"Extreme Risk"
Now this is an episode! "Extreme Risk" has got to be bordering on being a
fan favorite. First things first. "Drone" leading so well into this episode
with B'Elanna's distractedness and the comments about class-two shuttles was
more than what I expected. It was also quite pleasing to see Alexander
Enberg (Vorik) in his first reprise this year. Vrulck was a good alien
although he seemed like he could have been Emck's brother he was so
one-dimensional. Yes, I do like the "Captain Proton"-style controls and the
lines that accompanied their introduction.
Director Cliff Bole pulled every aspect of "Extreme Risk" together in the
way only he could do it. Kenneth Biller's original script was well
thought-out, too.
Let me see, that was one shuttle! The Delta Flyer is then perfect solution
to Voyager's shuttle problem. Its sleek design is attractive and the the
Borg weapons systems (photonic missiles) were neat -- and packed a pretty
good punch. The scene where Chakotay, Paris, B'Elanna and Seven were
designing the Delta Flyer's extreior on the holodeck was amusing as well.
Now onto B'Elanna's side of the story -- and what a story it was, at that!
Roxann Dawson was sensational! I don't think I've ever seen her act like
that before. She was so real! Her scene with Neelix -- who's turning out to
be a well-rounded guy this season -- was great. It was a perfect set-up for
the final scene when she lets go. She also had a great scene with Chakotay
on the holodeck -- it was the high point of the episode, in my opinion.
B'Elanna's decision to replace Chakotay was one where you just want to
smile.
The basic plot threads were well-knit and I couldn't have asked for anything
better. I think it's about time B'Elanna got to deal with the loss of her
Maquis comrades, her family. This is a deep episode and for some people it
could really hit home in an emotionally inspiring way. Consider
congratulations for that one are duely sent out.
Generally speaking, I don't think Voyager's gone wrong yet this season. And
with the return of Species 8472 on the horizon, good things are sure to keep
on coming. Mr. Braga, keep it up!
Next order of business: my final evaluation. Did "Extreme Risk" measuer up
to last week's "Drone"? Close enough for me. So, "Extreme Risk" was a risky
gamble at all as it rounds up a final 10 out of 10.
"In The Flesh"
While not as good as its predecessors this season, "In The Flesh" had its
strong moments.
Chakotay romances seem to always be a total flop, but this one was nearly an
exception. It had its redeeming points, but nothing too strong. The
character of Valerie Archer being so compellingly different is probably the
reason for the romance aspect of this episode's succes with me.
The negotiations ("class reunion") part was fun, as was the comments about
other galaxies and the such.
The amazing Ray Walston as Boothby was most likely the highlight of this
episode, though! He's always fun, energetic and just a well-rounded
actor!
I find that the Delta Flyer and the view screen in Astrometrics are becoming
the producers' favorite toys of late. While I love these sets, once per
episode is a bit excessive!
Some quick notes... I can't believe that even after the reference to Picard
in this week's DS9 ("Treachery, Faith and the Great River"), there was a
comment in passing by Archer about him, I beleive. That's sort of
interesting.
Seven's new uniform is a welcome change. It's much more colorful and bright.
It seems to reflect the more optimistic and less Borg-like Seven of Nine
we've gotten to know these past few weeks.
The plot (a well-kept secret!) was okay (I feel we've been turned down from
further Species 8472 plots), but the characters and acting was much better.
Boothby and Janeway's interaction was great. His final gift of the flower
was touching as well as giving the episode more of a sense of purpose.
I wasn't overly impressed with David Livingston's direction, but Nick
Sagan's wit appears to shine through in this script. That's off to a good
start under Brannon Braga's control.
To sum all of this up, "In The Flesh" is a show most people will watch just
once or twice, while it still has its novelty. Despite some failing
qualities, "In The Flesh" continues this year's streak of good Voyagers: 9
out of 10.
"Once Upon a Time"
Well, this episode was fine, but not of any real interest. It just brings
back too many elements of "Mortal Coil" and a dozen other episodes and
mends them together with a thin thread. Not what I was expecting from
Michael Taylor, mind you.
Nonetheless, strong performances by Ethan Phillips (Neelix), Nancy Hower
(Ensign Wildman) and Scarlett Pomers (Naomi) brought this show up. Other
acting was so-so and I wasn't really impressed with Tuvok comforting Paris
and Wildman.
