American Consulates in Turkey Reopen After Review
January 2, 2001 6:46 am EST

ANKARA, Turkey (Reuters) - American consulates in the Turkish cities of Istanbul and Adana reopened on Tuesday after a three-week closure for a security review, an embassy official said.

"We announced the consulates were closed to review the security situation and today we can confirm they reopened," the official said. He declined to comment on whether the consulates had been closed because of a specific threat.

The consulates in Turkey were closed at the same time as the U.S. embassy in Qatar, also shut for security reasons.

The moves followed the bombing of a U.S. warship at the port of Aden in Yemen in October.

Turkey prison standoff continues

Police in Turkey are preparing to end a three-day long siege at a jail on the outskirts of Istanbul.

They've already stormed many jails across Turkey to stop nationwide protests by prisoners.

The violence has left more than twenty people dead.

At the Umraniye prison near Istanbul, more than four hundred inmates, many of them members of extreme left-wing groups, are armed with makeshift weapons, including flamethrowers.

They're protesting against government plans to move them to jails with smaller dormitories which are easier to supervise.

But the prisoners say they'll be more vulnerable to attack by violent guards.

A BBC correspondent in Istanbul says the violence has again focussed attention on the poor state of Turkish prisons and possible human rights abuses. (BBC)

Thursday, 21 December, 2000, 23:32 GMT

Turkey troops set to storm jail

The EU has condemned the crackdown

Turkish police are trying to end a three-day siege at a prison on the outskirts of Istanbul, the last jail still controlled by its inmates three days after the authorities moved to quell nationwide revolts.

More than 20 people have died over the past three days as police have raided 20 jails in an attempt to break a hunger-strike by prisoners protesting at plans to move inmates to maximum security prisons.

Police are now preparing to storm Umraniye jail, where more than 400 prisoners are still holding out armed with a variety of makeshift weapons including flame-throwers.

Earlier in the day, more than 150 protesters surrendered at the jail in the city of Canakkale, in eastern Turkey.

The Turkish Government says the transfer of inmates is necessary to break the influence of organised groups within prisons.

 Many victims are said to have set themselves ablaze Thursday's raid came as the Turkish parliament voted again to extend an amnesty to many prisoners.

President Ahmet Necdet Sezer, who had earlier vetoed the measure on the grounds that it was unfair and divisive, has now bowed to pressure and ratified it.

The amnesty could halve the number of prison inmates, currently estimated at about 75,000.

Critics say it will free common murderers but ignore inmates such as Kurdish guerrillas and Islamist militants who have fallen foul of Turkey's tight political restrictions.

Prisoner ablaze

During Thursday's raid on Canakkale prison, the police used heavy machinery to smash holes in the walls of the prison blocks and force their way in.

They also removed the corpse of a prisoner thrown into the courtyard.

Turkish Justice Minister Kikmet Sami Turk confirmed earlier in Ankara that a female prisoner had died there after being set ablaze by fellow inmates.

 More than 100 other hunger-strikers are in hospital with injuries.

Hundreds of troops accompanied by bulldozers, fire-engines and armoured cars were still struggling on Thursday to enter the jail at Umraniye.

Television pictures showed helicopters circling above and paramilitary police trying to enter through the roofs of the prison blocks.

The Interior Ministry said security forces had been met with "flame-throwers made of kitchen gas canisters, petrol bombs, pipebombs and cutting, piercing weapons".

The hunger strikers believe that the new jails - which have one- or three-person cells - will leave them vulnerable to abuse by the prison authorities. Most prisoners are currently kept in dormitory-style cells.

Rights concern

But the European Commission expressed concern over the crackdown.

 Inmates fear new cells will expose them to abuse Spokesman Jean-Christophe Filori said: "We are worried. We call upon all parties to stop the violence in order to reach a peaceful outcome."

Turkey's attempt to gain membership of the EU depends on improving its human rights record and democratic institutions.

Human rights groups have also condemned the assault.

Amnesty International called for a full and independent inquiry into the raids.

The government tried to reassure the inmates that the controversial plan of moving them had been postponed until legal amendments were passed to allow inmates to associate in recreational areas and to introduce civilian supervision. (BBC)

Thursday, 21 December, 2000, 18:44 GMT

The battle of Bayrampasa


Militants and their role models in an Istanbul prison

Conflicting accounts have appeared in the Turkish and Kurdish media over why so many people were hurt during the security operation in Istanbul's Bayrampasa prison.

