A TRADE UNION RESPONSE
TO THE ALBERTA GOVERNMENT EDUCATION
ROUND TABLE
The primary purpose of the Alberta governments round
tables on Education are two fold. Firstly a short term response
to the fiscal mismanagement of previous Progressive Conservative
governments. And secondly a view towards Americanizing our education
system.
In the short term the Government is using the deficit
as an excuse to cut funding for all levels of education as well
as social services and Medicare. What is obvious is that the series
of roundtable's on Education have systematically backfired. In
fact the public response to the governments' roundtable's as well
as to the ATA roundtable's has shown that the public is "willing"
to fund education and educational institutions even if it means
higher taxes. This was not the response the Klein government was
looking for.
In a time when the terms "global economy,"
"global competition" and "education" are used
in the same breath, we have to seriously question the foundation
of the Klein governments working papers on Education . In fact
by trying to define "basic" education at the primary
and secondary level, in the Meeting the Challenge workbook, we
see an underlying philosophy that would radically alter what we
know as "public education." In simple terms it is an
attempt to move away from providing a comprehensive education
for all Albertans.
The government clearly is suggesting that we have
a two tiered education system in the province. Public Education
would provide minimal basics and the rest of curriculum such as;
fine arts courses, industrial arts/vocational training., International
Baccalaureate/Academic Challenge courses etc. would be done by
private schools.
The Klein Government has no mandate to Privatize
Education, on any level. Yet this is what they are hell bent on
doing. In order to shift the financial burden of their twenty
years of investment blunders, the Klein government is preparing
Albertans for a very specific future; an Americanized one.
The Klein challenge to Education and Post Secondary
Education is to "rationalize." To look at privatizing
schools and their services as well as allowing more and more private
schools (such as the so called DeVry Institute) to take up the
load .
Internally the government proposals want us to view
schools not as a social responsibility, borne by all Albertans
for the benefit of all Albertans, but as a consumer market place.
This is the current language of many Education bureaucrats and
administrators. The education system is seen as a Ford factory,
or perhaps a Nissan factory, where taxpayers are seen as consumers
and children are seen as products. The Klein Governments proposals
fit into this trendy "marketplace" thinking
The roundtable proposals for defining a "basic
education" clearly show that the government wishes to only
provide the basic minimum. The rest of the courses would be conducted
by private enterprise; that is private schools and colleges. As
well some educational course such as those that are work or job
related would be conducted by business themselves. Businesses
in many cases, who have failed to pay their fair share of the
tax burden of education in the first place, would now be getting
even bigger tax breaks by providing "on the job training"
in the guise of education.
On the Job Training is not education!!! It is job
specific, industry specific, and lacks the overall training that
a comprehensive vocational education in the public system can
and should provide. It doesn't allow us to acknowledge that plumbers,
x-ray technicians, auto mechanics, also may want to know about
Shakespeare, Quantum Mechanics, or Medieval History.
It is the same with so called "Fine Arts courses."
In elementary school music, drama, and art are an integral part
of a child's growth and education. This should be the case in
the later grades, but sadly it is not. Usually these are the first
courses to be cut, since they are seen as options. Rather than
expanding these courses and access to them the Klein Government
would see these as extraneous, and would allow them to be provided
by private schools.
Arts and Culture in Canada are not only a crucial
part of our national identity and social culture but a major industry
as well. Television, Movies and other electronic media production
have grown in this country over the past twenty years. Failure
to provide for this education and training in the public education
system means that we will lose control of our cultural institutions,
our technological abilities and our children's ability to be well
rounded culturally aware individuals. Privatization of fine arts
courses will mean ghettoization, Americanization and again "on
the job training" disguised as education.
Removing Academic education from the basics ; e.g.
the International Baccalaureate (IB) and Academic Challenge (AC)
courses from public education means we will step back into the
past. It opens the door for the British Private School system,
reinforcing an elitism based on money and ones academic abilities.
What this means as well is that public education will be seen
as second best, for those of "average" intelligence,
stigmatizing both students and parents. It also leaves the door
open for further decline in funding of public facilities when
they are seen as "second best". And it opens the door
for an American style voucher system approach to education.
Integration of the severely handicapped is a tough
issue currently being debated in the education field. It too is
not seen as part of a basic public educational need by the Government.
In reality then whether severely handicapped children should be
integrated or not is not the question, rather that they should
be given an education equal to that of any other children is our
concern. The Government would wish to again see the burdens of
educating these children fall to their parents or guardians. Thus
increasing the financial burden on those who face the enormous
challenge of raising children with special needs.
The Alberta Government plans on privatizing our public
education system. It is using the cover of the deficit to dismantle
our heritage, and sell it lock stock and barrel to private schools,
corporations and special interest groups. As Albertans and taxpayers,
we reject the notion that one can define a "basic education"
if it does not include a full education for all Alberta students
regardless of whether they are going on to post secondary educational
institutions, are becoming technicians, mechanics or are becoming
painters, actors or TV. Technicians. Whether they are "gifted"
students or "special needs" students. All should be
provided for in our public education system. What this government
is proposing is to fragment our public education, and sell it
off to the highest bidder.
What they have done with the ALCB is what they would
like to do to our schools. In order to privatize our schools and
to get the public support they need the Klein Government, in spite
of public outcry, protests and roundtable findings is determined
to reduce the governments share of financial responsibility by
20%. In 1961 the Provincial share of education costs was 88%,
today it is only 54%. The Klein proposal will see this further
reduced to 34%!! This means that the burden of taxes will fall
upon each school board district to collect. It means that our
provincial government will be spending less on education than
any other province in Canada. And by spending less, they hope
to reduce the education schools can provide so that Albertans
will be forced to support privatizing education. There are no
real tax savings in the governments proposals, only a shifting
of the burden to municipalities and public sector workers.
We in the Trade Union movement know how valuable
public education is. We have fought for it for the past one hundred
years. We have been in the forefront of promoting education, not
only for our own members, but for all Albertans and Canadians.
We reject this Governments call to dismantle our education system
bit by bit in order to sell it off to private schools and corporations.
We reject the idea that we can face the "global challenges"
facing us in this "New World Order" without a strong
and well-funded public education system. As with other Albertans
who have responded to the Roundtable's on Education we believe
that this government is responsible for funding education. The
real problem in education is the fact that staff in our public
schools, at all levels from support staff through teachers, are
being asked, and have been asked for the past ten years, to do
more with less.
It is time that this Government which has been reducing
its financial commitment to Education in boom times as well as
recessions, stops putting the burden of their financial mismanagement
on the children and taxpayers of Alberta.
It is time that the Corporate pals of the Government
paid their fair share for all government services. Services that
provide them with a well-educated tax paying workforce of Albertans.
If Business and its Government are so worried about public education
it is time they started paying for it rather than trying to privatize
it!!!