"Image in the Sand"
I'm impressed and disappointed at the same time. Impressive was the episode
as a whole. Disappointing was the meager bit we got to see of Ezri Dax (not
that she said her name is Ezri, that is). Sure the credits have changed
(Nicole deBoer's name added and "Colonel Kira"), but so have some other
things: First of all, I like Kira's new hairdo. (I know I'm among the few.)
It's more personal and conscious. (I know, I'm personifying hair follicles.)
Cretak (Megan Cole) is complex for a Romulan antagonist. Her chemistry with
Kira is just great, enjoyable! Special guest stars Brock Peters and James
Darren were their usual great selves; what can I say? Admiral Ross is as
stoic and neutral as ever, so I guess that also qualifies as great acting.
But, I'd have to say that my favorite scene would be where Kira marches in
and tells Cretak that either
they move out or Bajor makes them leave. I think that has potential (as does
Damar's less two-dimensional game with Weyoun). (The Barclay discussion is a
close second in the favorite scene category, however.) The lack of Dukat's
arrogant
presence was also a minor setback in my view of "Image in the Sand". The
Pah-Wraith cult seems somewhat out of place, yet, at the same time,
effective. Too many plots at once. Overall, "Image in the Sand" was
top-notch, albeit a few minor things. A very emotional, (director) Les
Landau-style approach to a dramatic season opener. 10 out of 10.
"Shadows and Symbols"
"Shadows and Symbols" in a nutshell: Spectacular. The "false vision" with
Damar/Wykoff was an interesting spin on Benny Russell's character. I was
actually fooled for a while there. (The paint brush versus shovel thing was
well played out too.) And I think that I'm pretty much used to Ezri by now;
she's the Dax we know and love! Even better, almost. The "space sick" scene
in the runabout was quite funny, as was the "two words" scene on the
Rotarron. Aside from the constant references to Kiss Me Deadly, the Kira
part to the episode was entertaining. (It was great to find out who was the
one to end the showdown!) Dialogue was at a premium in this episode,
especially when Ezri entered into the picture. And, while I'm sure many
people are going to disagree with me, the visual effects in this episode
were the best I've seen in a while. I mean, the solar shockwave smashing
into the shipyards was almost breathtaking. The Sarah stuff with the
Prophets was sort of wierd, but hopefully it will get smoothed out in the
near future. Another confusing episode with many story twists, "Shadows and
Symbols" gets a hard-earned 9.5 out of 10.
"Afterimage"
As far as settling as new character into the show goes, the story was good,
if not a bit old. I mean, how many Starfleet officers really consider
resigning their commissions for other fields of endeavor? Apparently quite a
few. Ezri was as fun as last time, but in a more serious and solemn way this
time. I could really feel bad for her when Worf told her he wanted nothing
to do with her; I also felt her victory in the final moments of the show.
It's nice how she got her promotion at the end. The scenes with Sisko and
Ezri were fun -- especially the predictable "I didn't send it" one. The
Garak side to the story was -- dare I say it? -- boring. We all know he's
claustrophobic and there's really not much to explore with it in my
opinion... But if it keeps Ezri there! Again back to Ezri, her moments with
Quark and Bashir were great, letting us into Jadzia's mind and all. It's
nice to know Jadzia won't be forgotten to everyone, although some people are
accepting the new Dax a little easier than others. The direction by Les
Landau (Isn't he perfect for personal shows?) and the musical score fit this
episode as well as any other. You could almost feel the episode! Well, the
good in this episode it far outweighed some minor flaws, so "Afterimage"
gets a 9.5 out of 10.
"Chrysalis"
From what I can tell, DS9 is going to go out with a bang and "Chrysalis"
won't be an exception as far as I'm concerned. This is probably the Trek
romance episode I've been the most impressed with in years. Now, up front I
have to say "Statistical Probabilities" was an exceptional episode,
particularly the last few minutes, so I'm going to be prejudiced in favor of
a sequel.
