
Updated October 1, 1998
| STEELERS OFFENSE | ||||
| Position | First Team | Second Team | ||
| WR | 81 | Charles Johnson | 15 | Hines Ward |
| LT | 77 | Will Wolford | 78 | Chris Conrad |
| LG | 62 | Roger Duffy | 65 | Alan Faneca |
| C | 63 | Dermontti Dawson | 66 | Jim Sweeney |
| RG | 68 | Brenden Stai | 65 | Alan Faneca |
| RT | 73 | Justin Strzelczyk | 67 | Jamain Stephens |
| TE | 87 | Mark Bruener | 85 | Mitch Lyons |
| WR | 88 | Courtney Hawkins | 89 | Will Blackwell |
| QB | 10 | Kordell Stewart | 18 | Mike Tomczak |
| FB | 38 | Jon Witman | 33 | Richard Huntley |
| RB | 36 | Jerome Bettis | 45 | Chris Fuamatu-Ma'afala |
| STEELERS DEFENSE | ||||
| Position | First Team | Second Team | ||
| RDE | 76 | Kevin Henry | 71 | Orpheus Roye |
| LDE | 74 | Nolan Harrison | 71 | Orpheus Roye |
| NT | 93 | Joel Steed | 98 | Oliver Gibson |
| ROLB | 51 | Carlos Emmons | 96 | Mike Vrabel |
| RILB | 50 | Earl Holmes | 54 | Donta Jones |
| LILB | 99 | Levon Kirkland | 57 | John Fiala |
| LOLB | 92 | Jason Gildon | 96 | Mike Vrabel |
| RCB | 20 | Dewayne Washington | 23 | Jason Simmons |
| LCB | 37 | Carnell Lake | 23 | Jason Simmons |
| SS | 41 | Lethon Flowers | 21 | Bo Orlando |
| FS | 39 | Darren Perry | 24 | Chris Oldham |
| STEELERS SPECIAL TEAMS | ||
| Position | First Team | |
| K | 9 | Norm Johnson |
| H | 18 | Mike Tomczak |
| KS | 60 | Mark Rodenhauser |
| PR | 19 | Andre Coleman |
| KR | 89 | Will Blackwell |
| P | 4 | Josh Miller |
| PS | 60 | Mark Rodenhauser |