The characters and universe of Harry Potter are the sole property of J. K. Rowling and her 
licensees.

Darling Girl
By
Eric Thorson and Balthazar Kwiatkowski

________________DG_________________
Chapter Two: Who’s Your Daddy?
________________DG_________________

Remus woke up with a start. It took a few moments before he remembered what was 
troubling him. He remembered the events of the day before, and the things he remembered 
worried him. He remembered it all starting when Harry’s owl arrived with a letter for 
Dumbledore from Harry’s aunt during a staff meeting. It turned out that something had 
happened to Harry, and there was a mysterious girl unconscious on his bed. After they 
brought girl back to Hogwarts, everybody’s worries increased when they realized that the 
girl might be a Death Eater plant and Harry could have been missing since the night his 
parent had died.

His worries were relieved and then redirected when he came to his room and found a letter 
addressed to him from Lily Potter; or rather from Lily Snape. It turned out that Lily was 
never married to James Potter at all, but instead married Severus Snape right after school had 
finished. That had been the first shock in the letter from his long dead friend, but by no 
means the smallest one. The letter had gone on to say that Lily had been pregnant before she 
moved in with James and that Harry was not James’ son, or even Harry. Lily’s only child was 
born a girl, Lilith, Snape’s daughter. It went on to explain how, to protect Snape’s cover 
among the Death Eater’s, Lily had pretended to be married to James Potter, and changed her 
daughter into her son.

It was so hard for him to take in. His whole world view had changed. The child that he had 
seen as the only part of his friends that he had left, the only reminder of what he had once 
had, wasn’t the son of the brother he’d never had. She was the daughter of his soul sister and 
one of his greatest rivals. As he thought about the changes his world had undergone, a voice 
at the back of head kept shouting ‘if you think you have it bad, think about what that poor 
child will be going through when she wakes up.’ Swearing to himself, Remus surged out of 
his bed and got dressed as quickly as possible, then froze when he thought of something else. 
“How am I going to convince Albus and Severus? Lily did too good a job of convincing the 
world that Harry was James’ son.” He muttered to himself, slumping back onto his bed.
He thought about the problem for several minutes, discarding idea after idea before he 
remembered the letter sitting on his dressing table. Remus quickly got out of bed, looked 
through the letter again to be sure that it said the same things that it had the night before, 
then rushed from the room, hoping he had the chance to tell Dumbledore about it before 
they used the Progenitor Potion on Lilith. He ran most of the way to Dumbledore’s office, 
shouting the password and running up the stairs two at a time.

“Professor Dumbledore.” Remus called out when he entered the room and saw him standing 
near his desk. Dumbledore looked up in surprise.

“Remus, good morning, what can I help you with.” Dumbledore replied with a smile.

“I have some information about the girl for you to see before we use the Progenitor Potion 
on her.” Remus said.

“I can’t imagine what, but we have decided to use the Progenitor Potion on her and Severus 
should be here shortly with the finished potion.” Dumbledore said. “While we wait for 
Severus, why don’t you tell me about this information you have.”

Right when Remus was going to pull out the letter and show it to Dumbledore, Snape burst 
into the room and strode towards Dumbledore and Lupin with scowl on his face.

“It’s not possible!” Snape almost shouted out at the top of his lungs.

“Please quiet yourself Severus, there are people still sleeping in the castle.” Dumbledore 
asked him. “What is not possible, Severus?”

“According to that woman, the girl is a relation of mine.” Snape replied after taking a few 
breaths to calm him.

“A relation you say?” Dumbledore said. “I thought you were the last of your family.”

“I may be able to help there.” Remus said taking the letter from his pocket.

“What would you know about this, wolf?” Snape snarled dismissively, and then turned back 
to Dumbledore. “We need to have this matter cleared up quickly before the Dark Lord hears 
of it. This could be the death of the both of us. If the Dark Lord were to discover that I had 
living relations, and lied about them, he would not stop until the girl was brought before him 
and I had explained myself. ”

“As I was about to show Dumbledore here, I found a letter last night that should clarify all of 
this.” Remus said and pulled the letter out and made to hand it over to Dumbledore, but 
Snape snatched it out of his hands and threw it to the floor.

“Shall we stop wasting time with this nonsense and find out who this girl actually is.” Snape 
stormed out of the room with the vial of Progenitor Potion clenched tightly in his hands. 
Lupin and Dumbledore followed him to the Hospital Wing where they were met by Madam 
Pomfrey who looked outraged at the intrusion into her domain.

