newspic.jpg (8851 bytes)

HHUGS In the News

HH Research

HH Surgery
HH Surgery Down Under:
Royal Children's Hospital
Melbourne, Australia

Kings College Hospital
The UK hospital where the TC approach has been used successfully

Montreal Neurological Institute

Barrow Neurological Institute

University of Texas

 

HH Media Archive
HH stories featured in the international media



The Joshua Potts Foundation
Find out about our efforts to raise money for the research and treatment of HH, in memory of a very special boy


Back to
HHUGS Home Page


New HH Study Underway at RCH, Melbourne

Following on from their groundbreaking surgical program on HH, the team from the Royal Children's Hospital (RCH) in Melbourne, Australia are currently undertaking a new research study into the causes and effects of hypothalamic hamartoma, which hopefully will answer some of the many questions about why the hamartomas develop, how they cause epilepsy and why they often cause problems with behaviour and learning.

The researchers are:
Dr Jeremy Freeman, Epilepsy Research Fellow at RCH (training to be a specialist in child neurology)
Dr Simon Harvey, specialist in child neurology and Director of the Children's Epilepsy Program at RCH
Associate Professor Jeffrey Rosenfeld, neurosurgeon and Director of Neurosurgery at Alfred Hospital
Professor Samuel Berkovic, specialist in neurology and Director of the Epilepsy Research Institute
Ms Jacquie Wrennall, Coordinator of Neuropsychology at the RCH

The research will centre on those children who have had a HH removed at the RCH or who have been referred for evaluation to the Children's Epilepsy Program.

The research will consist of:

  • an interview with the parents of each HH child covering family history and pregnancy issues
  • a blood test to check for any genetic changes which could explain the development of the HH
  • testing of a small piece of each HH removed by the operation
  • various other tests as performed routinely as part of the pre and post surgical process at RCH

According to Dr Freeman, the research team are trying to test the theory that a HH develops because of a "somatic mutation" in the DNA of the brain.

"These type of mutations happen after a baby is conceived", says Dr Freeman, " and only affect some cells in the body. If we find a mutation like this, it will not mean that your child got this mutation from you or that they could pass it on to their children. It will just help us to understand how these hamartomas develop".

Dr Freeman says some of the genetic testing will be done at the National Institutes of Health, NIH (many of the children on the HH Support Group have already had this done on their blood). However, the RCH research will build on these data by testing other genes (to be conducted at Harvard, Boston) and testing of the tissue, which is where the Melbourne researchers believe they have the best chance of finding something.

Early data from the Melbourne research have been published in the January 2001 issue of  Neurosurgery (click here to read a copy). A larger surgery outcome paper is in press in an Epileptic Disorders supplement, another paper is in press in Neurology, and a surgical technique paper is currently being considered by another journal.

 

Dr Kore Liow's Study at NIH

In 1999 a group of HH families travelled to the National Institutes of Health (NIH) in Bethesda, Maryland to participate in one of the most comprehensive research projects ever conducted into the HH condition. The research was being conducted by Dr Kore Liow, who was until recently Clinical Associate at the NIH. Below is an excerpt of a letter sent to the HH Group by Dr Liow describing his study.

Dear Families

Gelastic seizure is indeed a rather rare seizure, even at a national referral center like the National Institutes of Health. Because of its rarity, doctors often missed the diagnosis. Even in cases where the condition is diagnosed, doctors often do not know what to do with it. We have in recent years seen quite a number of cases and, in conjunction with the National Human Genome Research Institute, have been able to link some of the hamartoma to a newly described genetic syndrome. It is still not known how frequently the hamartoma is inherited as this genetic syndrome. Because of the paucity of knowledge about this disease, we would like to see as many of these gelastic patients as possible. By conducting further testing, like special MRI, PET, SPECT, EEG and genetic testing, we could learn more about this disease to disseminate the information to neurologists worldwide. This will in turn enhance our ability to make a correct diagnosis, know the most effective treatments and be able to offer them to our patients. This will be the first time this disease is being studied in this scale and magnitude and the scientific findings will not only be significant to HH but may also help us to understand other generalized seizure disorders.

