T   H   E     R   I   N   G     O   F     H   O   N   O   R

  2008 Cleveland Browns

Home | Draft Board | Awards Board | 1999 | 2000 | 2001 | 2002 | 2003 | 2004 | 2005 | 2006 | 2007 | 2008 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2012 | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | 2024 | 2025 | 2026 | 2027 | 2028 | 2029 | 2030 | 2031 | 2032 | 2033 | 2034 | 2035

2008 Cleveland Browns

Year End Score: 79 (100/92/52/71)

No retirements.

We remove the Franchise designation from DT Christian Peter and place it on FB Edwin Bednarik. Bednarik wouldn't renegotiate, but his skill level coupled with his backup's refusal to re-sign left us with no choice.

Both our Scout, Erik Johan, and Coach, Martin Force stay. They are both clearly the creme-de-la-creme at their positions. I recommend giving Johan a raise in the near future.

Fan Loyalty and Support for Stadium are both maxed-out at 100 (again). Since we are coming off a Superbowl year, (but still saw a sharp decrease in revenue), we raise prices between 4%-6% across the board. Still, none of our prices are the highest in the league.

Franchise Value: 716,230,000 (1st overall, 42/100/99/52)

Free Agency
We go into free agency with precious little cap room and it looks like we are going to lose backups Earnest Astley (FB) and Dan Neil (G). We need a DE, but the prices are still insanely high, and we are close to maxed, so we wait till the latter stages, hoping a solid backup drops down. None does. We lose the aforementioned players, but move confidently into the draft.

The Draft
We begin the draft with a 1st round pick (32), and two 2nd round picks (7 and 32). Our mission is two-fold - get a stud DE by any means necessary and add to our depth on the aging o-line. We have little cap space and lots of aspirations, so we put on our Trader Jack hat.

Trades
Trade #1: Backup QB Sieh, 5th WR Porter, 2008 2nd round pick (32), 2009 5th and 7th round picks to Baltimore for 2008 1st (7) and 3rd (7) rounders and a 2009 1st round pick.

Unhappy with the draft depth, we trade down.

Trade #2: 2008 1st (7) and 3rd (7) rounders to Philly for 2008 1st (10) and 2nd (10) rounders.

Unable to choose between a stud G and a maxed-out LB, we look to pick up another 1st rounder.

Trade #3: Backup LB Conrad Bernstein to Minnesota for 2008 1st rounder (12).

Our 4th trade has several motivations. Backup RB DeStefano is demanding a trade and is int he last year of his contract. This draft is also stacked with Cornerbacks (as are we). So we can probably move a good veteran backup and not lose much in that category.

Trade #4: Backup CB Jerald Mummert and backup RB OJ DeStefano to San Diego for 2008 2nd rounder (17) and 2009 1st rounder.

We draft:

10. Freddie Kobeski, LB, Indiana (94/96/98/72).
12. Cory Corbett, G, Texas Southern (96/90/96).
39. Chuck Coleman, CB, Oklahoma (94/98/90/x/x/96).
42. Buddy Donovan, T, North Texas (70/76/61).
49. Dale Hixson, DE, Hawaii (54/64/45).

We tried for a solid hour to get a stud DE from another team, but the asking price was three 1st rounders - to much in my estimation. Hopefully, the draft cupboard is full for Darkiller for the next two years: 4 1st rounders, 2 2nd, 2 3rd, 2 4th, 5th, 6th, and 7th.

We sign every draftee and renegotiate almost every contract on the roster - re-upping almost every starter for 3 more years. We end up with 6 million dollars in cap flexibility.

After training camp, we receive an interesting offer for Sheen. The first pick in the 2008 draft - who happened to be a DE. We pass.


Exhibition Season

We choose seven studs to sit during the preseason - partly to avoid the injury bug, partly to give our new backups, QB Bucky Chapman and RB Tom Battle a crash course in game day experience.

We finish the exhibition season a respectable 3-1. Chapman and Battle perform well. The magnificent seven are activated and we get ready to start the season. Our passing cohesion drops like a stone though - probably because Davies was moved to third string and Sieh was traded. Hopefully this will normalize after a few games. Hopefully.

