JULY 1995 LHASA, TIBET LETTER



Section I: Images & Experiences
Introduction ... Bits Of India & Nepal
Entry Into China: Tibet ... The Tibet Adventure (Journal Entries)

Section II: A Philosophy For Living On Earth
Bits Of China & Confucianism ... Mind, Body, Soul
A Rational Self-Interest ... Against Altruism ... Closing Words






Introduction

There has been Mount Everest base camp at 5200 metres above sea level, Kathmandu, Tibetan prayer flags, pig's snout-ears-tongue, chicken heads, stomach lining, the new-found adoration of Ayn Rand, and Mimi the Dog has gone missing in the streets of Lhtzse -- somebody's meal perhaps? What a world is up here on top of the world -- Tibet is where I am, or should I clarify myself, Tibet province, China. I'm now in the capital city of Lhasa.

And so with the addressed envelope as my greetings I will begin the content of this letter with haste, for if I do not I may end up carrying these pictures over the Great Wall, through the Forbidden City, past Confucius' burial site, by Genghis Khan's mausoleum, over Hong Kong's skyscraping heights and the Pacific's depth, to place them in your hands personally. Yes that's right, the tour is coming to a close -- within a couple months my feet will be once again on North American soil: Canada. Returning 60 kilograms of body, 10 kilograms of backpack, a once discouraged mind that has just begun to realize the infinite possibilities and beauty of life, and a G-7 passport ...


Bits Of India & Nepal

I left Rishikesh on April 25 taking a bus to Dharamsala, currently the home for the exiled Tibetan government and the Dalai Lama. A week here, I moved on to New Delhi -- bought some new clothes and a Chinese visa. Then left for the mountains again, the town of Manalli, as +40C in Delhi was a tad too warm.

Finally, on May 20 I took my leave of India crossing over into Nepal. To insert a comic interlude, this journal entry comes on May 20 at 3:13am, after sixty or so continuous hours on various transports. Having just broken out of a brief slumber and realizing the bus is not moving … again.

It's a little bit nightmarish sitting in that seat sweating, trying to sleep, babies crying, people coughing and turning restlessly, dogs barking rabidly, brakes whining on the other buses as they fly by, cocks crowing -- in all this I ask to the wind (because I get no reply) -- "Why aren't we moving? C'mon, it's not like I'm going to get angry. Just amuse me."

Or the next day (May 21) looking back:

Pulled in about 6am I think. Deranged, in serious head spins, grabbed a cab and took the first pad I found for 150 rupees ($3US) -- clean, new and loaded with luxuries. Showered three days of blood and grime away, detangled my hair, looked around. The 'Heavy Breakfast' was fantastic. Gawd what a nightmare bus trip man. I swear it was the bus from hell and all those people were Satan's citizens -- old, grey, shrunken. A motley crew of creatures, each time waking to the question: "Where in hell am I now??"

Such is the insanity we backpackers love to return to.

A few weeks in Pokhara, the "Kashmir of Nepal", and a couple of weeks in Kathmandu in a hotel on Freak Street, I then blew out the top end of Nepal on June 16. Hello Zhangmu border town, Tibet, China.


Entry Into China: Tibet

Initially I did not plan to spend much time here in Tibet. I found out unexpectedly, after crossing the border, that the Chinese had done a policy change concerning foreigner's entry into Tibet (obviously in preparation for the upcoming September 'celebration' marking 30 years of the Chinese 'liberating' the Tibetans from their backwards ways.)

A permit was necessary to travel the 725 km road from Zhangmu to Lhasa. The only was to get a permit was to go through the Chinese travel officials, CITS, and sign up for a tour -- a tour not necessarily orientated for a backpacker's budget. So here I was in China but stuck in the border town unable to proceed any further without this precious permit. I considered turning back to Kathmandu and flying to Thailand for a while. Luckily a cheaper option came along, negotiated by an Australian lawyer, and I suddenly found myself with him and three others on the road to Lhasa. Deciding to end my tour with a big bang, I shelled out $220US to gain entry into China via Tibet. (I have to pay my respects to Confucius.)

The CITS negotiated tour initially was to be 9 days in total, but engine troubles had us stopping over at every small town and stretched the itinerary to 16 days. An absolute bonus at no extra cost! This, combined with Everest in all her glory, desert towns, monasteries, yak dumplings and burgers, have made the past three weeks a memorable experience. More than I ever expected to see. Dried sheep meat, Tibetan bread, 'moccasins' -- I think I am looking at the equivalent of North American Indians a hundred years ago, watching firsthand the cultural assimilation happen all over again. The 'white faces' being the Chinese this time.


The Tibet Adventure (Journal Entries)

To share a few moments -- journal entries, a route map and extra notes.

June 18, 1995 -- We started out from Zhangmu but were forced to turn back when a landslide made the road impossible to pass.

