Israel's Media Watch IMW Update Report -
#21, October 26, 1999 - Eli Pollak, IMW Chairman and
Yisrael Medad, IMW Director
met with MK Zevulon Orlov, Chairman of the Knesset
Education
Committee. Orlov's Committee supervises all media
concerns
that are dealt with in the Knesset.
MK Orlov reconfirmed IMW's status as a permanent guest
of the Committee when media matters are brought to its
agenda.
He also discussed different media themes that he thought
would
be appropriate for the Committee to discuss in the future.
- Deputy
Minister Yitzhak Vaknin in the Ministry
of Communicationshas agreed in principle to meet with IMW
representatives and an appointment is tentatively
arranged for the very near future.
- IMW was
informed by the State Attorney's Office that
the appeal against the decision to close the file on the
investigation of Eitan Oren, suspected of staging a
fabricated news clip of a "swearing-in ceremony"
of Avishai Raviv's Eyal organization, was still under
review.
The letter contained an apology for the lack of
communication since
the appeal was filed in middle May this year.
Miriam Suker, a senior
Justice Department official was assigned to the appeal.
IMW is determined to utilize all possible legal avenues
in
pursuit of justice in this matter based on the open
evidence.
- The IMW
weekly personal opinion corner broadcast over
Arutz 7 on Thursdays has been suspended due to the
station's desire to afford others an opportunity for free
expression.
The "Freedom of Broadcasting" hour-long
interview program
continues at its regular hour of 8-9AM every Sunday
morning.
- The
preventing of IMW from reaching the audience
of the main public broadcast radio of Kol Yisrael
continues. The two main
morning interview hosts, Shelly Yechimovicz and Daliah Ya'ari,
consistently refuse to entertain any IMW representative
on their
programs.
Kol Yisrael's media show, Docu-Media, has hosted Eli
Pollak although the television edition has studiously
avoided permitting an IMW rep. to appear.
- IMW
complained about a gross lack of balance relating
to
a segment broadcast on the Educational Television Network
(ETN)
program, "Woman's Viewpoint", via TV's Channel
Two.
The segment, moderated by feminist journalist Billy
Moskuna-
Lerman, dealt with the subject of women and the military.
The
show's participants included the head of "Four
Mother's Movement",
a group championing immediate withdrawal from Lebanon,
Ruth
Ben-David; Manuela Dviri, another movement activist who
writes in the Ma'ariv daily on the subject; Vered Shomron,
the head of yet another anti-war group called "New
Medical Profile" and Kol Yisrael's military
correspondent Carmela Menasheh. It should be noted
that Moskuna-Lerman admitted in an interview that should
would support her son's decision to refuse military
service if he so decided.
IMW stated that the show was unbalanced and did not
include,
for example a Women's Corps representative. We also
complained
that the participants were asked to give PM Barak advice
on how
to more quickly withdraw the troops, turning the segment
into a
blatant political statement.
- IMW's special report on the bias
promoted [in Hebrew] by the two main
daily newspapers during the elections, Ma'ariv and Yediot
Ahronot, which originally appeared in the Ha'Umma
Quarterly, was republished by the weekly Makor Rishon,
including some minor corrections.
As a result, Daniel Bloch, moderator of Kol Yisrael's
current affairs
program on the First Station, will be interviewing
Yisrael Medad on
Friday, October, 29.
From the Words of Lord
Holme, recently appointed
Chairman of the British Broadcasting Standards Commission:
"On the fairness side, freedom of information has to
be balanced
by fair and responsible journalism and a basic right to
privacy...
we will play an active role in ensuring that the
broadcast media
remain accountable to public expectations, and do so
openly and
transparently ourselves".
IMW applauds these goals and repeats it own aim of
establishing,
through legislation, an Israeli complaints review board,
similar in
form to the BSC and other institutions, as was
recommended in
the Peled Commission Report of which IMW's chairman, Prof.
Eli
Pollak, was a member.
|