Here is a quick peek at our starting lineup on gameday (Bold denotes keeper):

Offense: (current/future/experience)
QB Blaine Davies (18/18/10)
Flanker: Harvey Wallace (17/17/9)
Split End: BJ Bushon (13/14/2)
RB: Donnie Sheen (17/18/7)
FB: Edwin Bednarik (13/12/9)
TE: Ronald Stark (16/16/9)
LT: Jamie Nails (18/19/12)
LG: Raleigh Roundtree (17/17/12)
C: Jeff Smith (15/16/13)
RG: Ruben Brown (13/12/14)
RT: Flozell Adams (16/17/11)

Special Teams
P: Quinn Slay (12/12/10)
K: Corey Rollins (16/15/10)
KR: Dusty Parrish (6/8/3)
PR: Doug Barnette (3/4/2)

Defense
LDE: Jason Taylor (11/10/12)
RDE: Matt Champion (17/17/5)
LDT: BJ Mudgett (18/17/8)
RDT: Tommy Pieper (13/15/3)
OLB: Leon Roose (14/13/8)
MLB: Rufus Duke (17/16/10)
OLB: JR Farmer (13/12/9)
FS: JR Quinn (14/16/4)
SS: Joseph Swift (12/17/2)
CB: Christian Ferderer (17/19/4)
CB: BJ Carr (16/16/9)

Future Stars
LB: Phil West (11/19/2)
LB: Freddie Kobeski (9/19/1)
CB: Chuck Coleman (10/19/1)
CB: Ross Dawson (16/19/3)
T: Willie Guy (15/18/6)
T: Buddy Donovan (7/15/1)
G: Cory Corbett (9/17/1)
C: Cornell Flowers (13/16/3)
G: Harvey Gretzky (12/16/2)
DT: Dwayne James (11/15/2)
QB: Bucky Chapman (9/15/2)

On to the regular season!

2008 Regular Season

You can access the box scores by clicking on the link. They are saved in Adobe Acrobat format (the Reader is free from Adobe's web site). Let's get right to it...

Week 1
Cleveland (0-0) at St. Louis (0-0)(-3) .
Rams win 34-31.

Week 2
Cleveland (0-1) (-1) at Atlanta (0-1).
Cleveland wins 15-10.

Week 3
Cleveland (1-1) at Jacksonville (2-0) (-2).
Cleveland wins 38-18.

Week 4
Cleveland (2-1) (-2) at Baltimore(1-2).
Cleveland wins 13-3.

Week 5
Cleveland (3-1) at Pittsburgh (2-2) (-1).
Steelers win 13-12.

Week 6
Cleveland (3-2) (-2) at Baltimore (2-3).
Baltimore wins 41-13.

Week 7
NY Jets (5-0) (-5)at Cleveland (3-3).
Cleveland wins 29-24.

Week 8
Jacksonville (4-3) at Cleveland (4-3) (-10).
Cleveland wins 34-3..

Week 9
Cleveland (5-3) at Cincy (5-3) (-2) .
Cincy wins 31-19.

Week 10
Bye Week

Week 11
Cincy (6-3) at Cleveland (5-4) (-3).
Cincy wins 35-13..

Week 12
Tennessee(4-6) at Cleveland (5-5) (-5).
Tennessee wins 34-31..

Week 13
San Francisco (3-8) at Cleveland (5-6) (-8).
San Francisco wins 13-0..

Week 14
New Orleans (6-6) at Cleveland (5-7) (-4).
Cleveland wins 44-19..

Week 15
Cleveland (6-7) at Tennessee (7-6) (-2).
Tennessee wins 21-14..

Week 16
Cleveland (6-8) at New England (6-8) (-2).
New England wins 41-31..

Week 17
Pittsburgh (6-9) at Cleveland (6-9) (-3).
Cleveland wins 24-20..

2008 Playoffs

Wildcard Round
Arizona (9-7) @ Carolina (10-6): Carolina 17-10.
Tennessee (9-7) @ Baltimore (9-7): Baltimore 27-17
Oakland (9-7) @ Denver (10-6): Denver 21-17
Tampa Bay (9-7) @ Detroit (11-5): Detroit 24-20

Quarterfinal Round
Detroit (12-5) @ Atlanta (11-5): Detroit 28-3
Baltimore (10-7) @ NY Jets (13-3): NY Jets 31-14
Arizona (11-6) @ Philadelphia (11-5): Arizona 12-3
Denver (11-6) @ Cincy (11-5): Cincy 33-7

Conference Finals
Carolina (12-6) @ Detroit (13/5): Detroit 27-21
Cincinnati (12-5) @ NY Jets (14-3): Cincinnati 33-27

Superbowl
Detroit (14-6) @ Cincinnati (14-5): Cincinnati 30-17.

2008 Postseason

Honor Roll

RB Donnie Sheen: 297 att, 1,349 yds, 4.7 ypc, 11 tds, 37 rec., 369 yds, 4 tds.
1st Team RB

Key Players
QB Blaine Davies: 13 gs, 179-328 (54.5%), 2,455 (7.8 ypc), 17 tds, 6 ints, 88.4 rating.
WR BJ Bushon: 53 rec, 994 yds, 18.7 ypc, 4 tds.
LB Leon Roose: 87 tckls, 2.5 scks.
DE Matt Champion: 14.0 scks.

