The Information Age and the
Effects of Therapy
In the Field of Mental Health
by Joscelyn Curtis Levine
In this piece, for all of you who would like
enlightenment pertaining to a wonderful branch of therapy in the field
of Mental Health, and for all who would like to know a little more about
a certain brand of therapy, I will discuss sources that illustrate
the effects of information and/or technology on the focus of Art Therapy.
I will provide the links for the sources, and explain the effects or issues
the sites provide information, and then, explain why I think these issues
or effects are relevant to my field, the field of Mental Health.
Perhaps, after reading this, you may be interested in this
as well.
First, I would like to talk about my topic in
relation to the Mental Health field. I am primarily interested in therapies
related to abnormal behaviors such as, addictions, affective disorders,
alcoholism,
conduct
disorder , dissociative
disorders, neuroses, psychopathy, phobias, psychoses,
psychosomatic illnesses, mental retardation,
and some very rare
conditions such as and
Multiple Minds.
I am particularly interested in multiple
personality and schizophrenia.
I am interested in the biological differences in their brain function,
and that of normal brain function. The resulting prognosis of my findings
will be significant, in that you will be able to see the significant difference
in physical attributes of the two brains. In my interest, my intent in
studying mental illness is to, but not limited to, finding and diagnosing
the problem, observing behaviors associated with the problem and coming
up with various theraputic constructive methods to modify the behavior
associated with the
problem.
In order to simplify things, I have chosen art
therapy as a single, more specific topic of interest that I would incorporate
in my work. That website provides lots of information for the prospective
Art Therapist. In the Multiple Minds website, you can see that therapy
at work. Scroll down once you get into the site. See how art plays a role
in therapy for the mind. There is a new and exciting field of art therapy
out there, and it's very healing. I don't want to sound too New Age-ish,
but Art and healing are joining and becoming one. The healer is discovering
that art, music, dance and poetry have profound healing effects. Doctors,
nurses, and therapists are now working with artists and musicians to heal
people of all ages with many conditions including cancer and AIDS. Healers
have found that art and music, combined with traditional medicine are powerful
healing tools. At the same time, artisits and musicians have found that
art and music heals themselves and others around them.
Sexual Abuse
Early childhood sexual abuse results in many
disorders, and Multiple Personality Disorder (MPD) commonly develops when
abuse begins at an early age, aggressive coercion is used to silence, violence
is present, and the perpetrator is a primary caretaker (especially a father
figure). Many
children resort to trauma coping defenses such
as dissociation, denial, splitting, idealizing the perpetrator, grandiosity
to restore feelings of self esteem, helplessness, and the repression of
anger which can bring perpetrator retaliation. Childhood sexual abuse occurs
in the majority of MPD victims, interfering with identity formation.
Most cases of multiple personality have histories
of early sexual abuse by family members (Incest), and usually includes
physical abuse to obtain victim co-operation and silence. Physical abuse
frequently begins when children develop speech. Recovered Memory (resurfacing
of childhood memories for abuse) is a common symptom when sexual abuse
includes physical abuse and
violence meant to silence the child. Recent
research in neuroscience demonstrates the biochemical basis for an abuse
victim's memory loss in child sexual abuse cases. Physical abuse is present
in a large percentage of sexual abuse experiences that involve family members
or
acquaintances.
Child neglect is a common finding in cases of
early childhood sexual abuse, physical abuse and
multiple personality. Neglect either overtly
or covertly allows family breakdown of sexual boundaries and subverts protective
parental instincts that normally would shield children
from harm.
Severe early childhood abuse frequently results
in Borderline Personality or Multiple Personality Disorder (MPD), currently
called Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID). Psychic trauma caused by childhood
sexual abuse, incest, physical abuse and neglect, frequently opens permanent
fractures in early childhood personality development. Intimacy becomes
equated with sexual or physical abuse, exploitation, and personality enmeshment
with the perpetrator.
Can psychotherapy really help restore personality
integration to victims of early childhood sexual and/or physical abuse?
Yes! Medical science now has the proof. Brain scans of clients before and
after undergoing psychotherapy dramatically demonstrates that normal thinking
and behaving can be restored through the therapy process! Victims of severe
early childhood sexual and physical abuse resulting in multiple personality,
have compensating rewards awaiting them following personality integration.
