMAN, with
the clear, dimensional letters exploding out of space and forming
the names of the stars. That design is based on something that
was done for Banco de Ponce, a bank of Puerto Rico. When we sent
it to England so SUPERMAN's director Richard Donner could see
it, someone from their production was in our New York offices
within a week to discuss our working on the titles.)
Time tended to be a tricky opponent on XANADU. The film completed
principle photography in January, but our work began the previous
September, so on certain scenes and certain effects we could
only go so far, since you must have a lock down print of what
they're going to use for timings and rotoscope position before
you can start to do effects on the footage that exists.
Staying on schedule
As various fantasy conception began to take hold of XANADU, the
principles involved (Silver, Greenwald, Kemper) started wanting
more effects, fancier effects, heavier effects. Then with it's
Christmas 1980 release moved up by Universal Pictures to summer
1980, we found that in many ways working with the techniques
we'd come to understand and developed was invaluable in meeting
the workload. Still, we tend to handle 15 projects at one time,
so eventually a specific groups had to be assigned to work exclusively
on XANADU.
The animation stand and the optical bench became our creative
tools. Animation effects in XANADU mark a sharp departure from
the cell type of animation of Disney studio days, in which cels
were opaqued and top-lit. In the case of Disney's work, animation
occurred on the cells, an image subtly one frame at a time, creating
the illusion of movement. With bottom lighting, the animation
techniques in XANADU (and this speaks for the entire changing
nature of graphic film animation) are done in the camera, using
an open lens to create lighting effects.
Throughout XANADU, we were creatively guided by the central concept
of the script-namely, that out main character was not a mortal,
and thus needed to be persuasively supernatural. As early as
the wall painting sequence, the muses who appear are given a
glow, which is achieved through the use of a diffusion filter.
(In a small way, the glowing outlines on our muses were something
of a blessing, since they were successfully eliminate any of
the blue screen fringing that betrays some matte work.) And before
the film was several minutes old, the viewer hopefully has been
dazzled by the sight of nine young women exiting the image as
streaks of light, executed on the optical printer with high-contrast
stock with the contrast increased, then doing time-exposed zooms.
Since fantasy is XANADU's dominant trait, certain mattes, including
a couple of time-lapsed cloud effects matted over the departure
along the highway of one of the muses, and another matted above
Gene Kelly as he sits on a beach playing a musical instrument,
don't look 100 percent realistic. This was intentional, done
with the hope that the various sequence take a mythical ambiance
that looks unreal, rather than phony.
There was a definite challenge to XANADU that effects teams on
movies like STAR WARS and ALIEN often managed to avoid (although
SUPERMAN frequently faced the same difficulty). Except for the
sequence set in heaven, XANADU is and earthbound fantasy, and
many of the elaborate matting effects had to be successfully
worked into naturalistic settings, street scenes, etc. One of
the muses even exits as a live-action tapered streak (that technique's
official name) from within the metal superstructure off a large
building, to cite a particular example. Unlike the even the most
complicated space films, XANADU doesn't get to pull off it's
most impressive effects within the comfortable black limbo of
space.
Many of our discoveries can be considered state of the art. This
sort of fortuitous discovery is in many ways at the root of some
of the most creative effects work in the industry. At any rate,
XANADU is intended as a movie about the fantastic; the craftsmen
of R/Greenberg Associates worked to make a movie that looks like
nothing you've never seen before. When you think about it, at
least occasionally, it looks like nothing we've ever seen before
either.
XANADU:A Merger
Of Media
Part Two:
Robert Greenwald
As Xanadu was originally concerned, the use of special effects
was going to be minimal. However, as the style of the film became
less real and more fantastic, the special effects grew, for they
seemed the absolutely ideal way to capture in the visual form
a movie based in the real world but essentially non-real. What
was particularly interesting about collaborating with Richard
and Robert Greenburg was that we worked on a creative-concept
approach, not the "it can't be done because...." school
of special effects.
