How many times have you received a message asking you to send a copy to
all of your friends? Did you send it along? Maybe it looked legitimate,
or maybe it was from a trusted source such as a close friend. Did you
check it out first, or did you just forward it to everyone in your
address book?
There are many Internet stories and "urban legends" being circulated on
the Internet, and they often sound very legitimate. Many times, they
prey on a persons sense of duty, of wanting to do what's right, of
wanting to help right a wrong. Oftentimes, they prey on our natural
fears. Unfortunately, many of these are also false stories; sometimes
they were never true in the first place; sometimes they were true at one
time, but are now outdated; and sometimes they simply twist facts to suit
the author's purpose.
In this article, I'm going to address several of the more common rumors,
chain letters, virus warnings, and stories that are circulating on the
Internet. I'll let you know which ones are false (most of them), and
which ones are true, and I'll also give you a few sources where you can
verify the validity of these stories.
WHAT SHOULD YOU DO IF SOMEONE SENDS YOU ONE OF THESE STORIES?
Regardless of whether you feel you can trust the person who sent it to
you, and no matter how official or realistic it may look to you, if you
don't know if it's true or not, you should check it out
before you send it to someone else.
If you have checked it out and verified that it is false, I recommend
that you send a nice email to the person who sent it to you, explaining
it to them, providing them with the information or link verifying its
falsehood, and encouraging them to notify the person who sent it to them
AND anyone else they may have forwarded it to.
WHAT'S THE HARM IN FORWARDING IT, EVEN IF IT'S JUST A FALSE RUMOR?
First of all, if it is false, then telling someone else about it is a
lie. We don't want to be responsible for spreading lies.
Second, these emails take time to read or scan and delete. As an email
newsletter publisher, I receive dozens of these emails each week from
well-meaning readers. It takes time to go through these emails, and also
to verify the stories.
Third, these emails take up space on your computer. The more of these
floating around, the more space they take up. They also take up space on
your Internet service provider's servers, and any other servers used in
the transmission of messages. Imagine how much space these occupy
collectively on the world's servers.
Fourth, they take time and bandwidth to download. Some people don't have
unlimited or free Internet access. More of these messages means more
time to connect to the email servers, and more costs.
Finally, many of these chain letters ask people to take action, like
emailing an organization or writing letters to a company or politician.
In addition to the cost and time of someone doing this, it also takes a
lot of cost and time of the organization, company, or politician, which
is time taken away from their real purposes. Don't be a cause of these
distractions.
HOW DO I KNOW IF ONE OF THESE STORIES IS TRUE?
As a rule of thumb, if it has the words "Send this to all of your
friends" or some variation of that, it is probably a hoax. A real
warning from a credible source will not tell you to forward it to
everyone you know.
Legitimate businesses (i.e. Microsoft, AOL, Coca Cola, The Gap, etc.)
never conduct business by chain letters. If you receive an email from a
company asking you to forward it or promising you something if you do,
it's not legitimate.
Legitimate warnings and solicitations will always have the name and
contact information for a source of the information. Emails lacking this
information are probably hoaxes. However, merely having
legitimate-sounding contact information does not necessarily mean that a
story is true.
There are several places on the Internet where you can go to verify the
stories you receive from well-meaning friends.
(http://www.scambusters.org/legends.html). This site lists dozens of
hoaxes and false rumors, as well as more sources for research.
Scambusters also has a free email newsletter.
Another great site for information on how to spot a false rumor or chain
letter is Hoaxbusters (http://hoaxbusters.ciac.org/). Hoaxbusters is a
public service of the CIAC (Computer Incident Advisory Capability) Team
and the U.S. Department of Energy.
For a large variety of hoaxes, rumors, and urban legends, check out
Snopes.com (http:\\www.snopes.com). They have a searchable database, so
you can enter a keyword from the message you want to research and it will
take you to related articles.
WHAT ARE SOME OF THESE STORIES, HOAXES, AND RUMORS?
First, let's cover some of the religion-based emails:
THEME: Jesus will be portrayed as a homosexual in an upcoming film.
This email urges you to sign the email and forward it on, and also
encourages you to write letters of protest to the Attorney General of
various states.
STATUS: FALSE. This petition first started circulating as early as 1984,
when in fact, there never was such a film.
