Nick: Kyle, I'm gonna start out with the negatives first. Disney Week was a while back, so I would have liked to see something else from you, I can only take one week of Disney. Secondly, that was a very safe song. Just about anyone who can sing good or bad can pull off that song. However, you did an excellent job with the song. Like I mentioned last week, you are definately the darkhorse of the competition. You definately never popped into my mind as the winner, but my thoughts are definately changing. Keep doing what you are doing, and there is a great chance I will be seeing you in the finals! Well Done!

Stacy: Other then the crappy recording with the annoying pops throughout it (I wanted to slit my wrists because of the pops LOL) But besides that this was the best performance of the week!! I liked how you did this very good support, control and pitch. Not perfect but a great week for you nice job on this. I FELT this song and you made that happen! Keep it up!!

Do you want Kyle S to advance? Don't forget to vote!

Lastly tonight is Heather singing "Midnight Train To Georgia" by Gladys Night:

Nick: Heather, you and I both know this wasn't your best. It seems you have taken a few weeks off. Not a great time to be doing that, especially so close to the end. However, I definately don't think it was the worst tonight! Your vocals were solid and like always you have a strong voice that can pull almost anything off. Just try putting a little more effort into your performances, and song choice is key. Great Effort!

Stacy: This is such a great song and I would’ve thought this would be a good song for you, but for some reason, I wasn’t as impressed with it as I would have liked to have been. It seemed you were a bit sharp/flat in areas a little nasal in some spots and it just didn’t work for me. You still have the best voice in the competition, in my opinion but I just felt that this song was not your best. It was almost as if you didn’t know the song that well or something. I can’t pin point it but I just wasn’t feeling it. Not like your other songs. I mean, it isn’t terrible. By all means, but comparing to your others it isn’t the right fit for you. Sorry.

Do you want Heather to advance? Don't forget to vote!

Well, thats all for tonight folks! Unfortunately, yet another idol must go home:

The judges discussed who they thought were the bottom 2 this week. Andrew and Dean are this weeks bottom 2 and they are both vulnerable for elimination. Please vote for the idol you want to stick around in the poll below. Polls close at 8PM EST on Wednesday May 19th! To attend the live results chat at 9PM EST, IM VirtualPopIdol for access on AIM! Good Luck Idols! Last but not least, check out the poll on the homepage for the Final 3 Medley song vote!