Personal Website of R.Kannan
Learning Circle - Trading in Derivatives
Risk Analysis & Risk Coverage in
Options Trading

Home Table of Contents Feedback



Project Map
Back to Module
First Page

Risk Analysis & Risk Coverage in Options Trading

Risks for an Option writer

The risk of an Options Writer is unlimited where his gains are limited to the Premiums earned. When a physical delivery uncovered call is exercised upon, the writer will have to purchase the underlying asset and his loss will be the excess of the purchase price over the exercise price of the call reduced by the premium received for writing the call. The writer of a put option bears a risk of loss if the value of the underlying asset declines below the exercise price. The writer of a put bears the risk of a decline in the price of the underlying asset potentially to zero.

Option writing is a specialized job which is suitable only for the knowledgeable investor who understands the risks, has the financial capacity and has sufficient liquid assets to meet applicable margin requirements. The risk of being an option writer may be reduced by the purchase of other options on the same underlying asset and thereby assuming a spread position or by acquiring other types of hedging positions in the options/ futures and other correlated markets.

If however the option-writer were to default, the risk factor passes on tothe Clearing House of the Stock Exchange. Risk containing measureas are therefore to be studied with reference to the Stock Exchange.

What is SPAN

Standard Portfolio Analysis of Risk (SPAN) is a worldwide acknowledged risk management system developed by Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME). It is a portfolio-based margin calculating system adopted by all major Derivatives Exchanges. Objective of SPAN: SPAN identifies overall risk in a complete portfolio of futures and options at the same time recognizing the unique exposures associated with both inter-month and inter-commodity risk relationships. It determines the largest loss that a portfolio might suffer with in the period specified by the exchange i.e may be day (or) two. BSE has licensed SPAN from CME for calculating margin requirements at the Exchange level. At the same time members can also calculate margin requirements of their clients by using PC SPAN

What is PC-SPAN?

PC-SPAN is an easy to use program for PC's which calculates SPAN margin requirements at the members' end. How PC SPAN works: Each business day the exchange generates risk parameter file (parameters set by the exchange ) which can be down loaded by the member. The position file consisting of members' trades (own + clients) and the risk parameter file has to be fed into PC-SPAN for calculation of Margins payable for the trades executed.

Index Option Contracts -SEBI Guidelines Regarding Risk
Containment Measures

SEBI has specified the following risk-containment measures to be adopted by the derivative exchange/segment and the Clearing House/Corporation for the trading and settlement of both Index Option Contracts:

  • The Index option contracts to be traded on the derivative exchange/segments shall have SEBI's prior approval. The contract should comply with the disclosure requirements laid down by SEBI.

  • Initially, the exchanges shall introduce premium style index options.

  • Initially, the exchanges will introduce European style Index Options which shall be settled in cash.

  • The Index Option Contract shall have a minimum contract size of Rs 2 lakh at the time of its introduction.

  • The Index Option contract shall have maximum maturity of 12 months and shall have a minimum of three strikes (in the money, near the money and out of the money).

  • The Initial Margin requirements will be based on worst case loss of a portfolio of an individual client to cover a 99 per cent VaR over a one-day horizon. The Initial Margin requirement shall be netted at level of individual client and it shall be on gross basis at the level of Trading/Clearing Member. The Initial margin requirement for the proprietary position of Trading/Clearing Member shall also be on net basis.

  • A portfolio-based margining approach shall be adopted which will take an integrated view of the risk involved in the portfolio of each individual client, comprising of his positions in index futures and index options contracts. The parameters for such a model should include:

What is Worst Loss?

The worst case loss of a portfolio would be calculated by valueing the portfolio under several scenarios of changes in the index and changes in the volatility of the index. The criteria to be used would be:

  1. The price range is defined to be three standard deviations as calculated for VaR purposes in the index futures market for the near-month contract.

  2. The volatility range would be taken at 4 per cent for six months, after which it shall be reviewed.

  3. While computing the worst case loss, it shall be assumed that the prices of futures of all maturities on the same underlying index move up or down by the same amount.

  4. For the purpose of the calculation of option values, the exchanges may use any of the following standard Option Pricing Models -- Black-Scholes, Binomial, Merton, Adesi-Whaley.

  5. The maximum loss in any situation is referred to as the Worst Scenario Loss. Subject to the additions and adjustments mentioned below, the Worst Scenario Loss is the margin requirement for the portfolio.

Calendar Spread

The margin for calendar spread would be the same as specified for the index futures contracts. However, the margin shall be calculated on the basis of delta of the portfolio in each month. Thus, a portfolio consisting of a near-month option with a delta of 100 and a far-month option with a delta of -100 would bear a spread charge equal to the spread charge for a portfolio which is long 100 near month futures, and short 100 far month futures. The Calendar Spread Margin would be charged in addition to the portfolio's Worst Scenario Loss.

As in the index futures market, a calendar spread would be treated as a naked position in the far month contract as the near month contract approaches expiry. In the index futures market, this is done in gradual steps over five trading days. For the sake of computational ease, it is now decided that when options are introduced, the gradual steps would be eliminated. Therefore, a calendar spread would be treated as a naked position in the far-month contract, three trading days before the near-month contract expires.

