Thursday, November 15, 2001
Gay trial ends in Egypt
An Egyptian court convicted two defendants accused of leading a sex ring of
52 gay men, sentencing one to five years in prison and the other to three years
in a case that touched on a subject considered highly taboo. Twenty- nine of the
accused were acquitted Wednesday, prompting ululations of joy from family
members who had staunchly denied the charges and accused the Egyptian media of
sensationalizing the trial. Twenty other defendants were sentenced to two years'
imprisonment each for debauchery, according to the official verdict. One
defendant received one year in prison for debauchery.
The four-month trial shocked Egypt, a conservative nation in which
homosexuality is seen as a shameful sin. Relatives of the accused often jostled
journalists covering the trial, accusing them of defaming the defendants. The
accused entered the courtroom Wednesday wearing white prison uniforms and hiding
their faces behind masks and handkerchiefs. There were chaotic scenes outside
the courthouse before the verdicts were announced. Only a few people had been
allowed into the courtroom. Police wielding sticks drove back a crowd of about
200 relatives, lawyers, journalists, and passersby and closed the courthouse
doors. As news of the sentences came in bits and pieces from people leaving the
court, relatives ran to the courthouse windows and shouted requests for
information on the verdicts. One elderly woman joyfully distributed sweets and
soft drinks, saying she had heard her son was among those acquitted.
Inside the courtroom the verdicts were met by angry shouts from the
defendants crowded into a fenced-in dock. The presiding judge continued to read
his decision, ignoring the shouts from relatives who chanted, "We will
appeal to God! He is our defender!" The two alleged ringleaders, Sherif
Farahat and Mahmoud Ahmed Allam, faced multiple charges. Farahat received five
years for debauchery, contempt of religion, falsely interpreting the Koran, and
exploiting Islam to promote deviant ideas. Allam received three years in prison
on the religious charges but was acquitted of debauchery. Earlier Wednesday a
director of the U.S.-based International Gay and Lesbian Human Rights
Commission, Scott Long, condemned the verdicts as "a travesty" of
justice.