The Turkish Health Ministry said in an initial statement that a total of eight people died there, five in the prison itself and three later in hospital.

It added that of the 81 prisoners hurt, 66 had been hospitalised.

However, one newspaper, Radikal, reported that 14 of the prison's estimated 300 inmates lost their lives.

Bayrampasa housed militants from the Revolutionary People's Liberation Party-Front (DHKP-C), the Turkish Workers and Peasant Liberation Army (TIKKO), the Marxist-Leninist Communist Party [MLKP] and the Kurdistan Workers' Party [PKK].

The mass-circulation daily Milliyet said that, when they first entered the prison, the security forces could not believe how much it had been altered by the inmates.

"There were doors where the walls were supposed to be and doors had been turned into walls," it said.

Another mass-circulation newspaper, Hurriyet, carried a graphic account of the conditions encountered by the security forces.

It said the eyewitness was a soldier who took part in the operation.

The soldier's tale

"We entered C-Block where the militants were housed," the soldier said.

"We urged them by Tannoy to surrender. The prisoners started shouting slogans and setting their beds, quilts and blankets alight. We repeated our surrender request and the PKK militants surrendered...

"We regained control of the cells in C-Block, one after another. But in the section where the terrorists were housed we could hear bombs exploding, and automatic rifle fire.

 At least eight died in the Bayrampasa operation "The terrorists connected the cells of the block by boring holes through the walls. When their resistance weakened in one cell, they retreated to another. We had to break in through the walls to intervene when the fires started...

"Meanwhile the leaders of the organisation were issuing their orders. But the most horrifying thing was that the leaders poured petrol on the militants and set them alight with matches. We were too far from the burning militants to intervene."

The inmate's tale

Birsen Kars, who had been in Bayrampasa for five years, was among those who suffered serious burns during the course of the security operation.

According to Milliyet, she blamed her fellow militants for her condition: "They set six of us women alight", she said.

But the pro-PKK television channel, Medya TV, which broadcasts from Paris, quoted two unnamed female inmates from Bayrampasa as saying six of their colleagues had been "thrown into the fire alive by the Turkish police forces".

"Six people were killed in the fire. Six persons were burned alive. They were burned alive," one of the prisoners told the TV as she was taken to hospital.

Appeal

Kiraz Bicici, a deputy leader of the Istanbul Human Rights Association, told Medya TV that while some prisoners may have committed suicide, most of the casualties had been caused by the excessive use of force by the Turkish authorities.

 Unbelievable massacres have been carried out in 20 prisons in Turkey. I would like to tell this to the whole world  Kiraz Bicici "Once again, the state showed its true face," she said.

"There may have been some who committed self immolation. But the real reason for the deaths were the light anti-tank weapons and tear gas bombs. The inmates were burned by them", she said.

"Unbelievable massacres have been carried out in 20 prisons in Turkey. I would like to tell this to the whole world and call the whole world to be aware of this issue." (BBC)

Wednesday, 20 December, 2000, 19:23 GMT

Turkish press backs prison operations

 

Special forces transfer an injured prisoner to hospital

Columnists in many Turkish newspapers have given broad support to the government's decision to launch raids to end the long-running hunger strikes in prisons across the country.

But several commentators questioned the timing of the move and the violence that has surrounded it.

Writing in the liberal newspaper Yeni Asir Mehlika Turkmenoglu described the situation as a "tragi-comedy".

"The government cannot be criticized for conducting this operation but only for doing it so late," she wrote.

"We paid the price yesterday for a government which lacks authority even in its own prisons and for the existence of prison cells where the state's writ had no power for more than nine years.

"A country which cannot guarantee the right to live even in prisons does not deserve any other human right," Ms Turkmenoglu said.

Hornets' nest

Guneri Civaoglu from the mass-circulation daily Milliyet also asked why the government had not acted much earlier and he questioned the methods employed.

"Such an operation was suggested many times by the former ministers of justice and internal affairs, but they could not manage to get a decision backing it... no former government wanted to poke a stick into a hornets' nest," he wrote.

 Our leaders... hesitated too long Radikal "The government made every effort to shed as little blood as possible ... [but] it could have used smoke bombs such as are used in other countries, producing less violent results."

Haluk Sahin from left-wing daily Radikal took the same view.

"Our leaders, who fail even at more simplistic questions, obviously and unfortunately failed at these questions too ... they hesitated too long," he wrote.

Smell of death

Hikmet Bila, writing in the left-wing Cumhuriyet, said the government's decision to act had been expected.

"These hunger strikes which had been going on over two months had the smell of death ... While the prisoners were heading towards death minute by minute, their persistence was tearing at the public conscience. Finally the operation was launched and their protest was brought to a halt".

The fundamentalist daily Turkiye gave its support to the government. "Yesterday's sudden operations gave us the hope that the security forces would finally take the control in hand," Yilmaz Oztuna wrote.

"If they keep it tight from now on, if they don't loosen it, the rule of gangs in prison could come to an end and the state will resume control of its own prisons."

Government patience

Writing in the mass-circulation daily Hurriyet, Ertugrul Ozkok said human rights groups had contributed to the rise in tension by encouraging the action of the hunger strikers and criticising the state.

 It would be unjust to blame the government Hurriyet "The NGOs in our country have a natural reflex to take a negative attitude to the state," Mr Ozkok said.

"The state, which is accustomed to using force, has been showing intense patience over the last 20 days.

"It would be unjust to blame the government for any bloodshed from now on," he said.

In an editorial in the Turkish Daily News, Mehmet Ali Birand said the government would win praise at home for finally taking hold of a situation that was spinning out of control.

"Throughout the country the operation was considered a positive development, and a surge in the stock market was the most interesting indicator of public support."

Human cost

Fatih Altayli in Hurriyet criticised the left-wing organizations whose members are involved in the prison hunger strikes.

"These militants who died in vain in the prisons and those who murdered them viciously should know that they don't have the support of the public. Whatever political opinion they have, the man in the street supports the govenment," he said.

 A curse on those who play political games with human life Cumhuriyet Ilhan Selcuk from Cumhuriyet stressed the cost in human lives.

"Can a country be ruled by its prisons? No," he wrote.

"A curse on those who play political games with human life, be they in the administration or running an anti-government organization. Anybody who, in the lust for power, conducts policies against human life, is nothing but a monster." (BBC)

Three killed as Turkish prison unrest continues

Three more prisoners at the Canakkale jail in western Turkey have died in a massive security crackdown on hunger-striking prisoners, bringing the death toll to 22.

The interior ministry says another 16 prisoners have been injured in the prison, one of two institutions in which hundreds of armed inmates had barricaded themselves inside.

The earlier toll in the operation launched against 20 jails had stood at 20 dead - 18-prisoners and two soldiers.

Turkish officials have previously said most of the prisoners died after setting fire to themselves, while the two soldiers were shot.

Paramilitary troops have succeeded in seizing control of the Canakkale prison, but they are still battling to break the resistance of inmates in the Umraniye prison in Istanbul.
(ABC)

Top World News
Fri, 22 Dec 2000, 6:10am EST

Turkish Inmates Resist for 3rd Day; Death Toll Now 21 (Update2)
By Yalman Onaran

Istanbul, Dec. 21 (Bloomberg) -- Inmates in one Turkish prison held out against security forces for a third day, while prisoners at another jail surrendered to authorities. The death toll rose to 21 in raids that began Tuesday.

About 170 prisoners at the Canakkale jail, three hours west of Istanbul, surrendered to security forces this afternoon, the interior ministry said. Three inmates were killed and 16 injured during the operation at Canakkale.

Security forces have regained control of 19 prisons. Some 450 prisoners at Umraniye jail in Istanbul are still holding out, eluding capture by using passageways to move into other prison blocks shortly before each raid.

``The reason the remaining operations are taking so long is because the security forces do not want any casualties,'' said Justice Minister Hikmet Sami Turk.

The raids were aimed at ending a hunger strike by about 1,300 prisoners. The inmates, led by left-wing groups, are protesting plans to move them into new jails, saying the change to smaller cells from the current dormitory system would leave them open to violence and abuse by prison authorities.

``If the operation was an effort to preserve life ... it was terrible failure,'' Human Rights Watch said in a statement.

The government moved in on the 60th day of the protest after doctors warned that some of the hunger strikers might die.

Many of the prisoners have now been moved to the cell-type prisons they were trying to avoid, because the raids have destroyed some of the older prisons.

Gaining Control

As a result of the raids, the government has reasserted its authority over prisons that had been out of control for as long as a decade. In the Bayrampasa jail in Istanbul, where 12 inmates died this week, wardens weren't able to enter some wards, and Prisoners used cell phones and fax machines to send press releases claiming responsibility for the murders of businessmen.

Inmates have used smuggled rifles to carry out executions, later releasing video tapes of the ``trials'' where other prisoners were condemned to death.

Most of the prisoners died after setting themselves on fire, with 94 inmates wounded during the raids, the government said. Two soldiers were killed when prisoners opened fire, and four others were wounded in the effort to bring the prisons under control, the Interior Ministry said in a statement.

Turkish officials said most of the 800 hunger-strikers hospitalized were in good condition because they had taken sugared water and vitamin pills during their fasts. They blamed doctors who examined the strikers before the raids for exaggerating their conditions. Doctors denied the accusation.

``We've re-examined the strikers in hospitals and see serious damages that are remnants of a hunger-strike,'' said Umit Ergun, head of the Ankara Doctors' Association. Some strikers are still resisting medical assistance and continuing their strike, Ergun said.



europe

Turkey moves on prison clashes
By FT.com staff Published: December 21 2000 16:03GMT
Last Updated: December 21 2000 16:55GMT

The Turkish parliament on Thursday approved a prison amnesty bill aimed at halving the country's inmate population. The proposal, which has already been vetoed once by President Ahmet Necdet Sezer, could still be referred to the constitutional court. If it is passed, it could mean nearly half of Turkey's 72,000 prison inmates being released by reducing prison sentences for crimes committed before April 23 1999 by 10 years. The potential beneficiaries include convicted murderers and thieves, but not rapists, corrupt officials, drug traffickers, separatist rebels or Islamic militants. The parliament's move came as violent clashes between paramilitary police and prison inmates entered their third day. Clashes began between police and prisoners on Tuesday after soldiers stormed 20 prisons across the country to end a two-month hunger strike in protest against a government bill to move inmates to smaller cells. Although police subdued resistance at the majority of institutions, by Thursday morning prisoners armed with guns and makeshift flame-throwers were still holding out against government forces in Istambul's Umraniye prison and at Canakkale in western Turkey. Local media reports said shots had been fired and police were using tear gas canisters in clashes which have left at least 19 people dead, including 17 prisoners and two police, and more than 75 injured. There were unconfirmed reports later in the day that police had subdued protestors at Canakkale, leaving only 400 protestors holding out at Umraniye. This week's violence is the culmination of a long-running struggle by the Turkish government to regain control over a prison population housed mainly in large dormitories. Turkish officials said the move to smaller cells was aimed at breaking the influence of organised groups within the prisons. In a bid to break the prisoners' control over the dormitories, which hold up to 100 prisoners, the government commissioned the construction of a number of maximum security prisons containing cells designed to hold between one and three inmates. But prisoners began a hunger strike in protest against the measures, saying a move to small cells would make them vulnerable to abuse. The violence has been widely condemned by international human rights groups, and could be a significant setback for Turkey, which is looking to gain membership of the European Union. Turkey's acceptance into the EU depends on improving both its human rights record and the transition towards democratic institutions.

Turkey: Trial of Islamic militants starts in Istanbul
BBC Monitoring Service - United Kingdom; Oct 23, 2000

Text of report in English by the Turkish news agency Anatolia

Istanbul, 23rd October: Trial of 51 suspects who are members of illegal Islamic Great Eastern Raiders Front (IBDA-C) started on Monday [23rd October] at Bakirkoy High Criminal Court No 3 in Istanbul.

Salih Izzet Erdis, leader of the illegal organization, who is also known as "Salih Mirzabeyoglu", is among the suspects.

The suspects requested additional time to prepare their defence.

The court delegation accepted the request and adjourned the hearing.

The indictment prepared by the Bakirkoy Republican Chief Prosecutor's Office, said that the suspects had staged a protest at the Metris prison in Istanbul on 24th January 2000 against gendarmerie teams who were trying to take Erdis to the Istanbul State Security Court (DGM) for a court session.

The indictment sought imprisonment terms from 14 years to 21 years to suspects Salih Izzet Erdis, Ali Osman Zor, Unsal Zor, Saban Cavdar, Omer Kama, Etem Koylu, Hasan Kapar, Alaattin Baki Aytemiz, Sadettin Ustaosmanoglu, Huseyin Yesilyurt, Cemil Sahin, Salih Sevim, Hayrettin Soykan, Ibrahim Tatli, Mehmet Fazil Aslanturk and Sabahattin Arslan on charges of "starting an uprising against prison authorities" and "starting a fire intentionally".