“What is going on?” She demanded. “What is the meaning of all this noise?”

Snape ignored her, and took the girls hand from where it was lying outside her quilt. 
Ignoring Madam Pomfrey’s protest, he drew a lancet from within his robes and pricked her 
finger, dropping several drops of her blood into the clear potion in the vial. Swirling it three 
times to the left and then once to the right, he drew a pure white quill from within his robes 
and then set a sheet of unbleached parchment on the bed side table. After dipping the quill 
in the now black potion, he nodded to Professor Dumbledore who drew his wand from 
inside his sleeve.

“Revello Progenitus.” Dumbledore said, making a writing motion over the white quill. The 
quill rose to a writing position, and began to move over the parchment. Stopping to dip itself 
in the potion vial several times, it continued down the parchment, drawing a pedigree chart 
and inserting names into each position. This continued for almost five minutes before the 
quill flared incandescently along with the remains of the potion, and both vanished, leaving 
behind a metallic imprint at the bottom of the parchment. Professor Snape snatched the 
sheet up and began reading it, then froze, dropping the parchment before collapsing to the 
floor in a faint.

“Goodness, what could have affected Severus so greatly?” Madame Pomfrey exclaimed, 
levitating the fallen professor to the sofa along one wall. After checking his vital signs, she 
turned back to the others as Lupin lifted the parchment and handed it to Professor 
Dumbledore. As the headmaster read through the pedigree chart, his eyebrows climbed his 
forehead until they had almost disappeared under his hat. Madame Pomfrey noticed that his 
eyes were twinkling merrily. “What does it say Albus?”

“Lilith Andromeda Amaranthys Snape is the daughter of Lily Evans Snape and Severus 
Saridius Lazarius Snape,” the Headmaster replied, his eyes twinkling violently. “It appears 
that many of us were under a number of misapprehensions.”

“Wait… did you say ‘Lily Snape’?” Professor McGonagall demanded, overcoming her shock. 
“Lily would never… she could never…”

“It would appear that she would, and in fact did, marry Severus. She also seems to have been 
married to him when this young lady was born, as this parchment would have another name 
on it if she had been married to James Potter.”

“But how is this possible? What about Harry?” McGonagall continued, still in shock. “Albus 
what about the boy that we knew for the last five years, where is he?”

“Right in front of us Minerva, if a little changed from the last time we saw him.” Dumbledore 
indicated the girl lying in the bed. “We shall have to wait for Severus to recover to learn 
more about how this happened though.”

“He should have regained conscious by now,” Madame Pomfrey sounded concerned as she 
moved back to Snape’s bedside. Passing her wand over his still form, she frowned and drew a 
pin from her hair, surprising everyone by jabbing Snape with it. The Potions Master erupted 
from the bed, diving to the other side with a roar of pain as the Medi-witch smirked at him.

“That will teach you to pretend unconsciousness in my hospital wing, Severus Snape.” 
Madame Pomfrey growled out, completely indifferent to the glare Snape was sending her 
way. “Now would you care to explain how your daughter happens to have Lily Evans as her 
mother?” Before Snape could begin his explanation, the shape on the bed started moving.

“Ugh, what happened?” a soft voice asked, sounding extremely confused.

“Ah, it seems our patient is waking up.”  Dumbledore said motioning for the adults to be 
quiet before turning to the girl. “We will have to talk about this at a later time.”

________________DG_________________

Harry slowly woke up to a throbbing on the right side of his head.  He groaned a little in 
pain and brought his hand up to the sore spot, trying to remember what caused it. Then, the 
memories of the previous day started slowly coming back to him.  His Aunt and Uncle were 
yelling at him for accidentally changing his hair color, his illness from earlier, and then the 
sudden wrenching pain and the blood, though he couldn’t remember where the blood came 
from. As he thought about it, trying to remember, he heard shouting and realized that he 
was not alone and decided to see who was shouting. When he saw the ceiling above him, he 
knew something was wrong.  He was not in his bedroom at his Aunt’s house like he should 
be. He was in the hospital wing in Hogwarts.  There was something odd going on, but he 
couldn’t figure out what it was. That was when he realized that he could see the ceiling 
clearly, without his glasses.

Looking around wildly, Harry sat up a little too quickly, and collapsed back into the hospital 
bed, but not before he noticed the Headmaster. “Professor Dumbledore?”  Harry asked in 
confusion. “What happened? What am I doing here?”