On some side notes, Patrick (Michael Keenan) was as adorable as before. His
desire for everything to be precisely as it was the last time and his
constant repetition of "That's a stupid question," was great. Lauren (Hilary
Shepard Turner) seemed so much like herself making comments about Nog, while
not even knowing his name to begin with. Jack (Tim Ransom) was his usual
cynical self. The group from the Institute wanting to halt the universe from
expanding (with such lines like "We're running out of time!") made for a
comical scene or two. Seeing the trio masquerading as Starfleet officers
(and Nog's reactions!) was a good idea.
Now, onto the real plot. Sarina's sudden emergence into real life was just
done perfectly. Kudos must duely go to writer Rene Echevarria and director
Jonathan West on that take. It was so easy to draw inspiration and hope from
the scenes where Sarina is looking all around her and is just taken aback.
That's really emotional stuff. And so is the scene where Lauren, Patrick and
Jack are teaching Sarina how to sing. I was quite impressed by that one
particular scene and how it seemed to reflect much of the rest of the
episode in it. I got worried when Sarina looked like she needed some further
treatment. I kept wondering what was happening -- and hoping that the Trek
time piece wouldn't be reset; it would be such a waste to see Sarina revert
back to the catatonic state she was in since she's such a great character.
The references of what a genetically-engineered girl should do once she
wakes up brought "Chrysalis" to a full circle, in my opinion. I mean, she's
a person now -- with feelings and choices and personality! What more
could you ask for?
Sarina's interaction with everyone was fun, even moving at times. I couldn't
help but feel badly for her when Jack put her down or when she was trying to
explain to Bashir what the problem was. Faith C. Salie is the perfect
actress for the part. (Her smile seems to fit for Sarina's character, too.)
And yet I still couldn't help feeling so terrible for the others when Sarina
decided it was best for her to leave.
To sum this one up in a nutshell (a little too late for that, isn't it!), I
loved this episode. It had memorable comedy (the universe problem was merely
one example), fun characters, a good plot, great direction (was it just me,
or were the camera angles of Sarina whenever she was showing emotion hit
just on the right spot?) and superb acting! (Gotta love those mutants!)
Finally, it seems quite likely that this will be the last
genetically-engineered crew episode and that makes me feel kind of sad; I'm
really going to miss Sarina, Patrick, Jack and Lauren. This has always been
a favorite plot thread of mine (more so than the mirror universe) and I'm
not at all happy about watching it end. I certainly hope this is not the end
of this plot; there are so many more directions to go in with this one...
One last episode is all I ask.
While I've figured out by now that I'm being really light on my reviews this
year, I feel that "Chrysalis" deserves a 10 out of 10 despite what anyone
will try to do to convince me otherwise.
"Treachery, Faith and the Great River"
A fine episode, I'll admit, but there was a problem or so with this one:
Why back to the B plotlines? DS9 was working out so well these past few weeks
with only one story to follow. The ideas were much better developed that
way. I personally think that "Treachery, Faith and the Great River" only
fell short with that small detail.
Something else I noticed was that it was possible that Gul Rusol, Odo's
informant, was the Cardassian man we saw in "Improbable Cause". That's what
I thought, anyway.
Now, I think that "Treachery, Faith and the Great River" has got to be one
of the most appropriate titles to a Star Trek episode lately. I mean,
treachery can refer to both of the plots, as well as faith. (Kira even threw
in a bit about her faith.) And the Great River goes well with the
Nog/O'Brien storyline.
Acting in this episode was great. Bravo, Jeffrey Combs! You've done it
again. (He's now played Brunt and several distinct Weyouns
oustandingly! And seeing Weyoun eating pizza just added to Comb's
performance!) Rene Auberjonois (Odo) was also quite enjoyable, as was Nana
Visitor (Kira) in her brief scenes.
Nog's scenes (as confusing as they were) were well done. The desks part
(DeSoto, Sisko and Picard -- quite a collection there, friend!) The Great
Material Continuum was funny on some weird level.
Again, the visual effects were breath-taking. Every battle was perfect,
every roll. It just looked real. I don't thik there have been effects that
good yet this season. Even what was seen from inside the runabout looked
life-like, in my opinion.
The bonding between Odo and Weyoun (both of them!) was just great. So many
great things: Odo's eventual acceptance of his being regarded as a god by
the Vorta; the story -- however true -- Weyoun shared with his idol, Odo;
how Odo looked at that very story and what it told us about how he'll always
feel about his people; the chemistry between the two actors; and the last
few moments (which you have to see to really understand why this episode is
so good!).