One of the unique things about a musical film is the number of
people involved in the various areas, from music to choreography
to costumes to effects. No decision is made that doesn't affect
dozens of key collaborations. Consequently, I insisted on stressing
the overall point of view of the film. I knew that for the movie
to work it needed to have the music, dance, effects and camera
deeply and inextricably integrated. The only way to achieve that
was to have all the key people aware of what the overall was.
In effects, three main areas emerged: 1) the opening, 2) Fiorrucci
dance, and 3) Special Place. In dealing with these three areas
of the movie, the discussion was primarily conceptual and creative.
Only after the groundwork was laid did wee get down to the nitty
gritty of implementing it technically. As a result of this thematic
approach to the material, rather than a technical/effects one,
we achieved a total integration of the effects into the fabric
of the film.
The Opening
The opening of the film became more and more important as the
fantasy element grew, for it was in the opening that I needed
to establish a style and feel so the audience would accept entering
a seemingly real contemporary world mixed with total fantasy.
If the fantasy premise was established and accepted in the beginning
of the movie, then all of our story about muses would work. If
we didn't get the audience to accept this premise up front, we
could never catch them later on.
The opening provided for Michael Beck to be at the end of his
emotional rope, and in need of assistance. At the very point
he gives up his artwork, Olivia Newton-John, a muse, enters his
life to help him with his dreams.
In the pre-production meetings, careful and elaborate plan emerged
which would take us from reality (Michael Beck painting and tearing
up his artwork) to a mixture of reality and non-reality (real
paper traveling across real buildings in a totally fashion via
use of the blue screen) to total non-reality (the paper drops
in front of a wall mural of nine women who comes alive and begin
to dance and turn into streaks of light).
The effects for the opening had three parts: a) the paper traveling
in front of the mural and bring the women to life; b) the dance;
and c) the women turning into streaks of light. The paper activating
the women was perhaps the key effect for me conceptually, for
at that moment we were making a transition that lies at the heart
of the movie-we were taking real paper, created by a real person
with real behavior, and utilizing it magically to transform a
seemingly real wall mural into a musical fantasy of dancing women
surrounded by a glow.
If this effect were to work, I felt that the movie would not
be off to an unusual beginning, and we would taken our audience
thought a process that our lead character goes through, accepting
a fantasy figure in his life. The process work, the creating
of the wall painting, the sue of video, the extensive blue screen
work, all came about only after we clearly and specifically conceptualized
this key transition moment in the style and mood of our film.
The dance itself I shot against blue screen, and matted in the
realistic background; this way I got not only the glow around
the women, but some of their shadows so that it seems as if they
were magical figures in a real place. In that sense the dance
is the perfect metaphor for the film itself-a real place with
magical mysterious and wonderful figures.
While the camera was not able to move in the dance sequence,
hence limiting some what I would have liked to do, there were
numerous other dances where it could move and the potential excitement
of these muses glowing and being on a real street was worth the
necessary sacrifice.
The third element of the opening, the streaking and turning into
the light. I wanted it to be a continuous gradual transition,
rather than a sudden startling effect. What I wanted was to conclude
the opening by seeing our lovely dancers transformed before our
very eyes into streak of light in a real setting, hence, ending
the sequence and taking us back to reality. In order to do this
we shot not just plates, but actual live action shots of the
women moving through the real environment. This turned out to
be effective in rooting them in reality, in giving the movement
a sense of creditability, and once more combining the sense of
fantasy figures in the real world-an easy sounding task by, in
fact, conceptually and technically a very difficult one to full
off.
Fiorrucci (Department store dance)
The second major use of special effects came about in a manner
opposite to the opening. As we edited the number, began to feel
that the transition from sequence to sequence, which had been
storyboarded and shot for visual excitement, could be improved
by the use of optics. So, in contrast to the opening, the effects
were added after the shooting was finished and without planned.