These are the tests that we will be conducting at NIH:

GENETIC BLOOD TESTS: to look for chromosomal mutation leading to the development of HH. I do not believe anyone else has looked at this. The mutation was discovered by Dr. Biesecker here at the NIH who will be doing the genetic studies with us. This will be extremely important in understanding the disease and could be the first step to finding a cure in the future. Like most diseases, finding out how it happens is often the clue to finding how to treat it or to prevent it.

GENETIC WORK UP: including a detailed family history as well as a SKELETAL X RAY of the hands and feet if indicated. The development of HH is coupled to the development of fingers and toes during the 6th-7th week of gestation pregnancy. There is evidence that the two organ system may be affected together in children with the mutation leading to HH.   It is not known how frequently the mutation exist in patients with HH and if there is another different mutation leading to the same HH but without the other anomalies. These findings will be significant in the understanding of HH.

NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL EVALUATIONS:  these will be conducted to classify the type of cognitive deficits present (if any) in HH children and monitor their progress over the years. We would like to work with your local providers to help manage your child in this area. I have sporadic calls telling me that one antidepressant works better that the next, so why don't we centralise everyone and see if we can make any sense out of it. There is currently little data available for managing behavioral problems in these children and I feel it is time we conduct a systematic evaluation and release the relevant data.

MODIFIED VIDEO-EEG: This will be different from previous EEGs in that it will have different leads specifically placed to try to detect gelastic seizures from HH. Apart from invasive EEG like depth (surgical) electrodes, we still do not have accurate methods to detect gelastic seizures and that may be why some of your children are initially diagnosed with some other seizures/disorders or even a psychiatric condition. This will not directly benefit your children but if the data is helpful, it will help physicians in the future to make the right diagnosis earlier without dismissing it as a mere psychiatric or behavioral problem.

MRI STUDIES LOOKING FOR CHEMICAL RECEPTORS in HH and the brain. This will not be like a regular MRI, but specially designed to look for a deficiency of chemicals and their receptors in HH compared to the rest of the brain. We are interested in seeing if HH fires because it lacks certain calming chemicals.  We are not sure how this could help but if there is a specific chemical missing, then we could concentrate on using or designing a specific drug to replace the missing chemicals. We would also be very interested in obtaining any HH tissues from resection to further study this.

ENDOCRINOLOGIC EVALUATIONS: Some HH kids have precocious puberty and some do not. Could the hormones contribute to the seizures or vice versa? Could there be a hormonal therapy that we should explore? These are the questions that prompted us to pursue this. We will be obtaining hormonal blood levels before and after seizures.

Your stay at NIH will be something like this:

Day 1: advanced MRI study, hands and feet X ray, blood draw for genetic and hormonal studies, history and exam
Days 2 & 3: modified video-EEG, neuropsy evaluations
Days 4-7: the stay will depend on how many seizures are recorded and how long the neuropsy testings takes. Some people will stay for 4 days, some longer.

We feel that this study is of such importance in its contribution to the understanding of this disease and possibly other seizures, we encourage more participation from your group. We have close to 10 people who are scheduled for June/July 1999 and expect more once we send out NIH recruitment letters to all epilepsy centers worldwide. The more people that we are able to study, the better the statistics and stronger the data, and we will already have won the first step of the fight against gelastic seizures.

Kore Liow, MD
Epilepsy Research Branch
National Institutes of Health

In all, more than a dozen HH families underwent testing at the NIH during 1999 as part of Dr Liow's study. On 22 June 1999, Dr Liow wrote the following to the HH Group:

We have seen about 10-15 cases of HH with gelastic seizures over the years referred from the other study groups and now, with the participation from your group, we will have the experience of seeing close to 30 cases. This is again an extremely rare form of epilepsy; neurologists in their whole career may see only one or two cases. Our preliminary assessment is leading us to the following observations:

(1) Gelastic seizures are refractory to most anticonvulsants including felbamate and research drugs like vigabatrin. However, certain medications that have low side effects are worth trying if not already tried. For example, Diamox, a water pill used to treat hormonal menstral seizures (gelastic is closely liked to the hormonal system) induces a mild metabolic acidosis in the body which produces an anticonvulsant effect. It is generally well tolerated and causes few side effects if used carefully. Most common side effects are tingling and numbness in fingers and toes due to low calcium or magnesium. It can be corrected or prevented by drinking gatorates.  Please consult your neurologist further about this. Ketogenic diets can also be helpful but the benefits may be short term. Since it is a diet modification, it may be worth considering if you have not already done so.

(2) Many surgucal procedures have been performed and we are still in the process of analysing the results.
(a) Open craniotomy with resection of HH may be technically difficult for sessile lesions especially those invading the third ventricle without a clear border.
(b) The stereotactic approach with radiosurgery and radiotherapy, including gamma knife, needs further study. Concerns are damage to the visual system due to the close proximity of optic structures to the HH and incomplete ablation of seizure focus within HH. Stereotactic thermocoagulation like radiofrequency and laser are other options that could be explored. Focal ablative therapy with specialized electrodes that perform recording, stimulation and ablative function can be useful in this respect and a German neurologist who has performed this procedure on HH  may be available to NIH to develop this technique.
(c) Neuromodulation like those used in deep brain stimulation of Parkinsons and anterior thalamic stimulation trials in temporal epilepsy are other options.

(3) There is a common behavioral pattern arising from the children we have studied so far. It may be closely linked to their gelastic seizures and HH due to the exacarbation of the behaviour prior to or right after seizure activity. We are in the process of collecting data on the effect of pharmacologic agents on the behaviour.

(4) Other aspects like cognitive development, genetics, morphology (shape and size) of HH on MRI in relation to seizure severity, noninvasive dipole mapping of seizure focus on EEGs, endocrinologic influence on HH are still underway and I will address these issues as the data becomes available.

What does all this mean to my child or myself?? We are making some progress in better understanding gelastic and HH and may be taking a small step towards developing an improved treatment. There are certainly still many issues to be worked out and again, I am fully aware of the fact that time is running short for your children who are losing ground due to their ongoing seizures. How soon will surgical options be available at NIH or elsewhere, only God knows but we have planted the seeds for further research into this rare and understudied condition and sparked some interest in the NIH and in the worldwide medical community for further work. As I can see, it will benefit the patients in 2 ways.

(1) One is to push for NIH to develop a treatment protocol. I have talked to the neurosurgeon about this and there are some obstacles to overcome. One is that we need more data to present to the approving committee to tell them that this is a study worth investing in, since there is currently no known treatment and we have collected solid data from many patients. We will likely have stronger voice if there are more children participating in this study. This will be ideal since NIH is in a position to sponsor travel, cover cost of procedures and in a position to recruit the best surgeons for this study.

(2) Other institutions may already be developing treatments and this will also be good since their source of funding may be from NIH. It is good to maintain an interest in this disorder at the NIH.

I believe that we are making progress although not as quickly as we like. I am glad that some of you have made the brave journey over here to Wasington DC and we are all grateful to you for your contribution to the understanding of this condition. Special thanks to the Sinks, Potts, Maxwells, Mees, Davises, Lamps, Oakleys, Smiths and we are looking forward to seeing the Lindseys, Picarellis, McAuleys, Venturas and more of you!

Thank you for your support.

Kore Liow, MD
Epilepsy Research Branch
National Institutes of Health

In 2000, Dr Liow left NIH to become Medical Director of the Comprehensive Epilepsy Center and Neurological Laboratory at Kansas University. Here he hopes to continue the important research into HH that he began at NIH.

WATCH THIS SPACE for the latest from Dr Liow!

 

Back to HHUGS in the News

Back to HHUGS Home Page

1

1

1

1