June 19, 1995 -- this entry comes at 12:43pm during our second attempt --

We've been stopped up at the landslide for 45 minutes. Two explosions just tore a large portion of rock down into the river. Before the two blasts the workers were running and motioning me to follow them to take shelter in amongst the trucks. I just looked at them and thought to myself "Yeah, right. What the hell do I need to go back there for." Our driver had just pulled the truck around the corner. I got out quite unconcerned and, rolling my eyes, began to follow then stopped. Not bothering to go any farther, thinking it quite safe, I peered down into the river valley through the fog. The first explosion echoed … nothing … for a few seconds, then rocks began thumping down not more than a few feet away. The driver and I, both standing in the middle of the road, looked at each other then tore for shelter against the face of the cliff. The second explosion threw even more rock into the air, some of it sliding down the rock face and whizzing past our heads. A couple vehicles received dents, but all of us are alive.

The next day after successfully darting past the landslide area, we awoke to the effects of the previous day's altitude climb. From 2300 meters in Zhangmu to 5200 meters at the top of the La-Lung-la pass, then descending to 4390 meters in Old Tingri to spend the night. June 20, 1995 11:08am --

Good morning. Awake by nine. I feel like a freight train has hit me or I've been in a wrestling match all night: the altitude effects. Dull ache in the head, muscles ache. Last night I had to bolt for the door because I thought I was going to woof my cookies. Fortunately a simple movement was enough in front of the nighttime dog audience. The night stars here have only been equaled by Egypt's Dahab and Pakistan's Chitral region. The sky is alive with lights.
The hot water for this morn's wash was especially fine. Then I took a stroll around the hotel's dirt walls. Out back a few tents are pitched with donkeys and cattle wandering. I managed to get a couple of photogenic kids snapped up onto film and then a few of the town intersection. Noodles, three eggs, biscuits, and hot chocolate for breakfast. And hey! Sheep dry meat! These people are too much.
The clouds! The clouds are so perfect up here! I could take a picture of anything and it would be beautiful.

The same day, after having advanced along the road towards Everest base camp, we began to experience the beginning of what was to be a long record of engine difficulties. 5:04pm --

Stuck in Chay. Oil leakage. Overheating, slowly we head back for Old Tingri where repairs can be made. In between our fits of laughter we chug a few extra kilometers down the road, snap a few pictures, then hover on exhaustion. Push starting the truck, winding it up, bunting the hanging dice to give ourselves the illusion of bouncing along down the road. The driver has got to be choked. What am I thinking, feeling? Well, my legs and arms are jello.

Then 6:20pm --

"Geo" -- the only word I may end up memorizing throughout all of China -- oil. We're camped outside some desert palace waiting for the owner to come back. The woman says, "He will be back before dark." Dark comes at 10:30pm. Anthony and Florence, when they first crossed the border into Zhangmu, talked to three sets of travelers. He found it amusing to hear all three groups say: "Nothing works according to plan in Tibet." And so our Mad Max (movie) madness continues in search of oil on top of the world. A dusty, baked moonscape where seldom any soul travels. Oxygen and oil -- precious stuff. As fellow pilgrim Dana says to her friend Martha -- "Hey! No grumpiness, remember?!"

June 21, 1995, 5:35pm (Old Tingri) --

Last night around 1:00am the driver comes noisily into the room, a candle was eventually found, and he kept repeating "OK", "OK" as he wobbled to and fro, seemingly to try and reassure himself more than me. "OK", "OK". Out blows the candle. Awake by ten, breakfast by eleven. I have two more provinces to review in my Planet China book. The driver (now sober) says he can fix the truck. We may be on the road tomorrow.

8:52pm --

Since the beginning of the trip we have had a puppy with us in the back of the truck. I took him out for a stroll earlier and now being back in the truck he won't shut up. (Local natives) Bimba and her sister had Florence done up in Tibetan dress when I returned. Her blushed (sunburned) face went with the purple blouse. She said the kids were mystified over a white-skinned Tibetan woman. Blond hair?!

10:26pm --

Not wanting to take the chill (of a falling sun) sitting down, I took a stroll back into Tingri town. The feathery sky, pink peaks, and stretched shadows. The dogs awake, construction slows, and folks cozy into doors. How far the West has come. Sheer brilliance. God-like brains. But this too, this hardness, simpleness -- mud floors and well water -- this too is beautiful. The fear of gods, of nature, superstitions, tales, colors -- I like the latter's imagery, but I could never substitute the former for the latter. How to blend? … Nature and knowledge …

June 22. With the truck 'fixed', we attempt to make Mount Everest base camp again (the road was not paved). At the bottom of the Pang-la pass is the town of Chay, the Chinese checkpoint at 4300 meters. Well, we found out in Chay that with our combined body weights the truck was having a difficult time ascending the road. Determined to force the driver to his contract and to see Everest up close, four of us got out and began to walk up the pass (the top of the pass being 5120 meters). Leaving Florence in the truck (weakened by the altitude) with the driver and his transmission problems, up we started walking.

Several hours later, watching the truck do a slow and steady ascent, it eventually worked out that I beat the truck to the top of the pass by cutting cross-country and going straight up the hills. Two hours later as the last head, Anthony, comes over the final edge of the road to plop himself beside the truck, he muttered: "I must be in so good of shape because of all the office work I do." As I wrote at 7:34pm --

Hotel Passumpembah. Town of Passum. This side of the Pang-la pass is pretty enough. What I thought would be devoid of all life is spotted with villages, canals and plots. Somehow the truck has pulled through this far. A flat tire has capped the day, and not wanting to push for the Rombuk monastery today and do the climb to the Everest base camp tomorrow, we are going to camp in this pad for the night, resume travel tomorrow, doing the climb the day after next. The days keep stretching! What used to be a nine day tour is turning into weeks! I love it! It may not be convenient for the other four, but for me it is ideal. I don't have a scheduled departure date from anywhere. Having paid a large lump sum all this extra time is gravy for my Tibetan itinerary.
The kids here (in Passum village) are walking dirtballs, snotrags and full of noise. Our driver is ready to have his heart burst due to high blood pressure, and the rest of the gang is exhausted. That unscheduled multi-hour climb has wiped out most of our group energy.