Short Option Minimum Margin:

The short option minimum margin equal to 3 per cent of the Notional Value of all short index options shall be charged if the sum of the Worst Scenario Loss and the Calendar Spread Margin is lower than the, Short Option Minimum Margin.

Net Option Value:

This value will be calculated as the current market value of the option (positive for long options, and negative for short options) in the portfolio. The Net Option Value shall be added to the clearing member's Liquid Net Worth. This means the current market value of short options will be deducted from the Liquid Net Worth and the market value of long options will be added thereto. Thus, mark-to-market gains and losses on option positions will get adjusted against the available Liquid Net Worth. Since the options are premium style, mark-to-market gains and losses will not be settled in cash for option positions.

Cash Settlement of Premium:

For option positions, the premium shall be paid in by the buyers in cash and paid out to the sellers in cash on T+ 1 day.

Unpaid Premium:

Till the buyer pays in the premium, the premium due will be deducted from the available liquid net worth on a real-time basis.

Cash Settlement of Futures Mark-to-Market:

The mark-to-market gains/losses for index futures position shall continue to be settled in cash

Position Limits:

The position limits in the index futures market will be applicable to index options also on the basis of notional value

Real-time computation:

The computation of Worst Scenario Loss has two components. The first is the valuation of each option contract under 16 scenarios using an appropriate option pricing model. The second is the application of these Scenario Contract Values to the actual positions in a portfolio to compute the portfolio values and the Worst Scenario Loss.

For computational ease, exchanges are permitted to update the Scenario Contract Values only at discrete time points each day. However, the latest available Scenario Contract Values would be applied to member/client portfolios on a real-time basis.

Option on individual securities

Introduction of options on individual securities will help investors protect against market risk in the equity market by hedging, and also increase the capital market's liquidity and efficiency. It will also facilitate further development of human capital in the skills of market participants.

The SEBI technical group on new derivatives product is discussing the various parameters for introducing options on individual securities. Securities within the range of stipulated volatility and which fulfill specified criteria of liquidity, trading frequency, market capitalisation, and free float will be selected for introduction of options. The broad criteria will be:

  • Stock should figure in the list of top 200 securities, on the basis of average market capitalisation, over the last six months and average free float market capitalisation should not be less than Rs 750 crore. Free float market capitalisation means the non-promoter holding in the stock; and

  • Stock should appear in the list of top 200 securities, based on the average daily volume, over the last six months. Further, average daily volume should not be less than Rs 5 crore in the underlying cash market; and

  • Stock should be traded at least on 90 per cent of the trading days, during the last six months; and

  • Non-promoters holding in the company should be at least 30 per cent; and

  • Ratio of the stock's daily volatility vis-a-vis daily volatility of index should not be more than four, any time during the previous six months. Volatility estimates would be computed according to the Prof J. R. Varma Committee report on risk-containment measures for index futures.

On the above criteria, it is estimated that 30-35 securities would qualify for options trading. The eligibility criteria would be reviewed after six months to examine whether in the light of the experience, the list of eligible stocks could be expanded.

As a part of risk containment, the SEBI group also decided to impose limit on the overall open interest in options on individual securities. It was decided that open interest in terms of number of stocks should not exceed 20 times of the average of daily shares traded, during the previous calendar month, in the underlying cash market.

The eligibility criteria will be reviewed after six months to examine whether the eligible securities could be expanded. The group has also decided that for an initial period of six months, options on individual securities would be cash-settled and the exchanges would adopt delivery-based settlement.

(Source: Edited-extracts from the latest NSE News published by the National Stock Exchange of India. The author is Mr R. Sundararaman, Head -- Futures and Option Segment, NSE.)

Margining System in the Case of Options and
Futures Adopted by BSE

A portfolio based margining model (SPAN), would be adopted which will take an integrated view of the risk involved in the portfolio of each individual client comprising of his positions in all the derivatives contract traded on the Derivatives Segment. The Initial Margin would be based on worst-case loss of the portfolio of a client to cover 99% VaR over two days horizon. The Initial Margin would be netted at client level and shall be on gross basis at the Trading/Clearing member level. The Portfolio will be marked to market on a daily basis.

Risk management of options on Sensex would in accordance with guidelines stipulated vide SEBI press release Ref. No. PR 237/2000 dated December 15, 2000. Certain important and key features of trading, settlement and risk management is mentioned below:

  • The Initial Margin would be based on worst-case loss of the portfolio of a client to cover 99% VaR over two days horizon. The Initial Margin would be netted at client level and shall be on gross basis at the Trading/Clearing member level.

  • A portfolio based margining model would be adopted which will take an integrated view of the risk involved in the portfolio of each individual client comprising of his positions in all the derivatives contract traded on the Derivatives Segment.

Worst Scenario Loss

The worst-case loss of a portfolio would be calculated by valuing the portfolio under 16 scenarios of changes in the value of the Sensex and changes in the volatility of the Sensex.


- - - : ( EoP ) : - - -

Previous                  Top                  Next

[..Page Updated on 10.10.2004..]<>[chkd-appvd-ef]