THEME: Atheist Madalyn Murray O'Hair is trying to get religious
broadcasting banned from radio and television.
STATUS: FALSE. This particular hoax tends to evolve periodically. A
few years ago, the popular TV show Touched By An Angel was added to the
chain letter as a potential target for the bannings. The following is
excerpted from the Urban Legends Reference Pages:
Madalyn Murray O'Hair never petitioned the FCC to ban religious
programming nor was she ever granted a hearing by that regulatory body to
discuss the matter. That's not all that surprising either for there is no
federal law or regulation that gives the FCC the authority to prohibit
radio and television stations from presenting religious programs.
The real RM-2493 had nothing to do with Madalyn Murray O'Hair nor did it
have anything to do with banning religious broadcasting. That didn't stop
the above petition from being widely circulated as concerned citizen
after concerned citizen signed it, then sent it on to an ever-widening
circle. It's still kicking around to this day despite the real RM-2493
going in front of the FCC in 1974 and being turned down by that body in
1975.
It was a given that Madalyn Murray O'Hair would come to be associated
with the "ban religious broadcasting" petition. It was largely through
her efforts that in 1963 the U.S. Supreme Court barred organized prayer
from the public schools, bringing her national infamy. (In 1964 LIFE
magazine headlined her as "the most hated woman in America," a title she
burnished as a badge of honor.)
For the past few years, she's been the focus of a mystery. In August
1995, Madalyn (then 76), along with her son, Jon (40), and granddaughter,
Robin (30), vanished from their home, reportedly with breakfast still
cooking, and were never seen again.
A recent news story indicates that they may have recovered the remains of
Madalyn on a ranch in Texas. Interestingly, her son William, now 54, is
a Christian evangelist.
THEME: US Attorney General Janet Reno defines a cultist on a 60 Minutes
interview. Her reported definition was as follows:
A cultist is one who has a strong belief in the Bible and the Second
Coming of Christ; who frequently attends Bible's studies; who has a high
level of financial giving to a Christian cause; who home schools for
their children; who has accumulated survival foods and has a strong
belief in the Second Amendment; and who distrust big government. Any of
these may qualify but certainly more than one would cause us to look at
this person as a threat, and his family as being in a risk situation that
qualified for government interference.
STATUS: FALSE. Janet Reno never made such a statement on 60 Minutes or
anywhere else.
THEME: Immediate prayers are needed for Mike Hutchinson, a missionary in
West Africa, who is on trial for murder and will be hanged if found
guilty.
STATUS: FALSE. While this message has its roots in truth's (a boy in
Senegal did step in front of Mr. Hutchinson vehicle and subsequently
died), there was no mob as alleged in the email, he is not being tried
for murder, and he is not in danger of being hanged. In fact, Mr.
Hutchinson is now back in the United States.
THEME: Prayers are needed for David Allen, a missionary in Thailand, who
is dying from an unknown disease.
STATUS: FALSE. Like the previous theme, this one also has its roots in
truth, but the crisis is over, and David Allen is doing well.
The preceding two themes are examples of good intentions gone bad. While
there is certainly nothing wrong with praying for someone even after
their situation has passed, it is still perpetuating an untruth. Prayers
would be better used for those in need now, rather than those whose
crises no longer exist.
If you must pass on a prayer request, I suggest the following guidelines:
- Only pass it on if the request is from someone you know personally.
- Put a date on it.
- Put your contact information on the email so people can contact you
about the validity of the request.
THEME: Scientific discoveries supporting scriptures.
VARIATIONS:
- NASA scientists discover a lost day in time.
- An atheist professor challenges God to stop a piece of chalk from
breaking.
- Scientists drilling in Siberia drill down to the center of the Earth and
reach Hell.
- A group known as "The Second Coming Project" is seeking to clone Jesus
from the DNA of holy relics.
STATUS: FALSE. Most of these are simply stories that someone made up or
embellished. They prey on Christians? desire to justify or prove the
existence of God.
THEME: Missing Child -- A little girl named Kelsey Brooke Jones is
missing. Sometimes a photo is attached to the email.