As conceived, the dance was non-realistic: Olivia, Gene and Michael
enter a store and the dancers and the clothes all turn into an
old-fashioned musical dance number. However, it was more an absence
of reality (like the barn building number in SEVEN BRIDES FOR
SEVEN BROTHERS).
Each time we introduced an optical to take us from a face to
a car, from glasses exploding to a skating wheel, from the doors
exploding to a yellow cloud, to a new sequence, it became clearer
and clearer that not only did the opticals not validate the style
of the sequence; they in fact added to it and moved us from a
musical dance number in the Broadway stage sense to a total musical
movie number. Here, particularly, the Greenberg's ability to
use existing footage that had not been shot with opticals in
mind was unique and exciting experience for me. I was able to
talk in terms of, "here should be a color of explosion where
the yellow from the doors fill the frame," and from such
discussions, with the film we already shot, effects can produced-Gene
Kelly going to a pinball machine for instance, or where feathers
come out, they turn into color and fill the frame. So the resulting
number has stylistic unity and a contemporary feel, most of which
was the result of post-production creative discussions rather
pre-production.
A Special Place
A third section of the film where we utilized effects involved
Michael Beck's reclaiming Olivia Newton-John, who has disappeared
into the world of the muses. This world could look and feel an
infinite number of ways, I was curtain that this place should
not be a movie "heaven" or Disney-like environment.
I wanted to create a place of infinity, of beauty, and of abstraction-something
that would not scare off the children, and yet something not
based on literal references.
The decision was made before filming began that this environment
would be created via special effects; the dialogue, therefore,
was all shot against blue screen. However, exactly what the background
would look would be was only decided, through experiment and
trail-and-error. Only slowly and painstakingly did we create
an environment: the "floor" that connected the actors
to each other suggested an infinite perspective with a pulsating
feel.
The glow around Kira was planned from the beginning, but the
background behind Kira, the rising stars for Zeus, and the force
field of lights to hold back Michael, all evolved as the overall
feel of the place became clearer to us through our experiments.
There are a variety of other effects throughout the movie, a
mixture of these pre-planned and shot of effect, and other created
after the footage was shot. Throughout this very difficult endeavor
with too little time to do everything we wanted, the integration
off effects into the overall proceeded with a consistent principle
of combining, advancing and highlighting the musical fantasy
aspects.
XANADU:A Merger
Of Media
Part Three:
A Boost From Bluth: Don Bluth Animation
Also with an animated contribution to XANADU was Don Bluth Productions
in Studio City, California. The brief segment incorporates a
contemporary look of sparkles and glowing effects with traditional
lines of classic animation styles, accomplished with conventional
methods on a Fax animation camera.
The action follows Olivia Newton-John and her partner falling
in love through a lyrical metamorphosis from live actors to animated
characters, then to a variety of forms; fish, birds, and finally,
people again, this time enveloped in the folding petals of a
rose blossom.
Bluth had the option of doing most of these effects optically,
shooting the several segments of film and combining them through
a printer, or using multiple passes on the same piece of film.
The latter technique was chosen for speed, cost efficiency and
to exercise the extra degree of control that keeping the job
in-house would permit. Interestingly, portions of the art have
the flashy futuristic look of computer graphics. These were hand
drawn for the most part, with sparkles added by back lighting.
In order to increase the sense the depth and perspective, all
the artwork was filmed at least twice. Scenes with water, for
example, were shot with several passes, like double exposure.
First the cell art without the water was filmed at a 40 percent
exposure; then, the same art with the water at 60 percent, giving
the final result of 100 percent for the backgrounds, 60 percent
for the water, creating a desired effect of translucence. In
order to calculate these exposures, explained Disney expatriate
Don Bluth, a series of range tests were conducted to decide on
the optimum means of preparing the artwork and camera setting.
Don Bluth Productions is in the process of adding a series of
multi-plane camera systems, with stands designed by Mechanical
Concepts and a camera by John Monceaux, for use in their upcoming
feature, MRS. FRISBY AND THE RATS OF NIMM.

|