The indictment sought imprisonment terms from seven and a half years to 10 and a half years to suspects Osman Hakan Hira, Mehmet Akif Turan, Muhammet Mustafa Asik, Gursel Avci, Osman Temiz, Zeynel Abidin Danalioglu, Ibrahim Kapucu, Mustafa Sahin, Necdet Kocatas, Burak Cileli, Mustafa Fisenkci, Serdar Kaplan, Mehmet Sismanoglu, Bahattin Ustaosmanoglu, Yilmaz Sahin, Mehmet Ali Bayram, Mustafa Gunaydin, Fatih Turgut, Sinal Orhan, Mustafa Sismanoglu, Ekrem Demirci, Mustafa Sabah, Ibrahim Demirci, Yahya Yildirim, Turan Bartin, Sukru Sak, Hayrullah Mizrak, Metin Torsun, Murat Cilhan, Mehmet Yavuz Ucum, Gokhan Altunsoy, Fatih Ayhan, Fatih Turgut, Tugay Hukum and Abdulselam Tutal on charges of "starting an uprising against prison authorities" and "starting a fire intentionally".

Source: Anatolia news agency, Ankara, in English 1557 gmt 23 Oct 00

/BBC Monitoring/ © BBC.

Turkey tries to quash bloody prison revolts


Associated Press
Thursday, December 21, 2000

ISTANBUL -- Soldiers smashed through prison walls to battle radical leftist inmates reportedly armed with guns and makeshift flamethrowers as the fight for control of Turkey's prisons entered its second day yesterday.

At least 19 people were dead and the European Commission warned that Turkey's tactics were once again calling the country's human-rights record into question.

Justice Minister Hikmet Sami Turk urged inmates in Istanbul's Umraniye prison and in a penitentiary in the western city of Canakkale to surrender. But the inmates, most linked to an armed left-wing group, remained defiant.

Inmates have vowed to burn themselves alive if attacked. Several of the inmates who died Tuesday had set themselves on fire.

Prime Minister Bulent Ecevit said Tuesday's raids on 18 other prisons had been successful in ending a two-month hunger strike.

Many Turkish prisoners live in wards of up to 100 people. Inmates from political groups often run their wards like indoctrination centres decorated with rebel flags. The government has started to break up the wards by moving prisoners to individual cells.

According to TV reports, inmates in Canakkale hurled pipebombs at soldiers, who used heavy machinery to break two prison walls.

Selasa, 27/6/2000, 02:09 WIB Pemimpin gerilya Islam Turki coba bunuh diri Laporan Eka Chandrasari satunet.com - Pemimpin kelompok gerilyawan Islam Turki gagal dalam upayanya bunuh diri setelah teman satu sel di sebuah penjara memotong tali yang menjerat lehernya. Menurut kantor berita Turki Anatolian Senin, pemimpin kelompok gerilyawan Islam IBDA-C, yang dikenal sebagai Salih Mirzabeyoglu, telah ditahan sejak dua tahun lalu karena berupaya mengganti konsitusi negara dengan cara kekerasan dan ia tampaknya bisa dijatuhi hukuman mati. Ia dituduh telah melakukan serangkaian pemboman di sejumlah sasaran milik golongan sekuler Turki. Pemimpin gerilya, yang lebih dikenal dengan sebutan Mirzabeyoglu, meski nama aslinya adalah Salih Izzet Erdis, telah beberapa kali mengalami depresi, menurut laporan polisi setempat. Pejabat penjara telah memindahkan seorang tahanan ke ruang sel tempat Mirzabeyoglu guna ikut menjaga bila ia berusaha bunuh diri. Sejauh ini belum diketahui apa yang digunakan teman satu sel Mirzabeyoglu untuk memotong tali yang menjerat leher pemimpin gerilya tersebut pada hari Minggu itu. Sebelumnya, yakni awal tahun ini, beberapa anak buah Mirzabeyoglu menyerang penjaga penjara guna berusaha membawa pemimpin gerilya itu keluar dari penjara untuk dilakukan pemeriksaan pengadilan. Namun upaya mereka gagl setelah pasukan keamanan berhasil memadamkan kerusuhan di penjara tersebut dan kemudian menempatkan Mirzabeyoglu di sel tersendiri. Pada kesempatan lainnya, Mirzabeyoglu dan anak buahnya juga pernah menyandera 150 penjaga penjara pada Desember tahun lalu.(trm)