home reviews awards oscars music lists links
    2005 a - e f - l m - r s - z 2004 2003 Unreleased
 
MELINDA & MELINDA (Woody Allen, 2004, USA)
Woody’s back! After some mediocre movies, everybody (including me) started to think that Allen was losing his touch. But it seems he’s back. Melinda is not as near as some of his classics (and, admit it: the premise of telling the same story twice has been done before) but it’s certainly an improvement of his latest films. It has funnier jokes, it’s deeper and this time it doesn’t start to get repetitive.
 
OLDBOY (Chan-wook Park, 2003, South Korea)
Most entertaining movie of the year? Well, 2005 has just started but it’ll be really hard to find a better replacement because Oldboy never bores and there’s a surprise after another. But, to be honest, everything’s too exaggerated and, if you analyze it, you’ll realize it doesn’t make much sense. It’s just an entertainment, a very good one, but don’t ask for anything more.
 
PARADISE NOW (Hany Abu-Assad, 2005, Palestine)
Its delicate subject didn’t bother me because it is always interesting to listen what the other side has to say. But the main problem is that the dialogs feel forced to make a statement and end up being unnatural. Besides, gags never work in this kind of films and much less if they are not very funny and overlong.