This is a detailed cognitive behavior therapy plan that one family
worked out together with a child
psychologist who specializes in treating children with
Selective Mutism. The plan involves
giving the child a small reward (a token) for little
steps of progression in speaking at school.
These tokens are redeemed at home for items the child
has indicated she would like to have.
Please note that this is an individualized plan that
is working (for the most part) for this child.
You will have to take into account your child's
preferences, your preferences about using
material things for rewards, your child's teacher's
willingness to work with you and child.
SETTING UP
Mom and Mary together determine which items Mary would
like to acquire through a reward
system. Cut out from magazines, catalogs or draw
pictures of these items.
Paste the pictures onto
construction paper sheets. Staple into a booklet to
make "Mary's Catalog". Do this project
together - the child got child very excited and
interested in the whole thing. Doing the project
together also allowed the parents to be able to talk to their
child a little about "talking."
Determine the economy you will use - ie Monopoly
money, tokens, or points. Then determine
how many tokens (points, monopoly money) it will take
to "buy" each item.
Write the "price" of
each item next to its picture in the catalog. Once you
determine the economy, you explain it to
the child. We used shiny brand-new washers as our tokens.
Mary loves tools, screws, nails, nuts,
bolts. So the shiny washers were a big hit.
The incentives: (Catalog)
lunch with Mom at school - 5 tokens
"Bitty Baby" doll clothes - 10 tokens
"Bitty Baby" doll furniture - 15 tokens
"Barbie" airplane - 20 tokens
"Kit" doll clothes and accessories - 10 to 15 tokens
per set
A puzzle piece of the "Kit" doll - 10 tokens
Earn tokens during fading sessions to save up and
trade in at home to "buy" items pictured in a
catalog.
Puzzle - "Kit" an American Girl Doll- earn pieces to
complete the puzzle and get the doll.
Explanation: Mary really likes the doll "Kit". She
also likes earning puzzle pieces to get a
reward. We glued a picture of this doll to cardboard
and cut it up into 25 puzzle pieces.
The doll is a huge incentive for Mary but it is
really expensive (in the real economy!) so it is
going to be much harder to earn. Earning the puzzle
pieces will be the immediate reinforcement
but it will take a while for Mary to get the
reinforcement of obtaining the actual item.
However,
she has a bunch of stuff she can earn. So, she can
choose to spend all her tokens on Kit, or she
can mix it up a little, i.e., use some tokens to buy
lunch with mom and some Bitty Baby
clothes/furniture (shorter-term but smaller rewards)
and put some tokens toward the purchase of
Kit (a longer-term but relatively huge reward).
The token/catalogue purchases will give Mary a more
immediate reinforcement. I designed
things so that Mary will be able to earn enough tokens
in the first session to "buy" at least one
item immediately upon getting home that day.
FADING - gradually changing the conditions in which
Mary is already speaking. Mary already
speaks to Mom in the classroom. We want to gradually
change the conditions so that Mary will
speak to Mrs. Jones (teacher) in the classroom.
Before we start the program, Mom will talk to Mary to
explain the program, the incentives, how
the tokens are earned.
Tell Mary that she will get a
token after she names all the pictures on a
sheet of paper.
She will get to name 4-6 sheets of
pictures per session. Also explain we are doing
this to help her feel more comfortable talking at
school.
THE PICTURE SHEETS
We have several sheets of paper with 20 pictures per
sheet; 5 rows of 4 pictures. The pictures
must be things easily recognized by the child. The
child is not being tested on if he/she gets the
picture right or wrong.
It has to be something the
child has no problem with. It's the speaking
that is important here, not the IQ. Here is a list of
possible pictures to use:
Page 1
Fish, Pig, Teddy Bear, Shoe,
Paintbrush, Rabbit, Slide Squirrel, Flower, Cat,
Apple, Birthday Cake, Pizza, Bird, Beach Ball,
Snail, Doll, Frog, Butterfly, House.
Page 2
Train, Book, Duck, Flag, Jack-in-the-Box, Dog, Food
(Meal or Hamburger),
Cap or Hat, Girl, Boy, Sand Pail or Bucket,
Present (Gift), Tea Set, Dinosaur,
Hotdog, Pencil, Pen, Balloons, Cupcake, Heart.
Page 3
Giraffe, Rhinoceros, Lion, Wolf, Beaver, Elephant, Ape
or Gorilla, Camel, Goat, Monkey,
Moose, Mouse, Panda, Raccoon, Rat, Tiger, Horse, Pig,
Zebra, Sheep.
Page 4
Suitcase, Wagon, Ambulance, Car, Baby Carriage,
Safety Pin, Pacifier,
Scissors or Shears, Bulldozer, Steam Shovel,
Dump Truck, Fire Truck, Bicycle,
Roller Coaster, Castle, Igloo, Tent, Yo-yo, Swing, Kite.
Page 5
Camera, Telescope, Telephone, Arm, Foot, Hand, Ear,
Feet, Comb, Brush, Toothbrush,
Toothpaste, Spoon, Fork, Knife, Bowl, Drum, Guitar,
Piano, Trumpet.
Page 6
Chair, Table, Bed, Fan, Key, Hammer, Saw,
Barn, Windmill,
Whale, Deer, Fox, Alligator, Cow, Fish, Hat,
Flower, Tree, Dog, Cat.
Reward = a token.
Immediate secondary rewards = tokens, puzzle pieces
delayed primary rewards = the stuff she purchases with
the tokens and puzzle pieces
PART 1
After school, in the classroom, Mom sits with Mary at
a table. Mrs. Jones is at other end of room.
(Or out of the room if Mrs. Jone's presence is too
anxiety provoking).
Step 1
Mom shows Mary pictures on sheets of
paper. It's best if the pictures are on sheets to
enable very fast, seamless naming (fast with no
time for pauses). Mom points to the
pictures one at a time. Mary is to name the item
pictured. After each sheet named, Mary
receives a token.
Just point to the picturess, no need to ask
her "what is this?" Let her name them as fast and
as loud as she can (we're shooting for a
conversational tone here, not screaming).
We may have to actually SHAPE up to louder
naming if she's doing it really soft. At first any
audible naming would earn a reward. Then tell her
it has to be a little louder in order to earn
the reward, and so on until she is naming the
pictures in a conversational tone.
Step 2
Mrs. Jones moves closer, as Mom
continues with showing pictures, rewarding after each
sheet named. Just keep going as long as it takes
for Mrs. Jones to work her way next to Mary.
(Of course, in order for Mary to continue to earn
the rewards, she needs to name the pics in a
conversational tone. You may have to strengthen
that before you start moving Mrs. Jones
closer).
Step 3
Mrs. Jones casually joins Mom and Mary
at the table. Build up to: no hesitation from
Mary in naming the pictures. Continue to reward
with one token after each sheet completed.
You shouldn't have to change the schedule of
reinforcement.(You should not have to
increase the number of tokens rewarded per page).
If you think this is going to be necessary,
BEFORE THE SESSION BEGINS, tell Mary that she
will get 1 token per page when Mrs.
Jones is standing far away, 2 tokens per page
when Mrs. Jones takes the next step forward, 3
tokens per page when Mrs. Jones gets even closer,
and so on. Set up the contingencies in
advance so you don't inadvertently reward her for
showing signs of anxiety.
If you up the
ante when she hesitates, you'll reinforce
hesitating. See what I mean? You'll avoid this
potential pitfall if you set up the contingencies
ahead of time.
Have Mary keep naming until she's doing so
without any visible signs of anxiety. If this has
been going on for a while and she looks fatigued,
just end the session. At the next session,
just start from the step you left off. You
shouldn't have to start over.
***Part 1 took us two months- we worked after school
and had three or four sessions per week.***
PART 2
Step 4 - Let Mrs. Jones move closer and closer until
she, not Mom, is pointing to the pictures.
At first just focus on getting Mary to name
pictures with Mrs. Jones sitting at the table next
to her and, perhaps, turning the pages. Then have
Mrs. Jones point to the pictures.
**We had
to spend three sessions with both Mom and Mrs.
Jones poiningt to the pictures together.
Then Mom "forgot" to move her figure to the next
picture until Mary ended up naming the
rest of the page with just Mrs. Jones pointing.**
Once we've achieved that, then Mrs. Jones
gave Mary the tokens (Mom had been passing out
the tokens until now).
***step 4 took about 2 weeks.***
Step 5
Mom gradually moves away from the table, to
other side of the room, and out of the room.
***After two weeks, Mom now at the door of the room,
with one foot out the door. Mary is naming
the pictures and answering a few other simple
free-form questions to Mrs. Jones.***
The family will continue to meet with the psychologist for
instructions on the next phase which will be getting Mary able to
speak to her teacher during the school day with other
children present.
The update will be published as soon as possible.