June 23, 1995, 5:11pm --

Well, good grief. Last night's sleep was eventful. Claustrophobia incorporated. I had the patent on it. Sweating, losing direction, massive world spins, lost in the darkness, short of breath -- and on top of it all, weirdo dreams.
We must have left Passum around 11:30am. Blood, sweat and tears -- literally -- to get here. Only two kilometers away from the monastery did our driver express himself again, almost pleading for us to agree to turn around: "There's nothing there! Why are we going there?!" For him, obviously, Mount Everest at 8848 meters not being a sufficient reason. Earlier too he had confirmed our thoughts as Dana translated his words: "If I had known what this road was like, I would have never agreed to this contract. I could have done Lhasa easily, but this side road to Everest is very, very bad." In an emotional moment, exhausted and frustrated, Florence let out some tears. And on we went.
Dana and I have seen the monastery with our own two eyes -- the scout patrol. Hopefully, in an hour plus, the remaining three will have the same opportunity. As the truck is not going to cross the stream (so says our driver), this leaves the last 2 kilometers to walk. Here goes …

June 24, 1995, 9:10am --

What a finish to yesterday! Managed to get across the stream (in our bare feet). After checking in we just about succeeded in burning the highest monastery in the world (at 5200m) to the ground trying to get Dana's kerosene stove to ignite. Her sitting in the doorway re-reading burnt instructions makes a good image for remembrance. Supper was eventually made -- noodles, hot chocolate and tea. Then water purification. Then preparation for Insomnia Round Two -- and a battle it was! Whew. I am glad to be awake. We're on the threshold of starting our walk to Base Camp I. Keep your fingers crossed for the clouds to clear.

The clouds did not clear that day, but the next day, June 25, 9:30am --

Everest is crystal clear!! Dana, Martha and I are going to Base Camp once again -- this is incredible!

In review of the day, a 9:33pm entry --

What was originally scheduled to be a 9:30am departure from Rombuk monastery was swept aside as the clouds covering Miss Everest decided to clear up and give us an eyeful. Eighty four minutes later I was back at the Base Camp. By 1:00pm the two girls and I were listening to three world class peak busters who were planning to complete the climb of Everest the beginning of August, allowing for sufficient acclimatization by means of a couple base camp progressions from now until then. Get this -- it costs $30,000 US to arrange a climb here on the Tibetan side. On the Nepalese side it is even more, a rumored $50,000 US (the fee is higher, the climb is easier). Rolex is the three gents main sponsor, and evidence of such hung about their wrists. Dana asked a ton of questions -- their route up the face, time, methods, equipment. All of it I found interesting but it left me as soon as it hit my ears.
Apparently, the first climber to scale Everest on the Tibetan side was done in 1980 when the Chinese began opening it up. The man did it by himself in two days -- his superior conditioning and knowledge of climbing being his assets. Then a few years later, two gents scaled it again by means of a different path up the face -- they did it in 39 hours, then slid down the entire mountain on their bums in 3.5 hours! The snow condition during the monsoon season allowed for it. Most climbs of Everest are during the month of May.

Having slept in Passum that night, the next day (June 26) somehow our truck made it over the Pass again. We caught a ride with an army truck over the pass to Chay, avoiding the walk. The night of the 26th we stayed in the town of Shegar where comes this late night entry, 11:25pm --

The hardest part of the tour has been completed. Though I know the tour is going to be fairly uncomplicated now that we are back on a main highway, I can't help but already miss the excitement of the unexpected. Of being prepared to scale passes, walk out of valleys, you know -- the exhausting effort which brings satisfaction, the pain which gives pleasure, work and accomplishment. Having pushed my limits then waking up to push them farther. I don't think I have had that much fun since Pakistan's mania tour!
The restaurant this evening, after our weekly wash, was the reason for my opening line (which was: "Wow, it's boggling to approach a larger, more organized and stocked town."). Chinese dishes -- like pork -- shelves stocked, pop and other refreshments, toilet paper (!), soaps, shampoos, jams -- a real store! Variety! Florence's cola sprayed all over her (a warning to me), the driver was well sloshed on his few beer, eating three huge plates of food by himself.
We all sat around joking about he last couple days' events, such as the driver: "It's 70 km to Rombuk -- we're not going to make it!" (he cries, on the verge of pulling his hair out). Or watching the driver ramming the gear stick, trying to get it to stay in first gear. At times having to hit it with all he's got, adding the classic line of "Chinese vehicles suck. Japanese vehicles are good" (our driver was Chinese). Or every time we came across a radio or TV, Anthony would translate for us the characters' lines (Anthony could not speak a word of Chinese) "I am sorry, we cannot issue you a permit to Lhasa. You need a permit." Or the dogs along the way have been interesting. The one in the Passum public toilet proved to surprise even me! He had fallen through the hole in the ground. As I was doing my thing he jumped up trying to get out. Or the staring squads of Tibetans in every village. All of them asking, with mouths salivating, for our empty plastic water bottles as if the emptiness in each could be converted to gold.