“Good morning child, how are you feeling?”  Dumbledore asked, smiling in reassurance.

“My head hurts, but other than that I feel okay I guess.”  Harry replied, looking around in 
confusion.  “Why am I at Hogwarts?”

“We were wondering if you could tell us how you came to be on Privet Drive. Who are you 
child?”

“What do you mean, Professor? I live there… you said I have to stay there every summer.” 
Harry looked around when he heard a gasp, catching sight of Professor McGonagall, who 
was staring at him. “What’s going on, Professor?”

“Child, many things have changed. Can you tell me what the last thing you can remember 
is?” Professor Dumbledore sat in the bedside chair, smiling encouragingly.

“I don’t really know what you want to hear, Professor.  I was at my Aunt’s house and weird 
stuff started happening. After a while, I started to feel sick, so I decided to take a nap. It was 
only getting worse though, so I went to the bathroom and … and …” Dawning horror 
flashed across the girl’s face as her eyes went wide. He remembered what had happened and 
sat up quickly, grabbing his lap to confirm what he feared. With that confirmation, he 
looked down, noticing to the first time the strange weight on his chest.  Shakily bringing his 
hands up, he cupped the bulges his or rather her chest. That was when he realized that the 
breasts that he was looking at belonged to him.

“What happened to me?”  Harry exclaimed in shock, grabbing Professor Dumbledore by the 
front of his robes.  “Why am I a girl?”

“Please, calm down child, and we will explain what we know.”  Dumbledore said taking 
Harry’s hands gently from his robes.

“Calm down?  Look at me! I’m a girl!” Harry yelled indicating her chest.

“We can see that Harry, but we need you to calm down so that we can explain what we 
think may have happened to you.”

Harry was having a hard time calming down, so Madame Pomfrey had her take a Calming 
Draught to speed up the process.  While they were waiting, Snape got fed up with the way 
the people in the room seemed to be fawning on Potter and stormed out of the room.  When 
Harry was calmed down enough, Dumbledore handed the girl a mirror so she could see what 
she looked like.  Harry took it and looked at her reflection for the first time.  Her image in 
the mirror looked vaguely familiar, and it was only a few moments later that she recognized 
the image she was looking at.

“I look like my mother.”  Harry whispered then turned to the professors desperately. “Why 
do I look like my mother?!”

“We were wondering the same thing.”  Dumbledore said with a reassuring smile when Harry 
looked at him confusion. “From what we have been able to discover, this is what you are 
supposed to look like.”

“What I’m supposed to look like? In case you haven’t noticed professor, I’m a girl right now. 
How could this possibly be the way I’m supposed to look? I’m a guy! I’m Harry Potter!” 
Harry glared at the headmaster, who was grinning at her, and then slumped back on her bed.

“How did I get to Hogwarts?” She asked quietly.

“The owner of the house where you were found sent a message to me and an associate and I 
went to investigate.” Professor Dumbledore explained. When we saw your condition, we 
discussed our options and decided to bring you here.”

“Aunt Petunia sent a message to you? How… she sent Hedwig?! Are we talking about the 
same woman who screams at me every time I even let my owl out to hunt?” Harry asked 
with disbelief plain in her voice. Dumbledore could no longer avoid the conclusion that this 
girl at least firmly believed that she was Harry Potter and sighed

“Yes Harry she did, and before you ask, she is also the only one there who knows of your 
changed appearance.  She kept you hidden from your Uncle and cousin until we removed 
you from the house.”  Dumbledore replied, his eyes twinkling when he heard Harry sigh in 
relief at finally being accepted by Dumbledore.
“What is going on? Is there some way we can break this spell I’m under?”

“Harry, as far as Madame Pomfrey and I have been able to tell, you are not under a spell of 
any kind.”

“But how is that possible Professor? How can I be a girl when I’ve been a boy for as long as I 
can remember? I mean, if I’m really a girl, what’s my name? It can’t be Harry… unless my 
mum named me Harriet. Please tell me that my name isn’t Harriet!” Harry’s horror at the 
idea was obvious.

“I shall let Remus, and Poppy explain what we have discovered to you. However, I can say 
that your given name is not Harriet, but rather Lilith.” Professor Dumbledore smiled when 
Lilith repeated her name several times. He glanced at the other adults in the room before he 
continued. “Now, I must leave you in these, rather capable hand, while I speak to Professor 
Snape.”  Dumbledore said, nodding to the others, and then leaving.

