The original grunge-sound is for
me the garage sound from Sub Pop's Reciprocal Recordings studio where the early
records of Nirvana (Bleach), Soundgarden (Screaming Life), Mudhoney and some
Green River albums were recorded. All these have a rather similar but still
distinctive sound.
In the mid- and late Eighties there was a large concentration of bands like
Green River, Soundgarden, the Melvins, Nirvana, TAD and so on, which formed
the music scene of Seattle. There was a whole subculture and its bands had a
previously unknown sound in their music. This sound was supported by Sub Pop,
a local record label. Its founders Bruce Pavitt and Jonathan Poneman wanted
this sound to be consistent and so they always recorded under the same circumstances:
they always used producer Jack Endino and recorded in their Reciprocal Recordings
studio. The bands certainly didn't all sound completely alike. But there was
definitely a house sound to Sup Pop largely due to Endino's work at the Reciprocal
Recordings studio. That's why the music has rather a garage sound than a studio
sound. Reciprocal Recordings was not a very sophisticated studio and therefore
the music was bound to sound crude. In fact some drugs and the cheap beer of
Seattle might have helped to produce such a sludgy dirty sound.
On the cover of my Green River "Dry As A Bone/Rehab Doll" CD there is a sticker
on which is written: "Seattle's legendary godheads who are now Mudhoney and
Pearl Jam". And in fact Green River have a real original grungy sound. The music
is dirty, smudgy and rough and so is Mark Arm's voice. Mudhoney still make music
which is very similar to the one of Green River and they can really identify
with the word "grunge". One of their band members once said: "We're the only
grunge band left in '95. No one else will take that word 'grunge' but we will"
and that's right. Bands like Pearl Jam, Nirvana or Soundgarden don't want to
be called grunge bands. If it's the garage sound that makes up a grunge band
then I think they aren't because they have the more modern grunge sound. Although
Nirvana and Soundgarden produced their first albums with Sub Pop and therefore
once had the original sound.
The modern grunge sound is much cleaner and much more commercial than the original
one. There has been a development which went away from the more punk-like old
grunge sound to a more rock-like one. Pearl Jam for example never sounded as
dirty as Green River did. Most new grunge bands like Silverchair and Bush sound
like Pearl Jam or like Nirvana's Nevermind. As this modern sound was much more
commercial than the original one it also got much more successful and so the
modern one is the sound we all know from MTV. When someone talks about grunge
music today he usually thinks of this sound and not of the original one. It's
sad but true: grunge has become a vogue word and has thus been alienated from
its original meaning.
Nirvana began as a small hardcore-punk band which is audible on their first album Bleach. In the time of their great success with Nevermind they left behind the hardcore part of their music and concentrated on a punk-grunge mixture. This made them popular so they kept this style on their third album, In Utero, but they got a little more distorted what their record company first didn't like. But as the public loved the new record it was all right for them and the rise of Nirvana went on. Sadly the story of Nirvana ends here abruptly with the death of Kurt Cobain. The Nirvana MTV Unplugged In New York is their last legacy. Courtney Love said that the new Nirvana album would have been very much like this special with lots of acoustic material but now we'll never get to know it. Later a live album called "From the Muddy Banks of Whiskah" was released but didn't get much attention anymore.
Pearl Jam had a very clean heavy metal-rock sound on their first album Ten. There were surely some dirty guitar riffs in between but the majority was clean. On Vs. they kept the rock sound but more and more left behind their heavy metal side in favour of some more punk-like songs and on Vitalogy they added some experimental material. There is for example a song called Bugs on which Eddie Vedder plays accordion. But there is also a hint to what they did on their next album which they produced together with Eddie Vedder's idol Neil Young. It was called Mirrorball and had a really old rock sound with a hammond organ in the background. A short time later they released an EP called Merkinball which was supposed to accompany Mirrorball as is written on the back of the CD cover. Before they released their next CD No Code Eddie Vedder made two songs for the Soundtrack of the film "Dead Man Walking" together with a pakistani called Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan. These songs are very oriental and so are some songs or at least parts of songs on No Code. Their newest album is called "Yield" and was released in 1998.
Soundgarden have perhaps undergone the longest development. They began as a Sub Pop act with a garage sound but already with some heavy metal and hard rock elements. On their third newest album Badmotorfinger you can hear some fast speed metal and some slow dragging songs with murderous riffs. Then on their album Superunknown they made some experiments with oriental sounds and they worked further on this tendency on their current album Down On The Upside. Sadly they disbanded in 1997 with one last greatest hits album called "A-Sides" as their last legacy.
The Stone Temple Pilots are or at least have been the most disputed grunge band being from Los Angeles and so not belonging to Seattle's community of bands. Their first album Core appeared shortly after Nirvana's Nevermind and Pearl Jam's Ten and it sounded like a copy of some songs from these albums. Purple, their second CD had audible similarities with some older rock bands like Led Zeppelin. But in the meantime the new Stone Temple Pilots album "Tiny Music ..." is available and they finally have found their own style. Their new record has got a very obvious blues- or jazz-touch.
Alice In Chainsfall a bit out of the grunge society. They are of course from Seattle but they have neither produced a record with Sub Pop nor has any member of them played in a Sub Pop band. They never had a very grungy sound but rather a hard rock or heavy metal one. Their development gets obvious in two EPs they have released. The "SAP"and the "Jar Of Flies"-EP are completely different from all their other albums. Phil Alexander, an editor of the music magazine "Kerrang!" wrote about it : "It is their [Alice In Chains'] most intimate moment. This [...] is Alice In Chains at their purest. Listen without prejudice". The two EPs have some very acoustic songs on them also with some jazzy parts and even a gospel- or spiritual-like song.
All in all we can say that there
is something that all the "old" grunge bands like Alice In Chains, Pearl Jam
and Soundgarden have in common. After their music got copied by so many bands
they seem to have tried to get away from their grunge image and develop their
own distinctive style. This way their new albums all have some experimental
elements. These developments become obvious through the instruments the bands
use. Pearl Jam used a hammond organ on their EP Merkinball, the Stone Temple
Pilots had a muted trumpet on the song Adhesive from their new album Tiny Music...
and on Soundgarden's Down On The Upside the song Ty Cobb begins with a short
passage with Mandolin and Mandola.
After all I must say that when you listen to one of the albums mentioned above
not all the songs are the same. On almost every one there is a ballad and a
fast song and a heavy one and so on.
In the following graphic I've tried to make clear the relationships between the bands: