This paper was first written in Fall of 1998; no changes have been made since 2000, and none are planned in the near future. Some of the information within the paper, especially that referring to transgender research, is very old, and has likely been made obsolete by current research.

With those caveats firmly in mind, I hope you enjoy the paper!
ELB

Gogol's Parental Influences

Nikolai Gogol did indeed have a father who was absent for much of his life, however the physical absence did not come about until his father's death when Gogol was only sixteen. In a letter sent to his mother after he received news of his father's death, Gogol seems to dismiss the 'tragic event' quite lightly: "My sadness soon turned to a light, barely noticeable melancholy" (Karlinsky, 8). This may imply that there was a great deal of distance between Gogol and his father up until that time. Such a lack of emotional reaction to his father's death could indicate that the father did not play a particularly important role in his life.
In contrast to the indifference Gogol exhibited towards his father, he appears to have been quite close to his mother. This closeness, embodied in the lifelong correspondence with his mother, nevertheless includes sentiments which Karlinsky (9) describes as mistrust, annoyance, and contempt. Such attitudes may indicate resentment of an excessively close childhood relation-ship, however his continual correspondence and occasional visits for the purpose of advising his mother and sisters do not indicate any serious estrangement. Further evaluation of Gogol's mother and his relationship with her are unfortunately beyond the scope of this paper, but could provide an intriguing avenue for future research in terms of Gogol's proposed transsexual orientation.

Gogol's Adult Life
Some of Gogol's longest lasting friendships were formed while he attended a private boarding school at Nezhin. He attended this school from age 12, shortly after his younger brother's death, until age 19. It was an all-male school, and Gogol participated in both literature and drama, often playing the female roles in dramatic productions (Karlinsky, 13). This aspect of his adolescent life may have no connection with his later transvestism, since cross-dressing by male actors had been widely accepted in drama for centuries for the purpose of playing female roles. However, Gogol's homosexual interests were already strongly established by this time, as can be seen in one of the letters he wrote to an older student who had just left the school.
After Gerasim Vysotsky left Nezhin for St. Petersburg, Gogol planned to join him and sent him many affectionate letters. One letter dated March 19, 1827 begins: "So you do love me after all, my kind, precious friend. You sacrificed a portion of your valuable time in order to give joy to someone who burns for you with an unfathomable, ardent attachment". He goes on to finish "Yours till the grave, unchanging, faithful, eternally loving you, Nikolai Gogol" (Karlinsky, 15). Unfortunately for Gogol, Vysotsky did not return his amorous feelings, and after leaving Nezhin, Gogol was apparently rebuffed by Vysotsky.
In conflict with his (homosexual) attraction to men, Gogol seems to have been attracted specifically to heterosexual men in almost every instance. This was the case with Gerasim Vysotsky at the beginning of his life, as it was with Nikolai Yazykov in later years. This attraction to heterosexual men has been described as a way for a homosexual man to deny his own homosexuality (Karlinsky, 308). The rationale seems to be that if a man is attracted to a heterosexual man, then he is obviously not homosexual, but simply attracted to an individual who inconveniently happens to be another man. Kiell, however, describes this attraction to heterosexual men as a normal consequence of the transsexual's belief that he is truly a woman.

He prefers normal, heterosexual men as sexual partners, and rejects homosexual men or the idea that his sexual activity is homosexual. Feeling he belongs to the female gender, he considers it appropriate to have a love relationship with a man, and feels 'unnatural' in a relationship with a woman, considering this 'homosexual'. (332)
In contrast to the failed relationships between Gogol and Vysotsky or Yazykov, there is a single known instance of (an apparently successful) romantic relationship between Gogol and another man, Iosif Vielhorsky. This relationship was short-lived, however, due to Vielhorsky's death from tuberculosis only six months after he and Gogol met. Throughout most of his remaining life, Gogol maintained a close relationship with the Vielhorsky family, quite likely in an attempt to keep up some kind of connection to his dead love. That relationship was terminated towards the end of his life, when Karlinsky (268-269) proposes that Gogol might have confided the true nature of his relationship with Iosif to one or more members of the Vielhorsky family. Such an admission, says Karlinsky, "would indeed constitute a plausible cause for the entire family to sever all contact with Gogol, suddenly and for good" (269).
After Vielhorsky's death, Gogol did attempt at least one more serious relationship with a heterosexual man. In his relationship with Nikolai Yazykov, Gogol began to act out the role of a Russian wife as he saw it; taking on the responsibilities which he described as the province of a woman in any marriage. In Gogol's (1969, 159) book, Selected Passages from Correspondence with Friends, letter XXIV, Gogol states that a wife's primary responsibility is to handle all of the financial and economic responsibilities of a household. In his ill-fated relationship with Yazykov, Gogol seems to have taken his own advice to heart and assumed those wifely responsibilities, although Yazykov describes the disastrous results.
He is constantly being cheated and swindled and fleeced by the Italians, whom he trusts as if they were honest and whom he respects exceedingly. He spends money as if it were dirt and fusses and bustles, being quite sure that he outsmarts everyone and buys everything cheaper than the others, and takes pathological offense if he is contradicted in anything. (Karlinsky, 224)
This assumption of female roles is mentioned as being typical of transsexuals: "transsexualism is...a psychiatric syndrome characterized by...a belief one is basically of the opposite sex, and an imitation of behavior associated with the opposite sex" (Kiell, 332). (emphasis mine)

