| Stock Investment |
Building a Portfolio: Asset Allocation The key to all asset allocation models is risk. What is "risk"? Well,
when capitalized - it's a board game, but it's more than that. If you
recall way back in Step 2.
Investing Concepts, risk is the measurement of how willing you are to
see the value of your investments decrease in the near term, even while
you know the chances that they will increase over the long term. The
higher the risk in an investment, the more likely it is to drop in the
short term as well as to rise.
In modern finance, risk is defined as the variability of returns. If an
asset jumps up and down a lot, it is deemed to be riskier than an asset
that stays put or climbs slowly - even if the asset that jumps around a
lot tends to outperform the slower moving assets over time. This is
somewhat akin to young children. The ones who jump around a lot are deemed
somewhat riskier to themselves than the ones that just sit and watch
television all day. Many will find the jumpy ones ultimately more
satisfying and successful, though they obviously require a bit more
attention. When your returns are more variable, you have more of a chance
of losing money. When investors adjust their returns for risk, they use
some figure (normally the "beta," or volatility relative to the S&P
500) to adjust the returns. If your stocks were jumpier than average, your
risk-adjusted returns get penalized.
The problem with this kind of approach is that it inherently has a
short-term bias. Stocks, by and large, outperform everything else over
long periods of time. Over more than ten or 20 years, if you invest in
stocks, you are almost guaranteed to outperform anything else. Investors
who use asset allocation models that are concerned about short-term
volatility underperform over the long term because these models will
inevitably take them out of stocks and put them into other investments
like bonds.
When Will You Need the Money? If you need the money within the next five years, you are going to want
to avoid individual stocks and stock mutual funds. If you need the money
within the next three years, you are probably going to want to also avoid
bond mutual funds and real estate investment trusts (REITs), which can
drop if interest rates increase. For those who need the money within the
next three years, you have a few choices left
- buying individual bonds or certificates of deposit (CDs) with durations
of less than three years, putting your money in a money market fund, or
using a savings account. Each of these investment vehicles generates
income while guaranteeing that you will get your principal back. If you
need the money within the next three to five years, you can't really
afford to lose very much of it, right?
Long-Term Returns
As you can see, over three pretty significant periods returns from
stocks walloped the returns from bonds or money market funds (in this
case, T-bills can serve as a proxy for money market funds and short-term
bonds). In spite of the fact that over all three periods measured stocks
had several drops of 20% or more, with a few leaving stocks down 80% from
top to bottom, the returns have still been superior to anything bonds have
produced.
The difference in annual returns is magnified over long periods of
time. Because of the miracle of compounding, each year you are left with
slightly more money that is reinvested at a higher rate of return, and
that extra money earns more money. Over the period from 1950 to 1995, an
investor would have earned a total return of 19,300% in stocks versus 523%
in long-term bonds - almost 20 times as much.
Let's try that sentence again, this time with some punctuation.
Over the period from 1950 to 1995, an investor in stocks would have
earned a total return of 19,300%! This compared to 523% in long-term bonds
- almost 20 times as much!! Didn't Einstein say something like, "The most
powerful principle I ever witnessed was compound interest"? He did say
that actually, which is a pretty ringing endorsement, since he discovered
a couple other pretty powerful principles as well.
As you can see from the historical returns listed above, stocks have a
place in every portfolio. The historical record stretching back to the
beginning of the 19th century indicates that stocks will beat returns of
other investments by a healthy margin. If you have the intestinal
fortitude to stick with stocks even during the inevitable periodic
downturns and you have money that you will not need for five years or
more, you should consider putting that money in stocks (or REITs, the real
estate equivalent of stocks). Of course, this is not a cut-and-dried asset
allocation model like you might get from a full-service broker, but in the
end the decisions about where to invest your money are so dependent on
your individual situation that no one-size-fits-all model could ever work
for each investor.
When to Sell Some investors believe they can "time" the market, meaning that they
think they can tell when the market will go up and when it will go down.