I'm also having trouble finding what's such a big deal about Wallace
Langham's performance as Flotter. I wasn't too trilled, myself.
Some high points included Janeway admitting she's a coffee addict (well, not
in so few words) and everyone relating to The Adventrues of Flotter...
Harry, Janeway and even a younger Samantha Wildman.
Nothing exceptional in the music, special effects and direction (by John
Kretchmer) gives "Once Upon a Time" a soothingly calm 8 out of 10.
"Timeless"
The Doctor put it right when he said, "Let's tempt fate."
This is truly a timeless classic. This episode joins the select few on the
Top Ten List of Trek, in my opinion. Another honor upon which I bestow
"Timeless" would have to be the best 100th episode ever. That honor used to
be held in such a high regard for DS9's "The Ship" (over TNG's
"Redemption"). And "The Ship" was really good too!
I don't think there has ever been an episode so fulfilling in Star Trek
history: The humor, relationships, action, hopes, fears, despair,
bitterness, time travel, incredible script, visual effects, musical score,
and guest actors of "Timeless" add up to one bid "Wow!"
First off, there's Christine Harnos (Chakotay's not-so love interest Tessa
Omand) -- and what a great job she did. Not that she was overly impressive,
mind you. It's just... well, I'm in a praising mood after just seeing this
episode!
LeVar Burton was an asset to the show too. His directing was as good as
usual. The contrasting views of Voyager and the Galaxy-class ship were quite
well done, as were the two scenes where the same dialogue is going on, only
with some noticeable differences that make you think, "It's different! It
may work! Hooray!"
The characters were all perfect: Janeway and Chakotay grew a lot in this
episode: Their dinner was reminiscent of "Night" to me. Their humorful scene
in Engineering brought back memories of "Parallax". Neelix and Tuvok were at
odds, B'Elanna and Tom were themselves. People being people was good for
"Timeless" since it was, in essence, the accumulation of 100 hours of
quality television.
And Garrett Wang (Harry) was like he'd never been before. Not using the term
at all loosely, he was fantastic! Harry Kim has never been so strong.
An acting performance to remember took place in the back room of the Delta
Flyer, for sure! Robert Picardo wasn't his best, but was emotionally
satisfying nonetheless! The one word that kept running through my mind for
those three minutes: "Whoah." That was something...
Some fun moments in "Timeless", a compilation of everything Voyager,
everything Trek, included: Seven's drunkeness and The Doctor's comments
about that very thing; Captain La Forge's brief cameo, but continuing
presence; Executive Producer Rick Berman's close involvement with the
production of this episode, considering he got a story credit and was on the
set.
The visual effects, of the opening scene with Voyager covered over with ice
and of the crash-landing, were the best I've ever noticed. The viwescreen
images were almost more dazzling for the fatal descent than the exterior
shots. Quantum slip-stream drive looked good too. No break-throughs there,
though.
Speaking of the opening part of the show, seeing all the crew dead at their
stations was sort of eery, spooky, creepy. It was almost nightmarish,
considering how well-preserved they were. Seven's body being useful seemed
wrong, yet perfect at the same time. Don't ask me why; these are just weird
impressions I get from watching the episode.
While I felt bad for Harry, I could understand his feelings. I mean, how
would you feel if you'd practically been responsible for all of your
friends' deaths?
The most touching moment so far this year goes to the final minutes of
"Timeless" in which Harry receives the message from his future self. The
etchings on the "real" Harry's face told the story of what he was going
through, would yet still have to face. (Janeway got some good moments in
that scene where she tells Harry the news.)
In light of recent events, I would have to say Harry Kim is now a much
stronger, well-developed character. He's more enlightened and proven. He's
assertive and fun. Now, where's that champagne, B'Elanna? We've got a
promotion in the works!
And I shouldn't forget good ol' Robert Beltran (Chakotay). He was a good
actor in "Timeless", enough though I've never been too impressed with him
before this episode. ("Nemesis" was the sole exception.) Go Chakotay!
Generally, Brannon Braga, Joe Menosky and Rick Berman did a superb job with
the story and teleplay, bringing back memories while throwing in dozens more
new ones.
