| Once More, With Feeling |
| The Buffy Musical |
| Lyrics |
| I've Got a Theory/What Can't We Face?-Giles, Willow, Xander, Anya, Tara, Buffy |
| Going Through the Motions-Buffy, Demons |
| Under Your Spell-Tara |
| I'll Never Tell-Anya, Xander |
| Dawn's Lament-Dawn |
| Sweet's Song-Sweet, Dawn |
| Standing in the Way-Giles |
| Under Your Spell(Reprise)/Wish I Could Stay-Tara, Giles |
| Sweet's Song(Reprise)-Sweet |