Kentuckian, 102, Recalls Mountain Feud Between Turners,
Sowders In Early 1870's
Click here for another account of this feud by Thomas Nelson Sowder
"Uncle Joe" (Pet) Marsee
of Middlesboro, who was 102 years old on Aug. 6 is the only living person
who can recall the events leading up to, and who knew all the participants
in the notorious mountain fued between the Turners and Sowders on along
the Kentucky Tennessee border during the early 1870's.
Marsee, who lives alone
with his wife in a secluded spot near the White Bridge in Noetown in Suburban
Middlesboro, vividly recalls the violent interfamily war in which many
lives were lost and scores were seriously injured before peace was restored.
Bell County's oldest male
resident, and widely regarded as an authority on the early history of Yellow
Creek Valley and its people, "Uncle Joe" was kin to both families.
"I was kin to the Turners through my aunt, Betsy Marsee, who married a Turner, and related to the Sowders through my grandmother, Nancy Sowders, sister of Jacob Sowders, who was the father of General Sowder, the key figure in the bloody fued," Marsee explained.
"I saw the fightin' and I lived through it all, but I took no part whatsoever in the battles," he related, adding "I reckon, though, I could name all the persons who were killed as well as those that did the shootin."
"Uncle Joe" crossed his legs flicked at a fly that was bothering him, and went on.
"The Turners were honest
and respectable people, but high strung and easily angered, fierce in their
loyalty to kinfolk and quick to resent any insult or injury. General Sowder's
father, old Jake Sowders, owned a farm on Stony Fork, adjoining that of
"Pussy Joe" Turner. General married Joe's daughter, Elizabeth."
"General and Elizabeth seemed
devoted to one another. No one ever heard of any trouble between them,
but somehow, during a playful scuffle, one of Elizabeth's thumbs was broken."
"Tongues began to waggin'
and someone told Elizabeth's brothers, Gordon and Harve Turner, that General
was mistreating their sister. Lee immediately sent word to General that
he intended to kill him on sight."
"Knowin' this to be no idle
threat, and seein' as how the Turners far outnumbered his own kin, General
lost no time in arrangin' a number of hideouts."
"While stayin' at the home
of a friend on Tackett's Creek in Tennessee, he was awakened late one night
by someone pounding on the door of the room in which he was sleepin'. Startled,
and thinkin' that the Turners had finally tracked him down, General hastily
grabbed up his rifle, and as the door was pushed violently from the outside,
blazed away at the intruders, killing them instantly. Too late, he discovered
that they were not enemies but two of his best friends, Rube Carroll and
Chad Massey."
Jailed in Tennessee
"As the shootin' had taken
place in Tennessee, General was arrested and lodged in the jail at Tazewell,
the county seat, but a group of his friends stormed the jail and released
him and he returned to his home in Yellow Creek Valley. The families of
the two dead men, convinced that the killings had been committed under
justifiable circumstances, forgave General and declined to prosecute."
After his return, according
to Marsee, for a time there was an uneasy truce, brought about, it was
believed, through the efforts of General's wife. But war was soon to break
out again.
"One day," he recalled,
"General met Lee on the county road as both were returnin' home from the
day's work. Lee remarked, casual like, that he needed a shave, and said
he would drop over to the Sowders place after he had washed up a bit."
"General told that he had
been followed for some time by four armed men, and suspicious of Lee's
intentions, upon returning home began to brood over his troubles and took
several big swigs of whiskey to settle his nerves. There was never a more
amiable man when sober, but a few drinks of liquor always made him cranky
and quarrelsome. He had reached that state by the time Lee arrived, and
had no doubt but what he would be shot down the minute he opened the door.
So, feelin' that his own life hung on the next move, he opened fire through
the partly open door, puttin a bullit through Lee's heart."
War Declared
"With Lee's death,
all friendly relations between the two families was abruptly terminated,
and open warfare declared," Marsee continued. "Within a comparatively few
months, Lee's brothers, Gordon and Harve Turner, were slain by Sowders
sympathizers. The three brothers were buried, side by side, in the Turner
Cemetery in Middlesboro's West end." These gory happenings are still fresh
in "Uncle Joe's" memory.
"Gordon had killed Will
Lane before Tom Black fired a fatal shot into Gordon's body. About the
same time a gang of Harve Turner's killed Jim Rains, who had made the mistake
of meddlin' a little too much in the fuedin'. Jim was related to the Turner's,
but had sympathized with the Sowders faction."
Law enforcement in the mountain
section in the period following the Civil War was difficult and usually
ineffective," Marsee said. "Few sheriff's deputies were willing to risk
the service of warrants, when to do so was to court almost certain death."
"Uncle Joe" remembers that he witnessed one such effort:
"It was one day as I was
crossin' a hill and followin' the narrow trail that served as a road through
what is now the business section of Middlesboro," he related. "I noticed
a party of twenty men or so, all armed and bearin' down on a party of the
Sowders. Gordon Turner and his brother Harve, were movin' in the direction
of General, and I heard afterwards that Harve thought he had killed the
leader of the Sowders clam, but after the battle, turned over the body
and found he had shot the wrong man."
"I realized that I was goin'
to see some gunplay, and threw myself down beside a fallen log. I had no
sooner done so than firin' started from all directions, and the air was
filled with gunsmoke. I don't know how many on each side were hit, for
just at that time Jim Johnson, Bell County's sheriff, and a force of deputies
came ridin' up, and the firin' ceased."
"The sheriff dismounted
and walked to where some of the men who had been in the fight were standin'.
"You know I've got a right to arrest you men," he told them. "Just try
it," one of the Turners replied." "No one did," "Uncle Joe" chuckled.
Clashes Continue
"In the following two or
three years, there were constant clashes between members of the two families;
each had a brood of relatives and in-laws who were always eager for a test
of strength."
"A person could hardly call
his life his own while this was goin' on," said "Uncle Joe." "After Lee
was killed a party of Turners shot the chimney off of Uncle Jake Sowders'
home, and then blasted the place to pieces."
"A warrant was finally served
on General and a trial was held at Pineville. The followers of both factions
filed into the courtroom armed to the teeth, their rifles restin' across
their knees all durin' the hearing. I don't just recollect all the details,
but there wasn't enough evidence to convict General of murder, and he was
freed."
"General Sowders had always
wanted his people to live in peace," Uncle Joe said, "and often said he
never shot a man except in self defense."
With the passing of Lee,
Gordon and Harve Turner, tension steadily diminished and peace settled
over the valley.
"I reckon that's about all
I can tell you," said "Uncle Joe" in conclusion. "General Sowders was one
of Bell County's most spectacular characters. Although he was accounted
a dead shot and was variously reported to have killed 12 to 14 men, I'm
sure he wasn't guilty of many of the crimes his enemies tried to fasten
on him. His son told me that his father had actually killed only six men,
and I know of only five for sure. He had many narrow escapes, some of them
almost miraculous, but lived out his life span and died a natural death,
respected by all who knew him."