Pleased? Sure am. My satisfication? Haven't begun to express it all. Will it
be the number one episode of all time? It's up there. Way up there!
I've already congratulated almost all the bog, important people involved in
Voyager's 100th, but I guess, I should say that if I missed anyone (yes, all
the little people, I know!) they should all get a big round of appalause on
a job well-done. Live long and prosper, Voyager...
This will sound silly, however, "Timeless" earns the biggest 10 out of 10
yet this year!
"Infinite Regress"
What? No Delta Flyer?
Just joking. This was actually a very enjoyable episode. I hope to see some
more episodes of this quality in the future!
Like it was predicted, the interaction between Naomi (Scarlett Pomers) and
Seven was great. They get a long so well. Their final scene was fun, just
plain amusing. I couldn't think of a better way to end the episode. Scarlett
Pomers was, quite simply put, better this time around. I like her scenes
with Seven the best so far; even more than the ones with her and The
Doctor!
Okay: Klingons, Humans, Romulans, Krenim, Tellerians, Ferengi, Bolians and
even those Species 6339 guys. Is it just me or is this the worst recorded
case of personality disorders in the galaxy?!
Highlight of the episode: The "inside her head" scenes with Tuvok searching
for Seven of Nine. Wow. The lights, stretch effects and all the different
types of aliens was incredible. That was high-caliber work! Amazing stuff if
more like it!
Another memorable scene was with The Doctor, Janeway and Tuvok in the
Captain's ready room. That was a good ethical and moral debate. Not the
best, but worth mentioning, nonetheless.
Some of the comments made by Seven's personalities (DaiMon Torat in
particular) were funny. The size of the viewer in Astrometrics, the cost of
medical treatment. What a cool way of looking at Voyager from a 20th-century
perspective!
The Seven biting B'Elanna thing was worth a laugh or two! Especially
considering their comments about her attempts to, well, initiate a Klingon
mating ritual, their scenes were played out very well.
I'm certainly not disappointed with this episode!
David Livingston pulled "Infinite Regress" all together, though. His talents
shone through in every aspect of the show. I just found his unique directing
style tied things up and delivered it the emotionally challenging way he
tends to.
And I almost forgot another key player in this episode: Jeri Ryan! Way to
go, Seven! Another spectacular Borg episode. Reasonable drama, good
acting -- all thanks to one person. But what more have we come to expect
from her? Honestly!
All the way through, "Infinite Regress" gets perfect scores. Yes, you
guessed it. It's another 10 out of 10 for the history books!
"Nothing Human"
Welcome back, Jeri Taylor!
Well, not really. It was just a pitched script, nothing permanent, but it
was good! The medical ethics, human morality, personal wishes, and racial
tension was outstanding. This one goes in the same league as "One", Taylor's
last script for Voyager.
Several great performances mark the progress brought to life through
"Nothing Human". Roxann Dawson's brief, but emotional scenes brought on
memories from this season's "Extreme Risk". Robert Picardo's role make me
think back to "Timeless". What great drama!
One scene that stands out is the one in the briefing room, where Paris,
Chakotay, Tuvok, and Janeway are discussing -- arguing, rather -- B'Elanna's
treatment or possible lack thereof. It sums the entire episode up more than
any other.
Crell Moset (David Clennon) was a fantastic character. He reminded me of the
EMH-2 from "Message in a Bottle" in the beginning. But as time went on, he
became more and more cynical. And more Cardassian, in the sense that we
generally know them.
While the idea of adding another new crew member seems too overused this
season, I liked the Doctor's final decision. His conversation with Crell in
the recreated Cardassian medical lab was a perfect example of why this
episode is so great: It is an ethical debate much like "Ethics" on TNG. The
reference to the Hippocratic Oath was bound to come up some time. And it
did, but with so much more impact than I expected!
I also should note that the realization of Crell being a mass murderer was
brought across in an excellent way.
I thoroughly enjoyed this episode: the talk of the occupation, B'Elanna's
attitude, Janeway's outlook, the bonding scenes between the two physicians,
the cool new cytoplasmic pseudoparasite (Is it just me or does this sound
too much like a microscopic organism's name?), the visual effects of both
the subspace pulse and the destruction of the alien's ship, and so much
more!