Analysis

We were decimated by injuries this year and that is what derailed us, plain and simple. Davies missed three games out right and was questionable in at least 4 more. We lost a number of starters for the season or extended time due to injury. The good news is that everyone is signed and Daveis and Sheen are chugging to the Hall. Good luck Darkiller.

More thoughts on our little team:

This bad year could have been a blessing in disguise, as many guys that were 2 or 3 years away from developing (QB Chapman, our two stud young LBs, some o-linemen) got lots and lots of real game experience.

Offense

Skill Positions: Our bread and butter. Two future HOFers here, although I am concerned about Davies' long-term durability (he misses 2 games per season on average). Conversely, Sheen hasn't missed a game in SIX SEASONS. Davies and Sheen are signed through 2011 and 2010, respectively. FB Edwin Bednariks skill level is starting to decline in to the low 60's, but he should be fine through at least the end of his contract (2010). It might be worth re-upping Chapman now - as he is getting pissy about backing up Davies. The wideouts are a an outstanding group and have a nice mix - two 9-year vets (Wallace, Woodson) and two 2nd year guys (Bushon, Dougherty). I think Bushon, in particular, is going to be something special.
Needs:Getting a better backup for Sheen (although Battle has looked good in preseason) might be in order. Bednarik also needs an understudy. Chapman needs to be signed to an extension before he gets too pissy, preferably right after he has been given the opportunity to start a couple of pre-season games..

Offensive Line: Lots of old guys, but I have always held the belief that the best o-lines are manned by grizzled veterans. Our cohesion rating for this group (96) is second in the league. The Tackles (Nails (78/99/72), Adams (87,81,90) are still playing at a high level, as is G Roundtree (89/100/63). G Brown (78/53/64) and C Smith (91/59/69) are begining to wear down. We have two guys T Willie Guy and C Cornell Flowers, who are ready to step in and contribute - I had Guy starting at Guard last year with some of the o-line injuries and he did well. A lot of the young guys are getting pissed about having to sit, so some decisions need to be made. Our Tes are solid, with TE Stark still playing at a high level - with a solid backup behind him (Bobby Lofton).
Needs: Ride the old guys as much as possible, but try and at least work in T Guy and maybe C Flowers..

Defense

Defensive Line: Suprisingly, this unit held up without injury - all year long. The DTs are strong in the pass rushing area and (except for Mudgett) are weak against the run. DT Pieper (60/78/96) and DT James (67/92/57) are certainly serviceable and can keep this position manned until a Mudgett-clone drops in our laps. DT Peter is odd man out and not happy. Trade him while he has value. The DEs are another story. DE Jason Taylor, while only missing 4 games in 10 years, is near the end - he started every game for us last year but only recorded 3 sacks. And he is awful against the run - before our rash of injuries to the LBs, I was starting LB Morotn at DE against the run. DE McDaniel (41/42/27) and Hisxon (54/64/45) are no better than backups. Thank god for DE Matt Champion (87/92/100) - and he's signed through 2011.
Needs:DE is the absolute most pressing need on this team, particularly if Taylor retires. DT is actually fairly strong, although I would make sure you have a run stopper at MLB..

Linebackers: In a year or two, we are gong to have a linebacking corps for the ages. They got crushed by injuries this year, though, and I am hoping that Duke (61/81/89/93) can return to form. If he can, we are ooking at the potential of three maxed-out starters (Duke, 3rd year Phil West, 2nd year Freddie Kobeski)and backups like the hard-nosed Roose (484 career tckls), and overachievers KC Morton (5th round pick) and JR Farmer (7th round pick, 5 year starter) .
Needs:Playing time. The horses are in place after two straight 1st round picks.

Secondary: The same can be said for our Secondary. Our corners (4 potential/actual excellents)are young and infinitely talented - I think Ferderer (17 ints in 3 years) can make the HOF. So are our two starting safeties, Quinn (4 year vet) and Swift (2 years). If we need anything here, its a backup to help the aging Leomont Evans (13 year vet).
Needs:Corners are the best group in the league, and all but Carr and KR Barnette are signed through 2010. A stud safety is a priority - to replace Evans and learn the position and then to eventually supplant Quinn.

All-Overpaid Team
LB JR Farmer, 4,000,000
DE Jason Taylor, 3,360,00
DT Christian Peter 3,200,000

All-Underpaid Team
CB Christian Ferderer, 1,750,000
LB Rufus Duke, 1,500,000
FB Edwin Bednarik, 1,200,000
DT Dwayne James, 850,000

 

 

     
1