Ethiopian Herders Await Aid
By ELLEN KNICKMEYER, Associated Press Writer, April 16 2000
HADAWE, Ethiopia (AP) --
Only the last of Hawo Abdi Subed's 40 camels made it to the village. Collapsed on the stones, it knelt unmoving while the old woman unloaded what was left of her family goods, and her family, after three children died along the way.
Hawo, the eldest of a band of mostly women and children, had trekked for days to the nearest village in hopes of aid -- like thousands of other ethnic Somali herders streaming in from the drought-devastated plains of southeastern Ethiopia.
She quickly learned that life was no better in the village, about 20 miles from the region's still minimal relief center of Gode.
''We came because we had no milk for the children. But they say they have no food here,'' Hawo said.
Village elder Mahamed Mahamud Gure could only record the numbers of the latest newcomers in a faded notebook, the same notebook in which he records their names when they die -- as 389 did in the last two months, according to his figures.
When the aid groups come, if the aid groups come, he wants to be able to show them.
''We are in very great want and difficulty. If anyone asks me, I want to be able to inform them,'' Gure said. ''I want them to know.''
The land has grown so hard that the people sometimes give up on digging proper graves and have resorted to shoving corpses into holes dug in termite mounds, he said. ''Twenty-five are in there,'' he said, pointing at one with his cane.
The drought threatens millions more people across the Horn of Africa, according to the U.N. World Food Program. An estimated 150,000 are in danger in Djibouti and 350,000 in Eritrea. As many as 425,000 people in Somalia would need food shipments if April rains fail, and 2.7 million in northern Kenya are hungry and urgently need donations, the WFP says.
Like the 7.7 million estimated in danger in Ethiopia, many of the first- and hardest-hit in those nations are nomadic herders.
Three years of sparse rains have killed virtually all the cattle on which Ethiopia's ethnic Somali herders draw meat, milk and life. Lush years immediately before the drought tempted many to trade their traditional camels for cattle, less hardy but more productive.
Modern borders and development have constricted migrations that used to range as far as northeast Uganda to a 60-mile-by-60-mile patch of land. That limits foraging in bad years.
Wracked by war and ongoing rebel conflicts, distrusted by the government in Addis Ababa, 620 miles and two days' drive away on miserable roads, the region and its people have little power to press for improvements that would help curb the accelerating cycles of famine.
The foreign community encouraged creation of emergency food reserves after up to 1 million people died in Ethiopia's 1984-85 famine. But gaps in donations of food or money into the relief pipeline mean aid to the nomads has slowed to a trickle in recent months.
Assistance threatens to stop entirely in June, aid agencies warned last month. That set off an international alarm, but so far it seems to have drawn far more journalists than aid workers.
The herders can't wait months; thousands gathering in Hadawe, Denan and other communities in Ethiopia's southeastern Somali region seem unlikely to make it weeks or even days.
''This child is going to die,'' said Bisharo Sheek Abdi -- speaking of her own child. The 4-year-old girl, a bundle of bones topped with the yellow hair of malnutrition, still was avidly alive enough to drink thirstily of the water that is all her mother has to give her. ''Or maybe she will live.''
The girl would be the last of her parents' four children to die. The family shelters under the hides of two of the 40 cows they used to own -- now all dead. The cloth and plastic bags hanging on the walls of the hut hold only more bags, no food.
Hadawe, which looks from the road like just a cluster of huts on the way to the growing refugee camp of Denan, has had no aid distributions for 26 days, Mahamed, the village elder, said Saturday. And the aid the herders are getting is not the aid they most need, said Ahmed Ibrahim Hussein of the Ogaden Welfare Society, a local group helping the drought-displaced.
As livestock raisers, the herders want milk. Their children must have it, Hussein said. Two-thirds of the up to 18 people being buried two to a grave each day at the Denan camp are children.
At Hadawe, Sunday afternoon finds Bisharo's 4-year-old girl dead, her body lying within a shroud in the shade of a hut. Village men hack out a grave -- a proper one -- in the heat of the sun.
It's the 27th day with no aid, Mahemed notes.
In the distance, where dust devils twirl on the horizon, herder Mahamed Olad points to indiscernible specks that he says are his cattle.
They are his last two, he says. ''When they die, then we will die too,'' he says.
Ethiopia famine yields profits for some
Financial Times (UK), April 16 2000
By Mark Turner in Djibouti - In the sweltering heat of Djibouti, the tiny former French colony in the Horn of Africa, scores of dockers noisily unload and bag 50kg sacks of European Union-bought wheat from the Vale, a vast Greek-owned bulk carrier. Swirling kernels choke the air, clouds of pigeons gorge themselves on the bounty.
The grain is destined for Ethiopia, where aid agencies warn that 8m people are at risk of famine. But to Ali Hettam, the stevedore in charge of the 2,500-tonne, 24-hour a day, unloading operation, it is an excellent commercial opportunity.
His company, Comad, is paid around $12.50 a tonne to unload, bag and shift grain onto lorries. Over the next eight months, his prospects are encouraging - the World Food Programme (WFP) is looking to ship 170,000 tonnes of food a month, of which the lion's share will go through Djibouti port.
If, as he claims, Mr Hettam has 65 per cent of the market, he could be looking at monthly turnover of around $1m - a healthy sum, even after costs. "Business is very good," he confides.
He is one of the winners not only from a big food operation, but also the vicissitudes of war politics. The Ethiopian government has refused to accept Eritrea's offer to bring aid supplies through the port of Assab, which can handle 2m tonnes of cargo a year and, before the neighbours' two-year border war, used to serve around 80 per cent of Ethiopia's needs. The United Nations - despite clear indications it would prefer to use Assab's donor-improved facilities - has agreed to focus on the alternatives.
The WFP estimates that 170,000 tonnes of food a month will be needed to avert disaster in Ethiopia. At present, Djibouti is capable of handling 100-110,000 tonnes in its deep-sea berths, while the Somaliland port of Berbera (being developed by the EU) can take around 25,000 tonnes. That leaves a shortfall of 35,000-45,000 tonnes a month. To fill that, the WFP has embarked on a $2.7m port improvement project. It is levelling two warehouses to make more room for unloading, and building a new one. It will install a new "virtual berth": an empty vessel docked alongside an oil jetty, where the grain from carriers will be bagged before it is loaded onto trucks on dry land.
In order to keep the supplies flowing south, the WFP plans to bring in 400 lorries from abroad, adding to its own fleet of up to 550 in Ethiopia. The organisation will also spend several million dollars on rehabilitating roads to the west and to the south, and will use the decrepit Djibouti-Ethiopia railway.
It will be a tight operation, with little room for error. It is also big business.
On average, delivering food from its point of origin to a hungry Ethiopian costs $250 per tonne. Multiply that by an expected 1.35m tonnes of food over the next eight months, and that makes almost $340m dollars in transport alone.
The WFP feels the cost and logistical difficulties are an acceptable price for fulfilling its overriding mandate: getting supplies through, where needed, as fast as possible.
But the operation does raise certain questions. By developing Ethiopia's alternative supply route, one could argue that the UN has become an agent of Addis Ababa's aim of isolating Eritrea. One impetus to end the war - Ethiopia's difficulty in finding an alternative port - may have lessened.
Trevor Rowe of the WFP is quick to dismiss such speculation. The impact of the programme will be small, he says, and will in no way prop up the Addis government. Others suggest it may even have the opposite effect: one of Ethiopia's main aims in the war has been to capture Assab, they say. Now it may not need to.