Therapy can restore functioning, while preserving the extraordinary talents
they developed to survive childhood abuse. Recent discoveries using PET
Scan neuroimaging techniques demonstrates that therapy restores normal
functioning by rerouting neural connections and increasing metabolic processes
in dormant regions within the brain, which were distorted and blunted during
prolonged early childhood abuse.
Click on Art
Methods, and you will see a beautiful website with all the wonderful
colors of an Art Therapy website. This particular site gives fantastic
information on methods and the application of art. It provides a wonderful
source of step-by-step procedures actually showing all the techniques that
computer technology could provide. I particularly enjoyed this website,
because I can always use new and teriffic ideas to enhance and enrich my
art experience. Not only was the website convienent, but every page I experienced
turned out to be loaded with beautiful colors and lots of information.
I was getting happy just turning the pages!
Art
programs in hospitals is a new and exciting website devoted to the
therapist who wants to bring
art to sick people. What a fantastic program
not just for the mentally ill, but the physically
handicapped as well. How
Art Heals the Mind has always been amazing to me. This website contains
pertinent information regarding Color Therapy as healing. This is something
everyone needs to know. I would eventually like to apply my knowledge
to the healing arts in the Mental Health hospitals, but now, after visiting
these websites, I am getting interested in Children's hospitals
as well!
Art,
Art Education, & Art Therapy at ArtForce1 is based on a philosophy,
which empowers the person and helps to make them more self-directed. That
is what the aim and scope. And I need to recognize at the outset that most
of us resist owning our power, becoming self-directed. We've been used
too long; to be told by others what to do, and more often, what not to
do. This has led us to believe that we are incapable of knowing for ourselves.
We sum it up; we ask others what's best. We give up
our power to parents, teachers, employers, the
clergy, and politicians - all those who profess to know best for us.
Using my resources in Art Therapy, I aim to
reverse this process. A student will ask me a question. I'll say: what
do you think? The student can then discover that she knows the answer within
herself. She has reclaimed a little of her power, has begun her journey
towards becoming
person-centered.
The necessary learning does not occur through
reading about, writing about, talking about the criteria of traditional
education, but through much personal work. First, we need to discover what
gets in the way of being person-centered. Old automatic strategies learned
in our childhood need to be
identified. Only after such often painful uncovering
can we relinquish the old, be available to the new. So we spend much time
during the beginnings of Art Therapy being empathetic, accepting and genuine,
before we can begin to extend that way of being to others. This can be
a
very slow process.
Part of our identity and learning about our
past, is to be commited to the society in which we live. I have experienced
its benefit for myself. I offer it as a counselor, and as a trainer. I
know that personal development can occur in a climate of acceptance, empathy,
and genuineness. I know when an
individual is regarded as trustworthy and responsible,
and she or he can move towards a more autonomous way of being. So why add
another component - art?
Through research conducted mainly at the California
Institute of Technology by Roger Sperry (1973), the separate functions
of the two hemispheres of the brain were revealed, showing that each hemisphere
perceives reality in its own way. The mode of the left brain is thinking,
analytic, judgmental, and verbal; the right side of the brain is non-verbal,
spatial, spontaneous, intuitive, creative, non-judgmental. Sperry says:
"Modern society discriminates against the right hemisphere." In education,
science and the workplace, academic knowing, rather than intuitive knowing,
is favored as selection criteria, a value judgment.
In therapy, a microcosm of society, it can happen
that by "talking about it" the client can stay in his or her lift side
of the brain, and not connect with repressed material on the right side
of the brain - the very material needed for integration. By introducing
imaging, made visible in art form, and working with it in a person-centered
mode, integration can occur. Part of the person's identity is challenged
when only one side of the brain is being tapped.
Images contain messages from the subconscious
- perhaps hopes or fears - needing to bee known. Alice Miller (1987) writes
that "the spontaneous images I began to do helped me not only to discover
my personal story by also to free myself from the intellectual constraints
and concepts of my upbringing and my professional training." When thoughts
are pushed aside, spontaneous images can emerge: symbolic aspects of the
self, in need of recognition. Art Therapy helps one to connect to the visual
memory and it allows images to present themselves to the inner eye. One
can make those images visible in art form. One of the best ways to do this
is to try to elicit the meaning of the image with a person-centered facilitator,
while keeping the client's identity in tact.