June 28, 1995. Written in review of June 27 --

What a day yesterday! Finally managing to piece the truck together, after lunch on main street Shegar, we sped to the highway. Made it a fair ways before the first abrupt stop, then the stops became increasingly frequent, the wrench and screwdriver making return stage appearances time and again, oil being poured out, mechanical bits coming undone. One time I think we spent several hours pulled over. I got bored of reading about Planet Tibet, so I took to one of the fields roadside, found an nice pad of green grass, and listened to the tinkers and baas of the herds being led along the hillsides as I drifted in and out of sleep.
By 8:20pm we had reached the top of the Lama-la pass (5220m), snapped a few photos, then whisked down the valley road to here, the town and war zone of Lhtzse. The Friendship Highway has been demolished and is being re-done in these parts, so imagine us driving though fields (desert fields) in the dark trying to find the right path to make it to town. The whole area is flooded, roads seemed to drift off in every direction, and then we hit this bridge which was on the verge of collapsing, literally. Well, after backing down on trying to cross it, tempers began to flare: inpatient, tired -- both the driver and Dana ignited into quarrel. The driver said "Enough!", picked this kid off the 'street' and we managed to find our way to a hotel without any problems after that. Well, I mean the road maze. Hotel price was 30 yuan, and after more discussion all agreed to pay and get the damn day over with. Nice rooms though.
Then the dog "Mimi" disappeared. After a brief search we gave up, headed for the restaurant across the 'street' and stuffed our faces full of Chinese dishes. Tempers died, smiles appeared and -- as stomachs filled -- friends we became once again. Pig's snout, ears, tongues -- cauliflower, eggrolls, beansprouts, salted vegetables, egg soup, fried rice -- you name it, we ate it. The party died shortly after midnight and we all gratefully collapsed on our beds to end a loooong day.

June 29, 1995. Spending a few days in Lhtzse, "Mimi" the meal resurfaced for a while but then mysteriously disappears again. At long last the truck is 'fixed'. The pup is left behind as lost.

July 1, 1995. An entry written on the village and monastery of Sakya seen the previous day --

Having arrived at the Sakya monastery shortly before 2:00 pm, I did not get to see much besides wandering around the perimeter walls to snap a few photos. When I heard that the main building (temple) opened at 4:00 pm for pilgrims to enter I took to the town. Had a bite to eat with the others, then crawled up the rocks into the village heights, snapped a few street photos, then by 4:30 was walking through the monastery doors.
The other pilgrims (Tibetans) were all older -- those who would remember the Dalai Lama's departure from Tibet. I followed them first to the left chamber which was filled with colors. Apart from natural light through the doorway and some high windows allowing strings of light to enter the chamber, the place was dark. It provided a very mystical and awe-inspiring sensation, accenting the towering pictures of the walls, the hundreds of miniature statues on shelves (climbing 40 feet or so to the ceiling), and the huge central figures four or five times my height -- gazing into the 'ocean of wisdom'. Supporting pillars were covered in various colored cloth, seats lingered for those occasions when pilgrims would too -- but not this time.
Following the older crowd I traced a route though the left chamber as they threw rice, deposited moneys, spoke prayers, prostrated, and bought paper flags. Finished with the left chamber we crossed the courtyard into the right chamber. This was the one to take my breath away. Lit like the first, with only threads of sunlight sneaking in from the small ceiling windows, three huge chortens were the main display surrounded by hundreds of smaller ornaments, hangings, idols, stands, pictures, paintings. Fantastically beautiful, one of the most impressive displays of religion I've seen in my life. Every inch of wall was smothered in art.
Once completed the chamber route, we again filed out into the central courtyard and entered the central chamber where a huge Buddha (and other statues) pierced us with his gaze. Ritual continued as like with the first two chambers. The final punch to the whole circuit was being allowed into the back of this chamber, into the library. For a good 100m (?) in length, 40 feet in height, books were stacked. Book upon book upon book behind a mesh wire. Scriptures accumulated over centuries all piled into one massive collection. Again, only strands of light peeked through the dust-covered windows high overhead. The one common thought to strike the five of us (who were all together again): the warehouse scene in the closing frames of the movie Indian Jones and the Raiders of the Lost Ark. Books layered with years of dust, some metal-covered. Had it all been translated? Were there copies? How had this whole complex survived the Chinese Cultural Revolution?
With such thoughts, our driver hurriedly pulled us out of Sakya and towards Shigatse. Radiator fixed, we made good time, arriving just after 11:00pm. There were even paved sections of highway! One thing of particular notice, the country and town people became much more appealing as we approached the more settled populations. Cleaner, brighter, healthier looking. Excuse me, I have a town to see …

Later on that day, 3:20pm --

From the restaurant, danced though the market streets -- I saw nothing but manufactured 'garbage' from other countries (Nepal, India). Not even a simple bracelet made of Tibetan spine to buy. I quickly found out that Shigatse's monastery opened at four so I took to the hills, stumbled on to the pilgrim circuit of the town. People have painted the rocks with Buddhist images.