Dumbledore walked out of the room and Lilith turned to face Remus and Madame Pomfrey.  
After a few moments of silence, she cleared her throat and asked her first question, “How is 
this possible?” 

“Well my dear, from the evidence we have, you have been under the effects of a gender 
switching charm, as well as several potions, for a very long time.” Madame Pomfrey began. 
“Normally, a spell of this nature would not last very long, perhaps a week at most, but the 
potions must have prolonged the effects.”

“I would say so,” Lilith replied with a smirk that made Remus gasp. “What is it Remus?”

“How could I not have seen it before? You act just like him.” Lilith looked at him 
questioningly, and Remus elaborated. “You looked a lot like your father just then.”

“My father?” Lilith looked at herself in the mirror, trying to see what Remus meant. “I can’t 
see it.”

Madame Pomfrey glared at Remus, but he ignored her and continued. “The only person I 
have ever seen smirk like that was Severus Snape.”

“And what does that have to do with me?” Lilith asked before a horrified look crossed her 
face. “No, please no… he can’t be… mum would never… she couldn’t have…” Madame 
Pomfrey glared at Remus again and tried to calm the girl down, realizing how much this 
must be affecting Lilith for her to react this violently when under effect of the Calming 
Draught.

“While I would have preferred to tell you in a less abrupt manner…” Pomfrey started telling 
her what she had found.  She told him of the spell residue and other indicators she found, 
that Lilith has recently been under several gender switching spells combined with a number 
of blood based mimic potions until very recently. That the spell is breaking down, which is 
canceling all the potion’s effects.  But the thing that shocked Lilith the most was when she 
was told about the Progenitor Potion and the results of it.

“So I’m not really a Potter, I’m a Snape? How is that even possible?  My mom married James 
Potter.  Are you telling me my mom was sleeping around with Snape?” Lilith accused 
angrily.

“Now before you start with that line of thought, I have a letter you might want to read.”  
Lupin said and handed Lilith the letter and saw as Lilith read it several times before looking 
at Lupin in shock.

“So, I was really born a girl and my mom really married Professor Snape and not my da … 
James Potter.  My mom did all of this to me in order to protect Snape while he was 
undercover.  And my name is Lilith and not Harry?” Harry or rather Lilith said as she then 
took a few deep breaths to calm herself again.

“You are being rather calm about all this,” Lupin said, watching her closely.

“I think I’m still under the influence of the Calming Draught, or I would probably be 
freaking out about now.”  Lilith replied.

“I see,” Lupin nodded.  “Well, this parchment shows who you and your parents are.  It’s what 
we got after we used the Progenitor Potion on you.”

Lupin handed that parchment over to Lilith and she looked down at the parchment  and saw 
that the name on top said ‘Lilith Andromeda Snape’ and below that name was “Lily Evans’ 
and “Severus Snape’.  Lilith set the parchment on the table next to the bed and layed back 
down.

“Can I have some time to myself to think about all of this?”  Lilith asked.

“Okay, but if you need any of us, just call out of us.”  Lupin said.

“All right.”  Lilith said as Lupin and Pomfrey left Lilith to her thoughts, a little worried what 
was going through her mind.

________________DG_________________

Dumbledore found Snape pacing around his classroom deep in thought.  Dumbledore just 
stood there until Snape realized that he wasn’t alone.

“What do you want?”  Snape asked.

“Just checking to see how you are doing after finding out about everything.”  Dumbledore 
replied.

“How do you think I feel?”  Snape snapped at Dumbledore.  “I just find out that my wife, 
who I thought cheated on me with my worst enemy didn’t, and that the Potter boy who I 
have been treating like scum is really the daughter I never new I had.”

“I was simply asking because I had noticed that there was a memory charm on you, a very 
powerful one that wouldn’t be detected with Occlumency.”

“A memory charm? And if it can’t be detected with Occlumency, how did you find it?”

“The type of charm I am detecting requires certain triggersthink due to recent events, the 
memory charm is weakening. It shouldn’t be long before you remember what it is blocking.  
But right now lets meet up with everyone and discuss what we are going to do with your 
daughter.”

“All right.”

So both of them left the room and headed up to Dumbledore’s office to discuss what the 
future of Lilith is going to be.

    Source: geocities.com/zciwohcats