I firmly believe that this is a major turning point for Odo. He'll never get
to know his people unless something changes. And he's right: No matter who
wins, he's going to lose in some way -- his friends' freedom, or his own
people. I don't know which could hurt more...
Generally speaking, "Treachery" was well-rounded and evened-out. Philip
Kim's story ideas keep getting better and better, as do Weddle & Thompson's
scripts.
Gracing along, "Treachery, Faith and the Great River" gets a 10 out of 10.
"The Siege of AR-558"
Ow. This one stings. What a message, what an episode. It's that
particular kind of sting...
Starting off, was the single Rom scene really necessary? He gets mentioned
in the guest stars list for singing one song (That was funny, though!) and
having a few funny lines? Come on! I like Rom too, but that scene could have
waited!
It's quite reassuring to know that Chin'toka hasn't been entirely forgotten
by the producers of DS9. Having AR-558 (it sounded to me as if it was in the
Chin'toka system...?) the physical and emotional battleground for this fight
was something that would provide a better scope for what was happening.
Having Nog be so severely injured -- it's better than having the no-names
die. One reason why I say all this: it hits so much closer to home.
Ezri got some very good moments that were so distinctly Ezri -- again! Her
scenes with actor Bill Mumy (Kellin -- what a valiant and dashing soul) were
outstanding. Her comments about war ethics were among the most important
points in this show. And then there were the usual
"was-it-Tobin-or-Jadzia-or-Ezri?" mix-ups. Tell me she didn't grow this
episode. I could almost picture how her eyes could change with the rest of
her after such an event (the battle).
The people behind the camera... Writers Ira Steven Behr & Hans Beimler were
their typical selves: brilliant, while not too outwardly so, creative, while
not confusingly so. Director Winrich Kolbe put together another emotional
bomb with "AR-558" -- basically, he was himself with that one.
Paul Baillargeon's (I think that was it) musical score was top-notch. His
composition for the ground battle was amazing, down-right amazing. It was
moving and, well, it hit home -- just like the rest of the show. How he
brought unity to an otherwise empty scene. (Sure, the faces told the story,
but that's not what I mean.)
While I wasn't originally fond of Bashir's idea to turn on a song by Vic, it
sort of grew on me since it lead into the battle so well.
Personally, I believe this episode should have aired last week: A
Remembrance Day (or Veterans' Day) week showing could only have strengthened
"The Siege of AR-558".
An overall good theme-centered episode that got into the gritty aspects of
war, "AR-558" was fulfilling down to the last detail -- particularly the
final scene with Kira and Sisko. This one's worthy of a 10 out of 10.
"Covenant"
This is one of those do-I-like-it-or-not episodes. I really don't know what
to think. It was okay, but not good.
First of all, I wasn't particularly looking forward to this episode. It
seemed so pointless in the beginning, but I'm now seeing a deeper meaning to
"Covenant". Not too deep though. I can see how writer Rene Echevarria sort
of beat around the bush on the topic of faith. That's fine, but it's been
done much better before. (Star Trek: Voyager's "Mortal Coil" comes to
mind.)
And Dukat: Ugh. What a turnaround. He's so useless now. The only reason I
see worth keeping him around for is the fact that he's so fallen for
Kira.
While the episode started off its first half as a good mystery, the latter
half dropped that direction and went for a more direct route: Dukat was
wrong. I don't like that. The mystery would have been preferrable to the
hole the producers dug for Dukat's character. There's virtually no way out
of that one.
And, to put it nicely, the most interesting scene in the whole episode took
place in Quark's with Barshir, Ezri, Quark, Kira, and Odo. It was just
another fun way to introduce the episode.
Then, the fact that the crew didn't even notice that unscheduled transporter
activity had taken place (let alone let it happen!) leaves me to question
Federation security -- during war time at that!
Frankly, this one was not impressive, but not a total flop either. Director
John Kretchmer just worked with what he got; and that wasn't too much.
I'd have to say that "Covenant" merely deserves an embarassing 7 out of 10.
This page hosted by
Get your own Free Home Page