Notes on the Shigatse monastery, 4:22pm --

The first building housed the 27m high statue of Buddha. Considering I'm approximately 1.8m high myself, it's a towering 15 times higher than me. The second sky temple housed three Halloween looking types (of statues) -- excellent faces. I wonder how they built these idols -- poured then pieced together in sections? Now in the Great Tenth Panchen Lama's Guilded Stupa Sisumnamgyal. Surrounding a high stupa, giving its admirers a neck ache looking up at it, the ceilings are coated in mandalas, the walls with fiery demons in various postures, and a thousand Buddhas cover the extra. The fourth chamber along the circuit housed a poorer man's model of number three -- needs reconditioning, at least the wall murals do. Now, in the moment of climax, in the courtyard of the Great Hall; as the book reads "The Grand Hall -- it's opulent tomb of the fourth Panchen Lama, containing 85kg of gold and masses of jewels."

July 2, 1995, visiting the town of Gyantse. "Gyantse Kumbum: a magnificent tiered structure now unique in the Buddhist world. Built 1440 AD. The stupa rises over four symmetrical floors and is surmounted by a gold dome that rises like a crown over four sets of eyes that gaze serenely out in the cardinal directions of the compass." A 10:19pm entry --

G'day. Broke Gyantse's limits by 1:30pm. Crawled out of lunch by three, in the monastery by four. Oh yeah, chewed on a chicken's feet at lunch. The driver ate the whole head. Another feast. The monastery had 108 chambers or mini-temples filled with murals and idols. Early on I took to rummaging through the money piles of donations, exchanging larger bills for smaller ones to supplement my Chinese collection. Found some nice ones. Oh yeah, the temple was okay too. The top tier with four huge chapels was the best. Mandala heaven, beautiful art work. From the monastery I scaled the Dzong's (town fortress) heights to have a 360 degree view of the town, the monastery and the valley. Descended to the town afterwards to watch people.

By July 4 we had entered Lhasa, capital city of Tibet (province). As it came to be written: "Lhasa -- a city … which has blown away all our previous 'dusty', 'unpaved', 'unlit', 'backwards' conceptions. This is a city proper all right, including the massive Yak Hotel where we stay as well as a flashy Holiday Inn a few kilometers down the road. 2:47pm --

Just downed a Yak Burger. We're at the Hard Yak Café in the Holiday Inn. Now we're going in for a banana split in the next shop over.

July 5 we said goodbye to our driver with one last feast --

… the last supper -- octopus, pig pieces (unidentifiable), peppers, more chicken heads, and lots of other goodies. Toasts, last quips, and chop-stick action to round out a couple weeks of adventure. With the good-byes over the five of us closed out the day with cheesecake at Tashi's.

July 7, with the group dissolved and returned to singular status, 7:54pm --

From the bank I took a stroll behind the Potala Palace to take a couple of photos, then turned my attention to the Post Office to mail off some Nepal postcards. I met two Tibetans, one who speaks very good English, while I was parked on the sidewalk watching the shoe repairers. A quick exchange, I didn't think much more about it. I moved on, made some photocopies. I noticed the Chinese businessman give his near-empty soup bowl to the Tibetan kids hanging around outside as a convenient garbage for him, then he laughed with the shop peoples. Interesting, the Tibetans have been reduced to beggars.
From there, my headache growing, I made my way to Tashi's to eat some grub. Lo and behold -- the two Tibetans. The one who speaks good English -- she's from Calgary. Born in India in 1962, emigrated to Canada in 1987, this is the first time she's been in her homeland. She leaves Tibet tomorrow so our meeting was only a one shot affair. She mentioned several times how much Tibetans would appreciate me being active vocally in Canada about the conditions in Tibet. She too thought North American Indians resembled the Tibetans -- historical similarities, clothing, facial features.
She went on to discuss eating habits, praying, purification rituals, yak butter candles in the temples (symbolic of wanting the light to shine in all peoples' minds), village conditions, prisons. It is all too obvious that Tibetans are second class citizens in their own land. A fact reinforced by employment statistics I'm sure -- only Chinese-speaking Tibetans get decent jobs with the Chinese. The Chinese military does village tours every so often to tell the locals to obey, basically saying: "We can do anything we want. Listen. If you want your monasteries open, keep your mouths shut." Tibet, for the Chinese, is about resources and living space. The loudspeakers which broadcast during the day in various towns and cities is propaganda.
During her time in Tibet 25 days were spent in a village outside Lhasa. The rest of the time she visited surrounding monasteries around Lhasa (4 days) and stayed in Lhasa itself with family. She spoke of how many people in the villages had little or nothing of nutritional quality to eat. In many villages clean water did not exist. Local people needed to get permits to travel between villages. As for the prisons, they are packed. One could pay money to be let out of prison for murdering somebody, but to speak out against Chinese rule constituted a permanent position in a cell.
It was unfortunate, but as she spoke my headache kept pounding harder, until by the end of our talk I was ready to keel over in pain. She paid for my meal (she said it was a substitute as she would have liked to invite me to a family supper, but as this was her last day it would be a little too personal -- I agreed), we exchanged addresses, then off they scooted.
Her visa took six months to obtain from the Chinese consulate in Ottawa: "you can enter Tibet June 1. You must leave by July 13. We will give you a visa as long as you keep your mouth shut when you get back." Throughout our conversation she was repeatedly looking around, lowering her voice. It is a well-known fact in the backpacker world that Lhasa is filled with plain-clothes spy personnel, including the hotels we stay in.

