The story made no sense because in Kirk's show they already talked about the Axanariens and the said it was Captain Garth who made first contact with them on the USS Republic. How does Fight or Flight makes sense with this? What happened? Did Archer never tell anyone about meeting them? What about his log? Did the Federation not count this and then when Captain Garth discovered them, they said he had first contact? This is just completely stupid and one of the bigest mistakes yet.

They didn't even get the man looking right. That is not what the Axanareans look like. They have purple skin with white dust and that protects them from radiation. And their hair is rainbow colored. Read the Star Trek sourcebook for a description and a drawing of one. The book reads nothing about them living for four hundred years and being endragenous. I can't find anything in Captain Garth's show that agrees with this. Does anyone else help this? Does it work? No.

And before anyone talks at me about sourcebooks not being canon because I don't want to hear that. This still happened and was written BEFORE the enterprise show was on the television.

Also, he did not command a ship called the Republic.

But you are right about the race being screwed up, everyone knows that the Axanaranienssss can shoot lightning out of thier arses.

The sourcebook says so.

and on an only moderately related topic, I'm in favor of referring to the people of the planet Axanar as either "the Axanar" or "Axanari" as opposed to "Axanarians", although I guess "Axanarians" sounds about as good as "Andorians".

Incuboy

quote:

---

Originally posted by Incuboy:
Based on the occasional refeences to the Axanar Peace Mission in the original series, I always assumed the Axanar were a fairly long-established race on the galactic political scene long before Kirk's cadet days.

and on an only moderately related topic, I'm in favor of referring to the people of the planet Axanar as either "the Axanar" or "Axanari" as opposed to "Axanarians", although I guess "Axanarians" sounds about as good as "Andorians".

Incuboy

I will not grovel like some ANT on a somewhat larger than usual anthill ...

---

im actually surprised that no one has mentioned it that kai winn said that the homeworld of the andorians was andor, when t'pol used andoria. is this something to go stark raving mad over! no, of course not, its a tv show and they make mistakes. im not gonna dislike the show because of a little error or two. thats what happens in a show with the history star trek does. the axanar, cool race, lets see more of em i say.

------------------
"Baseball-like our movies, like our newspapers and magazines-has fallen into the hands of rich, vulgar people who neither love nor understand it."

------------------
--Airbus 330--
Ron Moore Speaks out on Star Trek (DS9 Producer) check it out, he should have helmed Enterprise,seems like a true fan.

MajorBarcalow

Who does a brilliant job at it while getting around the terms of service every single time?

MajorBarcalow

Who can fool a good amount of people no matter how ludicrous his statements are every single time?

MajorBarcalow

I tip my hat to you, sir.

quote:

---

Originally posted by Silik:
Who can fool a good amount of people no matter how ludicrous his statements are every single time?

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by MajorBarcalow:
And before anyone talks at me about sourcebooks not being canon because I don't want to hear that.

---

Oh, how I wish this worked in the real world.

I would say this kind of thing all the time if it would work.

"Before you tell me to go to work, don't. I don't want to hear that!"

I've come not to take these posts seriously. I think they are simply jokes.

quote:

---

Originally posted by Kelso:
But you are right about the race being screwed up, everyone knows that the Axanaranienssss can shoot lightning out of thier arses.

---

LOL!!!

Thanks, good way to start the morning, good laugh!

quote:

---

Originally posted by Silik:
Who bashes the bashers?

[b]MajorBarcalow

Who does a brilliant job at it while getting around the terms of service every single time?

MajorBarcalow

Who can fool a good amount of people no matter how ludicrous his statements are every single time?

MajorBarcalow

I tip my hat to you, sir.

[/B]

---

1 official warning for trolling goes to Silik.

quote:

---

From the Policy:
Trolling is defined as posting remarks intended to anger another poster and or start an argument or flame war.

---

I believe the above post meets that definition since it is designed as an attack meant to initiate a flame war.

quote:

---

Originally posted by Apocolypse Cow:
I'm pretty sure the poor sod really believes the things he spouts off

---

1 official warning for flaming goes to Apocolypse Cow.

quote:

---

From the Policy:
In general, a flame can be defined as being aimed at one particular person or group of persons, and of an insulting or malicious nature.

---

Don't call someone a "sod." It's a flame.

Now, if someone wishes to engage in a civil discussion about MajorBarcalow's ideas, please feel welcome. If you want to act like adolescent children, please do so elsewhere.

Questions, Suggestions or Feedback related to moderating action should be directed to the QSF Forum.

*********************************************

EDIT: After consultations with my fellow Mods, the term "sod" actually falls short of the definition of flaming. My bad. The warning is thus rescinded and has been removed from the warnings utility. My apologies to Apocolypse Cow.

quote:

---

Originally posted by Kelso:

But you are right about the race being screwed up, everyone knows that the Axanaranienssss can shoot lightning out of thier arses.

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by Apocalypse Cow:
No, he's not stupid.  He's just... confused or something.  I know a lot of people who get like that, especially online, but not only about Star Trek but other hobbies I partake in (such as roleplaying games), too.

---

Aren't they basically the same people?

Matt

quote:

---

Originally posted by WeaponOfChoice:
No, no, no, the Axanaranienssss don't shoot lighting out of their arses. That's the Gornians. The sourcebooks say the Axanaranienssss fart laughing gas.

---

Now that's a weapon that can do some damage.

And about Andor, I'm pretty sure it was called Andor by Kira in a different episode as well.

Matt

1. I did not flame him. I actually COMPLIMENTED him!

2. If you're gonna give some ridiculous warning then you can at LEAST be FAIR and give warnings to people that are actually making sarcastic remarks.

3. You are so fucking blind that you can't even see through Barcalow's Andy Kaufman routine that should be BLATANTLY OBVIOUS by now! HE is trolling the board every other day by making fun of the bashers, and you LET HIM! And I'M the one that gets the warning! Oh that's just beautiful. Excuse me while I go clear my lungs from laughing so hard.

quote:

---

Originally posted by MvRojo:
Aren't they basically the same people?

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by gerbil:
Yo! Major 'sup! I been wondering where you are. Are you actually saying this or are yuo joking!?!?!?!?!?!? I [b]MUST know![/B]

---

I've been busy with my projects and catching up on my work. I've been very disappointted with posting here and you can look up for reasons to see why I am this.

quote:

---

Originally posted by MajorBarcalow:
But people make their own thoughts and I can't control them.

---

quote:

---

Originally posted by MajorBarcalow:
...And their hair is rainbow colored.

---

If you've got questions or comments about Moderating action, please refer them to QSF.

Thanks. Carry on.

Why was this double posted?

quote:

---

Originally posted by bolian12:
THey're called the Axanar, not "Axanareans"

---

also, my above post was just meant to point out what is real and what is not. star trek is not real, it is a TV show. hense my andorian parallel with the axanar. if this parallel was the jumping off point of attack on the major then i apologize.

------------------
"Baseball-like our movies, like our newspapers and magazines-has fallen into the hands of rich, vulgar people who neither love nor understand it."

quote:

---

Originally posted by WeaponOfChoice:
Do they also hold up large signs reading "John 3:16" at all football games they attend as well??

---