The Dark Lord Benjamin McGuinnes, is cold and without feeling. When he immerged from the portal, in the alternate time line, he was greeted by the Rev. Thomas Barton. Unlike in our time line, this Rev. Thomas did not think of him just as a dead hulk with no meaning, this time he was expecting more. Unlike Captain who was the first through the portal in our time, Benjamin was second to Sargent. The two had fought just like they did in our time, but this time Benjamin was able to throw Sargent through the portal, before he died.

When Sargent came out, he was in much the same state as Captain had been, but still moving, so when Benjamin fell through, he fell into the grasp of the Brotherhood. With the years that would follow before the team would find him, he would be a great help in the over taking of the United States, as well as a great help fighting off several of the demons that would try and take the world from the Brotherhood. The Rev. Thomas Barton saw a great deal of power in this dead man, and used him to the most of his power. He would later take control of a great deal of the grunt work with running a country. He also took it apon himself to head the Handlers group, as well working with them gather up information on the many aliens that seem to find there way to Dark Earth.