We are born creative, even though our culture
may not value creativity. With art we can rediscover our creative force
which releases such an amazing array of symbolic images. They come to us,
bearing their gifts, and a person-centered counselor can help us recognize
such gifts. Somehow, by thinking less, it is possible to know more. Working
with art is, in itself, a creative spontaneous process, as the counselor
moves from words to image, to feelings to body language, to wider reflections.
Wherever the focus of the moment, counselor and client proceed on a journey
into the unknown, a magical
world of color.
Art Therapy and Psychology
Counseling with the therapeutic use of art is
most helpful: imaging can be suggested "on the hoof" during a session,
to explore further a feeling, a situation, and an emotive word. Psychologists
apply art in many ways.
Roger Sperry mentions a woman who talked about
her friend who had promised to ring her the previous night, and did not
do so. She felt disappointed, abandoned. I suggested she close her eyes
and let an image come to her to do with bandoned" She drew a baby in a
cot, crying, a wall, and a woman the other side of the wall turned away.
She spoke of herself, the baby, and the mother who never came when she
wanted her. She was amazed. A memory from pre-verbal times. Thus far all
her work in therapy to do with issues if inclusion and exclusion had not
brought up this memory. The image connected her to the source of her belief
in herself as being unlovable, as someone to be excluded, to her exclusion
of herself.
Psychologists ask questions pertaining to the
whys of people. Because psychology is the science concerned with behavior,
both humans and animals, it is only about 125 years old. Despite its youth,
it is a broad discipline, essentially spanning subject matter from biology
to sociology. Biology
studies the structures and functions of living
organisms. Sociology examines how groups function in
Art Therapy and Anthropology
In addition to Art Therapy applied to psychological
aspects of mental illnesses and memory, ethical behavior from an anthropological
standpoint is discussed here. The individual acquires from his group an
extensive list of manners and customs. What a man eats and drinks and how
he does so, what
sorts of sexual behavior he engages in, how
he builds a house or draws a picture or rows a boat, what subjects he talks
about, what music he makes, what kinds of personal relationships he enters
into and what kinds he avoids - all depend in part upon the practices of
the group of which he is a member. The actual manners and customs
of many groups have, of course, been extensively
described by sociologists and anthropologists.
Here we are concerned only with the kinds of
processes, which they exemplify. From an anthropologist's
point of view, art is and was the integral part of communication in the
Stone Age. Early man drew on rock communicating with his family and friends.
They were dependant upon the communication in their social environment
for ways in which they did physical things, and built things, rowed a boat,
for example, they depended in part upon certain mechanical contingencies;
some movements are effective and others ineffective in propelling the boat.
Many of these activities depended on how well they applied their skills
in drawing. So, Art Therapy goes way back and there are signs of this throughout
the Stone Age.
Expressive Art Therapy
There are further, more specific characteristics
of the therapy side and the consulting and education side, but I believe
we have enough here to begin a larger dialogue on this subject. Perhaps
it does need to be said that the whole therapy process is rapidly growing,
forming and finding itself. The
expressive arts therapy process is more known
as a separate field of endeavor, but there are still a wide range of practitioners.
As the laws (or lack of laws) for psychotherapists and counselors vary
widely in different states of the U.S., and even more widely in different
countries, there are different expressive arts therapists who are clinical
psychologists, psychiatrists, social workers, mental health counselors,
marriage family and child counselors, pastoral counselors, school counselors,
adjunctive
therapists, etc., etc. The field of expressive
arts consulting and education is even broader and less defined. It includes
the incorporation of the expressive arts into: organizational consulting,
health education and hospital care, public health administration, human
resource management, arts
education, creativity development, education
in the areas of personal growth and human potential, community arts projects,
elementary, secondary, undergraduate and graduate education, and in
many other areas of human need. This field
is even less articulated and defined than the therapy side, it is only
now coming together and forming its identity.
BIBLIOGRAPHY