The Second Battle for West Melton

Dave's Excuses

What not to do with a Polybian Army Against the Carts

  • Mistake number 1: I confess to a henous crime. I HAD NO PLAN!

  • Mistake number 2: I set up in a defensive position in the corner to avoid the rough ground and hills (I'd placed!) on three quaters of the field. It takes a bold agressive hand to use the Polys properly, although they're good at a conservative stance when circumstances present. And while this was the time to be fairly conservative (Carts have more elements that don't mind rough ground.)...

  • Mistake number 3: Now seeing the Carts in full array advancing, I thought 'cor, I reckon I can take em, wiv just a little bit O fancy foot work.' And being suddenly inspired by a wave of square dancing I promptly set about re deploying the entire army! Arrgh! Doe-ce-doe! Under the mistaken assupmtion that two PS and Sp elements could handle the elephants and Wb (my only poor defence, I haven't actually read the 2.0 rules yet (yes I know not a good excuse)!)

  • Mistake number 4 as a result of all of the above: In for a penny in for a pound! However all but four elements of the Poly army only move @ 200pcs a turn. Arggh. Not so much Doe-ce-doe. 7 turns to redeploy (lesson about slow moving 'killer' elements for everyone there) and...

  • Now Nick had a plan. A good one which was going to be hard to beat even without the previous...mistakes. But, I never redeployed completely and got stuck because: I ran out of PIPS, and the Blades didn't move quick enough and the left hand flank got congested.

  • I was left with a weak centre and slow moving flanks! Facing one of the most cunning plans I've seen in a while. Including a slight of hand and a feint! But I'll let Nick explain that.

  • The End: Came mercifully quickly. I just didn't have the cohesion needed to win against the Carts with the van gone. There was even a sort of poetic end to it with Nick's mercenary Gallic general dispatching the Roman general as the last element to fall on my side. Lesson learnt.

  • Hindsight: the only thing I think I could have done once committed to the dance was to get the Sp meeting the Ele with Ps support BEHIND them and Bls on either side (Nick suggested this after I lost one of the Ps and the other had fled. A gracious suggestion but unfortunately too late to rescue the game for me).

    I have no excuse for this particular set of events. Maybe it was the stars, or something. But definately a good example of just about every mistake you can make with a Poly army.


Back to the Second Battle for West Melton


This page hosted by Get your own Free Homepage