We can't have anyone speaking against Chairman Mao now, can we?


A Philosophy For Living On Earth

Bits Of China & Confucianism

In China proper, as money begins to become a decisive factor, there are only a few definite points I would really like to see. One of them is the burial site of Confucius; another is the mausoleum of Genghis Khan in Inner Mongolia. But to stand over Confucius will be the highpoint of China. Of all the Eastern religions and philosophies, Confucianism is the one I am most attracted to. To tell you the truth, I can't stand the rest!

You have commented on my tolerance towards people's faiths -- well, I would like to think it true when it comes to the people themselves. But when it comes down to the religious philosophy I am not so lenient, and I am taking a progressively harder line as time passes and definitions are clarified. As much as I inquire into such lines of thought, I despise most of it. Apart from three small sects in Christianity which have potential, the Jews are of special interest to me. Judaism sprinkled with spots of Confucianism -- what a pair! Three fantastic examples of Confucian writing (of the hundreds I extracted) --

(1) The Master said, "At fifteen, I had my mind bent on learning.
"At thirty, I stood firm.
"At forty, I had no doubts.
"At fifty, I knew the decrees of Nature.
"At sixty, my ear was an obedient organ for the reception of truth.
"At seventy, I could follow what my heart desired, without transgressing what was right."

(2) To be able to follow what one's heart desires without transgressing moral principles merely means that one's mind has reached full maturity.

(3) Prepare for the difficult while it is still easy.
Deal with the big while it is still small.
Difficult undertakings have always started with what is easy.
And great undertakings have always started with what is small.
Therefore the sage never strives for the great,
And thereby the great is achieved.


Mind, Body, Soul

To round off this letter I will address any nagging doubts that may be dwelling in your minds. I remember the Boxing Day phone call when Nana cautiously asked about my ashram and Hinduism inquiry: "This is only temporary isn't it?" In reply I will say yes and no. My curiosity, I think, will never cease. In this sense, no. In my eyes religion is one of the most powerful motivating factors in many human beings' lives, and this is by no means a dying trend (Islam's birth-rate is soaring). To understand rather than shun them is one of my ambitions. As for becoming a pawn to any particular organization or religion, forget it. I'm my own man. I do not need any mediator between me and my conceptions of truth, guiding me, instructing me, sheltering me, 'taking care' of me, etc. That I killed when I returned to University for the second time to begin working things out on my own.

I will never fail to give credit to the religions I have studied and learned from (each has contributed to my perceiving the subtle ways men have spliced reality), but to lock myself away in one, to me, is anti-truth. To shelter myself in such a 'loving brotherhood' is the day I choose stagnation as my God, pumped full of propaganda and self-less dogma. A man, if he wants to find the answers, has to do it on his own. This was the purpose of my retreat in Rishikesh, not to become a monk high in the Himalayas, hoping, working for a better reincarnation the next time around, but to inquire into the causes of why I am the way I am.

As one writer puts it: "The control of the mind is not important; what is important is to find out the interests of the mind," or as another writes: "Don't ignore your own desires .... don't sacrifice them. examine their cause." I'm not afraid to say "I am wrong" or that I may have made pre-mature decisions on an issue. It's all a part of learning -- X's and checkmarks. Ultimately, I am my own evaluator. Unfortunately I am not as free of people's influence as I would like to be, though I find myself a lot more integrated than the tens of thousands of Humpty Dumpties wandering around me aimlessly and broken. I expect only to get stronger, more focused, as time passes. As I find the right formula to put the pieces together.

I will not hesitate to call myself a radical -- yes, I have heard this description applied to me many times already. The most probable reason as to why Dumpties find me radical is the plain fact that I think. Despite what hell it may take me through (only because I must deal with those who do not think), I cannot run away. I have to know.

One of Ayn Rand's sentences I have extracted from Atlas Shrugged is: "There are no evil thoughts except one: the refusal to think." -- and this summarizes it all for me. My first girlfriend's sarcastic name of 'Mr. Logic Man' is a title I will bear with a grin from ear to ear. As Blaise Pascal noted: "All man's dignity lies in his thought." The animals of the field do not have the ability to think like a human being - only we do. To shun thought is to shun being a human being. To not think is to degrade man in the worst way one can. To reject thinking is to reject man's beauty, his potential greatness -- ultimately, his existence -- in short, all I find sacred.

To draw a comparison: my body is the temple, my mind is the altar, my thought -- my devotion to life itself. If I am to believe in a God, as I inescapably must, then I find that this is the highest form of acknowledgement one can render. I live, not for ritual and superstition, but for the pleasure and potential of my own life. I do not desire to go to a mystical place called 'heaven,' and certainly not to a place called 'hell'. I do not believe in reincarnation and the cycle of rebirths. I understand that I am a man, that my *body is my soul,* and that earth is my heaven.