Cross-dressing Activities
Throughout his adult life, Gogol was fascinated with such things as clothes and fabrics, and "[h]e particularly liked brocaded and embroidered vests (the art of embroidery had interested him since his early youth, and a considerable portion of his correspondence with his mother during his stay in St. Petersburg is devoted to embroidery patterns and designs)" (Karlinsky, 205).
This phenomenon has a correlation in the case studies of transsexual boys, gathered by Stoller (1968, 336-344). In one particular case, involving a four-and-a-half year old boy who was diagnosed as transsexual at a very early age, the boy not only enjoyed feeling and wearing feminine clothes and fabrics, but in his behavior he somehow linked the wearing of feminine clothes to creative expression. In opposition to the definition of cross-dressing by transvestites above, this boy did not wear women's clothes for reasons of sexual arousal. Instead, he usually wore women's clothes while engaged in drawing. In the classroom, the boy would go to the dress-up box and pick out a skirt, bolero jacket and high heels. Once he had this outfit on, he would begin drawing. His drawings were described as very advanced and detailed for a child his age. At one point, however, the child was transferred to a different classroom where he was not permitted to dress up except during playtime; the boy then stopped drawing (Stoller 1968, 339). In this example we can infer that creative expression was somehow linked to the new identity assumed by the boy when he was allowed to 'become' a woman.
This connection of cross-dressing with creativity, rather than sexual arousal, may be seen in the single documented instance of transvestism by Nikolai Gogol. On this occasion, Gogol was surprised in his room by two friends, Vasily Zhukovsky and Sergei Aksakov, in an episode described by Aksakov in his memoirs.

"There was Gogol in front of me, wearing the following fantastical costume...Instead of boots, he wore long woolen Russian stockings, reaching higher than the knee; instead of a jacket, a velvet spencer worn over a flannel camisole; around his neck was a large multicolored scarf and on his head was a crimson velvet woman's headdress (kokoshnik), embroidered in gold and very similar to the headdresses of Finnish tribeswomen." Gogol did not seem to be particularly embarrassed at being caught in this outfit. He simply asked Aksakov what his business was and then dismissed him by pleading the need to go on writing. (Karlinsky, 205-206) [see Appendix]
Although this is the only documented case of Gogol's transvestism, at least in English translation, the lack of reaction by Gogol to being discovered could indicate that this was not an unusual activity for him to engage in. The fact that he was apparently writing at the time he was disturbed also tends to confirm the proposal that he did not engage in cross-dressing for purely sexual purposes. Whether he found it necessary to wear women's clothing in order to write, or whether he cross-dressed while writing of female characters in order to identify with them, are questions which cannot be examined within the scope of this paper. Further investigation into the thousands of pages of Gogol's correspondence and journals available only in Russian may shed more light on this aspect of his sexuality and creativity.


Nikolai Gogol - Introduction to Research Paper
Terms and Scientific Background
Biographical Information
Literary Analysis of "The Nose"
Literary Analysis of "Terrible Vengeance"
Psychoanalysis of Female Characters
Conclusion, Sources Cited, and Footnotes
Researched and Written by: Erica Brown
Fall semester, 1998

Course Information:
Russian 166 - Representations of Sexuality in Russian Literature
Instructor: Daniel Rancour-Laferriere
University of California, Davis

This page is © Erica Jean Lindsey Brown, 1998-2006.
http://www.oocities.org/ejb_wd/Gogol3.html

Written permission must be obtained in order to reprint
this material for any purpose.
Contact Erica Brown by email.