| 1 |
*Baltimore Orioles (1882-1889;1890-1891) |
| 2 |
~Cincinnati Red Stockings(1882-1889) |
| 3 |
Eclipse of Louisville(1882-1883)
*Louisville Colonels (1883-1891) |
| 4 |
Philadelphia Athletic(1882-1890) |
| 5 |
#Pittsburgh Alleghenys(1882-1887) |
| 6 |
*St. Louis Brown Stockings(1882-1891) |
| 7 |
Columbus Colts (1883)
Columbus Senators (1884) |
| 8 |
New York Metropolitans(1883-1887) |
| 9 |
~Brooklyn Bridegrooms(1884-1889) |
| 10 |
Indianapolis Blues (1884) |
| 11 |
Richmond Virginias (1884) |
| 12 |
Toledo Blue Stockings(1884) |
| 13 |
Washington DCs (1884) |
| 14 |
^Cleveland Spiders (1887-1888) |
| 15 |
Kansas City Blues (1888-1889) |
| 16 |
Columbus Colts (1889)
Columbus Salons (1890-1891) |
| 17 |
Brooklyn Gladiators(1890) |
| 18 |
Rochester Hop Bitters(1890) |
| 19 |
Syracuse Stars (1890) |
| 20 |
Toledo Maumees (1890) |
| 21 |
Boston Reds (1891) |
| 22 |
Cincinnati Porkers (1891) |
| 23 |
Milwaukee Brewers (1891) |
| 24 |
*Washington Senators(1891) |