Ethiopians March on, but Victories Hard to Verify
Reuters; Thursday, Feb 18 1999
MAKELLE, Ethiopia, Feb 18 (Reuters) - Close to midnight on a rocky road in the mountains of northern Ethiopia, a huge column of soldiers emerged from the darkness.
The seemingly endless river of thousands of troops marched in single files, carrying rifles, ammunition, rocket propelled grenades or stretchers.
They had been walking all day, but there were no signs of weariness among the high-spirited troops who said they were fresh from a victorious battle against the Eritrean army.
"I'm not tired because we got a victory," said 22-year-old Fanton, refusing to drop his brisk pace as he spoke. "I wanted to defend my country and I am excited."
Fanton said he had volunteered for the army shortly after Eritrean forces invaded a disputed western border territory around the Ethiopian-administered town of Badme in the first round of the border war between the two nations last May.
Now his battalion and several others were making the days-long trek to the Badme front, having defeated Eritrean forces at Tsorona, Fanton said.
"I wasn't afraid but sometimes I had to kill people," he said, the whites of his eyes gleaming in the darkness. "It's good, I like it in the army."
His was one of the few direct testaments to the battlefield successes that Ethiopia says it has scored over its northern neighbour in the Horn of Africa.
Other evidence is hard to come by since journalists are often barred from the front lines. When the latest fighting first erupted, Ethiopia said it won a key victory at the Badme front, capturing an important Eritrean stronghold, but it was a further 10 days before journalists were allowed to the scene.
It was clear there had been fighting -- spent cartridges littered the Ethiopian trenches from where they said they had launched a victorious counter-offensive against Eritrean forces.
Beneath, the rolling plain was patched with circles of scorched blackened scrub where artillery shells had landed.
Ethiopia said it had encircled Eritrean troops in a pincer movement, driving them back in vicious hand-to-hand fighting and regaining some seven km (four miles) of Eritrean-held territory.
"When we advanced down the hill and saw the dead Eritreans, I felt very happy," said one Ethiopian soldier.
Driving down onto the plain in a camouflaged army vehicle, an Ethiopian commander warned the Eritrean army still held the high ground to the west and that the area was prey to shelling.
The bodies of countless Eritrean soldiers were removed long ago, he said, and prisoners of war taken to a secret location.
Asked for more concrete proof of the victory, the commander pointed to a pile of stale bread rolls behind a blue water tank.
"That is the Eritreans' bread," he said. "They get it in sacks. Our bread is like a biscuit, wrapped in plastic."
The evidence was hardly conclusive, and at the Tsorona front it was impossible to verify another commander's account from a mountaintop observation point of a fierce battle which he said left over 3,000 Eritrean soldiers killed or wounded.
Ethiopia has the backing of the international community in its demand that Eritrean troops withdraw from contested border territories, and says it has no need to gloat over its victories by presenting bloodied Eritrean bodies to the media.
On the Eritrean side of the border, television pictures show dead Ethiopian soldiers, lines of prisoners of war and an Ethiopian helicopter shot down at the southern Burre front -- all giving an impression of military supremacy.
"The Eritreans have got their propaganda machine on overdrive and it's working," a diplomat based in Addis Ababa said. "Ethiopia may be winning on the battlefield, but we've no way of knowing."