I have found very, very few people who see the way I do, or who are even remotely aware of the immensely significant differences between religions. In this light, my respect and admiration for (pre-exilic) Judaism comes to the forefront. (I saved Israel for a reason, I want to see it properly when I cross its borders.)


A Rational Self-Interest

I have grown weary listening to people preach about "the sin of our existence" (Christianity, Islam), that "human life is suffering" (Hinduism, Buddhism) -- and in candid opposition to such lines of thought, something which I have been recently incorporating into my personal philosophy is Ayn Rand's detailed conviction that the ego, or the self, -- the individual -- is the fountainhead of human progress, that altruism (self-denial; placing the value of one's own self below that of others) is evil, that man can only live for himself and no one else. A re-occurring idea of hers is: "Man exists for the achievement of his desires," and "Every honest man lives for himself. The man who doesn't -- doesn't live at all." Or perhaps one of the best one-liners: "To say 'I love you' one must first know how to say the 'I'."

Rather than the 'evil' or 'reckless/thoughtless' overtones many people improperly assign to the term 'ego,' she has developed a new concept of egoism -- in terms of a rational self-interest -- and goes on to distinctly clarify the meaning of the words she uses, something Confucius called 'the rectification of names' and saw as essential if men were to begin understanding one another and come closer to the true nature of things. As Aristotle reasoned that the 'highest good for man should be attainable by most free men through the exercise of that faculty that makes us man, mainly reason,' she continues along these lines emphasizing that man must learn how to live:

"Man has no automatic code of survival" (no instincts or fixed action patterns as plants and animals have) "He has no automatic course of action, no automatic set of values. His senses do not tell him automatically what is good for him or evil, what will benefit his life or endanger it, what goals he should pursue and what means will achieve them, what values his life depends on, what course of action it requires. His own consciousness has to discover the answers to all these questions - but his consciousness will not function automatically. Man, the highest living species on this earth - the being whose consciousness has a limitless capacity for gaining knowledge - man is the only living entity born without any guarantee of remaining conscious at all. Man's particular distinction from all other living species is the fact that his consciousness is volitional."
"Nothing is given to man on earth except a potential and the material on which to actualize it. The potential is a superlative machine: his consciousness; but it is a machine without a spark plug, the self-starter and the driver; he has to discover how to use it and he has to keep it in constant action. The material is the whole of the universe, with no limits set to the knowledge he can acquire and to the enjoyment of life he can achieve. But everything he needs or desires has to be learned, discovered and produced by him - by his own choice, by his own effort, by his own mind.
"A being who does not know automatically what is true or false, cannot know automatically what is right or wrong, what is good for him or evil. Yet he needs that knowledge in order to live. He is not exempt from the laws of reality, he is a specific organism of a specific nature that requires specific actions to sustain his life.(emphasis mine-GW) He cannot achieve his survival by arbitrary means nor by random motions nor by blind urges nor by chance nor by whim. That which his survival requires is set by his nature and is not open to his choice. What is open to his choice is only whether he will discover it or not, whether he will choose the right goals and values or not. He is free to make the wrong choice, but not free to succeed with it. He is free to evade reality, he is free to unfocus his mind and stumble blindly down any road he pleases, but not free to avoid the abyss he refuses to see. Knowledge, for any conscious organism, is the means of survival; to a living consciousness, every "is" implies an "ought." Man is free to choose not to be conscious, but not free to escape the penalty of unconsciousness: destruction. Man is the only living species that has the power to act as his own destroyer - and that is the way he has acted through most of his history.
"What, then, are the right goals for man to pursue? What are the values his survival requires? That is the question to be answered by the science of ethics. And this is why man needs a code of ethics." And, as "ethics is an objective, metaphysical necessity of man's survival" ... "the purpose of morality is to teach you, not to suffer and die, but to enjoy yourself and live."

Her philosophy, Objectivism, is an argument that forcibly grabs one's attention, and she has brought me to begin thinking about political systems: her clearly made choice, laissez-faire capitalism, with its foundation upon individual rights and opportunity / freedom for that individual to create -- (1,4 - Nathaniel Branden; 2,3 - Ayn Rand)

(1) Capitalism, by its nature, entails a constant process of motion, growth and progress. It creates the optimum social conditions for man to respond to the challenges of nature in such a way as best to further his life. It operates to the benefit of all those who choose to be active in the productive process, whatever their level of ability. But it is not geared to the demands of stagnation. Neither is reality.

(2) There's nothing of any importance in life -- except how well you do your work. Nothing. Only that. Whatever else you are, will come from that. It's the only measure of human value. All the codes of ethics they'll try to ram down your throat are just so much paper money put out by swindlers to fleece the people of their virtues. The code of competence is the only system of morality that's on a gold standard.

(3) "Every man builds his world in his own image," he said. "he has the power to choose, but no power to escape the necessity of choice. If he abdicates his power, he abdicates the status of man, and the grinding chaos of the irrational is what he achieves as his sphere of existence -- by his own choice. Whoever preserves a single thought uncorrupted by any concession to the will of others, whoever brings into reality a matchstick or a patch of garden made in the image of his thought -- he, and to that extent, is a man, and that extent is the sole measure of his virtue."