STATUS: FALSE. The child was in fact missing, but only for about two
hours. Apparently, her mother awoke from a nap and discovered the child
missing, and immediately called the police. When the police arrived and
an officer began knocking on doors in the neighborhood, the child was
found playing at a neighbor's house. No one knows for sure how this one
got started -- the mother claims she did not circulate this email. For more
details on this, visit http://www.snopes2.com/inboxer/children/kelsey.htm
.
NOTE: There are many missing children, and occasionally one of these
emails turns out to be true. The best place to check them out is at the
National Center for Missing and Exploited Children web site at http://www.missingkids.com. There you can search for a child by name and
verify if the concern is real or not.
THEME: Forward the email to your friends, and receive money or products
depending on the number of forwards. A variation usually involves an ill
child, and the email claims that some organization will donate so many
cents for every email that gets forwarded.
STATUS: FALSE. It's impossible to track an email as it's forwarded. For
a complete explanation of why, visit http://www.urbanlegends.com/ulz/emailtracking.html.
THEME: Danger Alerts
VARIATIONS:
- AIDS or disease infected needles are being planted in coin return slots,
movie theater seats, gas pump handles, etc.
- Viruses are being mailed to people in envelopes, usually on small
sponges.
- Rat urine on the tops of soda cans can kill you.
- Kidney thieves are stealing kidneys from sleeping victims.
- Using a certain product (shampoo, drug, aspartame, etc.) can cause cancer
or sickness or is toxic.
- Gang initiations target motorists.
- Many others.
STATUS: FALSE. The vast majority of these are in fact, blatantly false,
meant simply to scare people. They sometimes sound real enough, but they
are not. If you have any questions on whether a danger alert is real,
check out one of the sites mentioned above.
THEME: Computer Virus Warnings
STATUS: Some true, some false.
So how can you tell the true from the false ones?
Source: Where did you get the warning? If your friend forwarded it,
which came from her cousin, who got it from her daughter, who got it from
her friend at college, who got it from the US Virus Lab, it's probably a
hoax. If you subscribe to a virus scanning service (you should!) with
your virus scanning software, you will probably receive the alert
directly from them.
Does it ask you to forward it? Genuine virus alerts from legitimate
sources won't tell you to forward it to everyone you know.
Does it link to a legitimate source? A genuine virus alert will probably
give a brief description of the virus, and will have a link to more
information. However, sometimes fake virus warnings will also link to a
legitimate site. The genuine link will take you directly to information
on the specific virus, not to the site's home page.
How can you verify if the virus warning is true? Check out a legitimate
website, such as one of the following:
ARE ANY OF THESE EMAILS TRUE?
Some are, but even the ones that are true are often exaggerated. For
example, you may have seen the one that warns you never to dial area code
809. This one happens to be TRUE. That particular area code belongs to
the Dominican Republic, not to the United States, although you would dial
it just like you would dial any long-distance number. However, it
functions like calling a 900-number, in which you get charged for every
minute you are on the line, usually at exorbitant rates. The common
version you may have seen states that you will be charged $2,425 per
minute, but the reality is much less than that, although it will still
cost a lot of money, and you will have little or no recourse with your
phone company since the charges are coming from a foreign country.
CONCLUSION
When you get these emails, the best things to do are:
- Check it out. If you are not sure if it's real, check it out on one
of the sites listed above. My favorite is http://www.snopes.com/ because it's
easy to remember, has good search capabilities, and is one of the most
comprehensive sites available on hoaxes. I'd even recommend that you
spend a few hours some time going through their site and reading up on
the various hoaxes. It will be both educational and entertaining.
- If it is not real, or if you aren't sure, DON'T FORWARD IT. Simply
ignore and delete it.
- If you are sure it is not real, let the person who sent it to you know
about it, and urge them to check these out before forwarding them. Send
them a copy of this article, if you like. Direct them to http://www.snopes.com/
or one of the other sites above. And encourage them to send a message to
anyone else they've sent it to and the person who sent it to them, asking
them to help stop the spread of these false stories and hoaxes.
- If it is real, then feel free to forward it if you like. It's a good
idea to include a link to the site where you checked it out and which
verifies its authenticity.
I almost hate to say it, but since we, as Christians, should desire to
put a stop to the spread of false rumors, stories, and lies, I'm inviting
you to...