I just adore deep episodes like "Nothing Human" that make you think and
evaluate your own morals, ideas, and comceptions about anything and
everything -- particularly medical science.
There's not much more I can say! This was just an awesome episode which
merits a 10 out of 10!
"Thirty Days"
Now here's a good episode. It's just another one of those "thinkers." (In
other words, it asks the question, "What would you do?") And I must
also admit it's one of the best Tom Paris shows in a long time!
The title, "Thirty Days", is quite appropriate. Even the title suggests
similarities to last year's DS9 episode "In the Pale Moonlight". The
flashback scenes, log entries, and even that feeling of foreboding that
accompanied the storylines were on-track with each other.
Again, my weekly highlight list appears right here: what fun it was to see
the evil twin sisters in the Captain Proton program, Harry got the best
lines in this episode (surprisingly enough), Seven's usual bluntness, the
Moneans were just so lovable compared to that cytoplasmic pseudoparasite,
and good visual effects (including the electric eel attack and that shot of
the Flyer leaving Voyager that was similar to the one used in "Extreme
Risk").
And the plot! This episode was very well thought-out. The strings tied a
tight knot that held this story together despite some ups and downs. Kenneth
Biller's fun script and Scott Miller's imaginative story made a good
combination. I actually thought the idea of an ocean in space wasn't going
to fly, but it did! The containment field problem was just the way to get
Tom involved in his own personal quest.
Heidi and Alissa Kramer (the Delaney twins) were enjoyable, even though they
had such a brief appearance this episode. I hope they return again since
their Captain Proton scene with the confusion between the two was
laughable -- in a good sense!
Ah! And "Thirty Days" proves that even if the little walking computer can't
be in the episode, Naomi can get mentioned in a quip or a passing thought.
Thank you, Doc.
I can truly appreciate the looping idea in this story. The demotion scenes
running along in tandem and the narration by our favorite conn officer were
good effects.
As some final comments, Guest stars Garson and Livingston were good actors,
particularly in the last act of the episode! What a turnaround for fair
play!
It wasn't really Winrich-Kolbe quality direction, but it was okay. Some
scanning shots were good but others seemed so thoughtless to me.
While not the best this season by far, "Thirty Days" swims more than it
really sinks, due to some redeeming points and creative approaches: 9.5 out
of 10.
"Counterpoint"
This episode wasn't great, but it wasn't terrible either. It had its twists
that made it hard to follow at times. (I just want to not that if you truly
want to enjoy this episode, don't read this review until you'v seen it.)
Guest star Mark Harelik (Kashyk) was surely a highlight of the show! He was
a great actor; his scenes with Kate Mulgrew were the best. And speaking of
Mulgrew, she did a good job too, even though it wasn't her best acting
ever.
My favorite points for "Counterpoint" include the glimpse into the inside of
Voyager's shuttlebay, the cargo containers trick (Oh, that was sly!), the
alien scientist's interesting puffing nose when he was angry, the background
music Kashyk decided needed to be played, and, of course, the new wormhole.
Or, rather, the "interspatial flecture."
The two shuttles making a break for the wormhole was an outstanding twist!
It even looked good visually, and it was a beauty compared to the repetitive
Bajoran Wormhole on Deep Space Nine!
On another visual note, why another Mutara-class nebula? The effects for the
nebula didn't look reused...
Surprisingly, the most enjoyable moment in this episode was with Neelix!
This season he keeps getting better and better. I really liked his scene
with the telepathic kids to whom he was trying to tell a story about Flotter
and Trevis.
What is it with script writer Michael Taylor and coffee? Is it just me, or
did we get a major mention of Janeway's java in his last episode, "Once Upon
a Time", too? I'm not complaining. It's just... narrowed the spectrum on out
captain's personality. I'm being overanalytical, I know.
Music played a big role in "Counterpoint". Jay Chattaway's familiar score
filled in those tension-filled moments on the bridge and in the ready room.
The performances of the classical music were enjoyable as well.
Overall, "Counterpoint" isn't an ace, but I'm a sucker for time-travel and
hard-to-follow stories, I'll give this episode a well-received 9 out of 10.
This page hosted by
Get your own Free Home Page