(4) If a man defaults on the responsibility of seeking knowledge, choosing values and setting goals -- if this is the sphere he surrenders to the authority of others -- how is he to escape the feeling that the universe is closed to him? It is. By his own choice.

The proper answer to the question --

And how am I to face the odds
Of man's bedevilment and god's?
A stranger and afraid
In a world i never made

-- is: why didn't you?


Against Altruism

Having been squashed into the altruistic creed in my early twenties; having seen the mess created in Northern Indian communities (Canada) where money is freely given, undeservedly, and the result is boredom, restlessness, a lack of self-esteem, anxiety, and bitterness -- a stagnation of the community where no one gets anywhere except drunk -- it has not taken much to convince me that altruism is a slow suffocation and road to decadence -- a creed heavily based on the body and (immortal) soul duality throughout the world. Friedrich Nietzsche:

Of altruism: The praise of the selfless, the self-sacrificial, the 'virtuous' - that is, of those who do not apply their whole strength and reason to their own preservation, development, elevation, promotion, and the expansion of their power, but rather live, in relation to themselves, modestly and thoughtlessly, perhaps even with indifference or irony (as a sacrificial animal - gw) - this praise certainly was not born from the spirit of selflessness. The "neighbor" praises selflessness because it brings him advantages. If the neighbor himself were "selfless" in his thinking, he would repudiate this diminution of strength, this mutilation for his benefit; he would work against the development of such inclinations, and above all he would manifest his selflessness by not calling it good !
This indicates the fundamental contradiction in the morality that is very prestigious nowadays: the motives of this morality stand opposed to its principle. What this morality considers its proof is refuted by its criterion of what is moral. In order not to contravene its own morality, the demand "you shall renounce yourself and sacrifice yourself" could be laid down only by those who thus renounced their own advantage and perhaps brought about their own destruction through the demanded sacrifice of individuals. But as soon as the neighbor (or society) recommends altruism for the sake of its utility, it applies the contradictory principle. "you shall seek your advantage even at the expense of everything else" - and thus one preaches, in the same breath, a "thou shalt" and "thou shalt not."


Closing Words

Put another way, if I was pressured or forced to have to serve a God, a state, a family, or another person -- how I would despise life (and I did). It has only been since I left the religion, the University, etc., and started doing things for my self that I have come to learn anything, progressed anywhere, done something. It has taken me five years time, but having selected the meats and vegetables for the core of my philosophical recipe for practical living, I will now concentrate on the subtler points, the shades, the spices ....

In answer to the last letter I wrote: How can I best help others? A: By continuing what I have been doing and helping myself first. If I had listened to all my religious 'brothers,' been pressured to submit to their form of ritual salvation, the individual I am today would not exist. Having been served the best of their reasoning until it tore me apart, I now plan to turn religion on its head, busting the altruistic creed, and asserting the way of the self in its place, the way of the creator ....

Influenced by Rand, Nietzsche, Voltaire, Jung, Hesse, Russell and many others, if I had to summarize the learning of the first twenty-five years of my life in three statements, they would be these:

(1) Man's nature, if he is to self-actualize, is to think.

"There is one art of which every man should be a master. The art of reflection. If you are not a thinking man, to what purpose are you a man at all?"

(2) In Rand's words: "Every code of ethics is based on and derived from a metaphysics, that is: from a theory about the fundamental nature of the universe in which man lives and acts."

(3) Jehovah is reality, reality is law; Jehovah is not independent of his law, he is law, and law is life.

"Reality is law. If a man chooses to examine and exercise law, then reality will respond. It will thrust him up to ever greater heights of achievement. If he chooses to ignore law, then reality will erase him."

Throughout this tour one of the most teeth-grinding truths I have seen is that men are still looking for a leader, unwilling to assume the responsibility of working problems out for themselves. So when nothing works out, they have a thousand scapegoats to blame.

As for my Paper, I am dissatisfied with what I do have at present. Section II, Government, is now doubled in size and currently resting in scissored pieces waiting to be reformulated. Perhaps when I reach thirty or fifty (?) pages I will be able to accept it as a comprehensive and competent explanation of the way I see history taking place: the greatest moral crisis the world has ever known. I have not worked on it for a few months. I was too busy reviewing Confucianism and finishing up my notes on the Qur'an before I left Rishikesh.

After China, I am going to have to cast my eyes towards North America. I was thinking earlier that if I could manage to buy a ticket to Hawaii and then onto Vancouver I would be ecstatic. For I would love to relax on the sand for a while. But this looks unlikely as I am going to be pushing my funds to their limits. The few people I have told this to chuckle when they hear it, but good grief, I seriously need a vacation. I'll relax in the land of polar bears I guess, with muktuk and raw fish to fatten me up. Or maybe I will head to Guizhou province here in China. I hear they have a delicacy of live rat embryos nicknamed the 'three squeals', since the embryo squeals when you pick it up with your chopsticks, once again when you dip it in soy sauce, and finally when you put it in your mouth ... or so the story goes.

Take care, enjoy the summer sun -- and I will see you in a few months!






Return to Letters & Poems




Website & Webpage July1995 are
Property of VamKam Inc.
URL: http://www.oocities.org/tsiktsikcd/july1995.html