As a result, they counsel selling all of your stocks when the market is
going to go down and buying them all back when the market is going to go
back up. Unfortunately, if it were that easy these same folks would be
sunning themselves on beaches in Acapulco and not trying to sell
newsletters. Certainly when the overall economic scenario gets bad enough
to hurt corporate earnings growth and companies start to flounder, you
might consider selling some of the lower quality companies that are
overvalued - but a system to consistently time the market as a whole has
been about as actively pursued as alchemy, and at this point is about as
realized.
If you have purchased a stock mutual fund, you have handed your money
over to a professional money manager or you have handed it over to
passively follow an index like the S&P 500. When should you sell a
stock mutual fund? If you bought a fund because of the record of the
manager and that manager leaves or turns out not to be quite what was
advertised, selling might be a consideration. However, as it has been
proven in several academic studies that people who jump from mutual fund
to mutual fund tend to wildly underperform those that stay put, sticking
with a fund even during bad times should be your default setting. If that
great manager you have known and loved for years jumps ship to go
elsewhere, you might want to consider following along. But just because
you have not done so well over the past six months is never a good reason
to sell a fund.
Selling a stock is slightly more complicated than selling a stock
mutual fund. The two major reasons to sell a stock are 1) if the basic
business changes in a way that was not anticipated, or 2) if the stock
becomes overvalued enough that even after considering the taxes you would
have to pay on the capital gains you still believe the company will
underperform.
When the business changes or management proves inept at handling the
business, all the patience in the world is seldom rewarded. Investors who
stubbornly held on to shares of buggy whip makers and ice delivery
services at the beginning of the 20th century saw their investments erode
into obscurity as automobiles and refrigerators made their products
obsolete. Selling might make sense if a company switches businesses to one
you don't understand very well. Is the teenager taking your burger order
asking, "Would you like a web-browser with that?" rather than the previous
attempt at getting you to add some fries? The most important risk you run
in owning a company's stock is that you don't understand the business.
Finally, if a stock becomes overvalued enough that the shares have a
substantial risk of decline, you should consider selling to preserve
capital. This is the "Sell high" portion of the "Buy low, sell high"
cliche. Don't be too eager though. If it is a quality company and the
overvaluation could be cleared up with a year or two's worth of financial
results, you may actually be better off holding and avoiding the big tax
charge on your gain. However, if the valuation is stratospheric and seems
to assume that all the news between here and the end of the world will be
good, selling could possibly be the better part of valor.
Bull, Bear and Volatile Markets Foolish investors believe that this is an exercise in futility and that
focusing on individual companies and their businesses is the only way to
go. Bull market, bear market, or volatile market aside, in order to get
the kind of long-term returns on stocks that investors have seen for the
last two centuries, the buy and hold mantra is the one that has served
investors the best over time.
The Impact of Taxes While tax consequences should always be something you consider when
selling a stock, never let taxes be the tail that wags the investment dog.
The decision whether you keep or sell a stock should never be made based
on tax consequences alone.
Review, Review, Review Reviewing your investments, particularly when you may have made
mistakes, offers a crucial opportunity to learn from your mistakes rather
than being doomed to repeat them. Everyone makes errors on occasion, but
most successful investors avoid making the same errors more than once. Set
aside time to review your portfolio at least once every three months, if
not weekly. While you shouldn't be glued to the computer screen tracking
your investments on a minute-by-minute basis, tossing them in a drawer and
forgetting them is not a great idea either.
Conclusion Finally, we'd like to stress that all of what we've covered here --
from compound returns to inflation to bond yields to asset allocation --
is more than simply numbers and philosophies. Investing is what enables us
to buy homes, pay for our kids' educations, retire early, take exotic
vacations, and give our grandkids extravagant gifts. We wish you luck --
but we don't think you'll need it. You've got all the tools at your
fingertips and a solid understanding of what it takes to be a successful
investor.
So you have made your way
through the first seven parts of Investing Basics, your brain hasn't
melted and you're beginning to feel Foolish. You understand how to get
your finances in order before investing and have mastered basic investment
lingo. At cocktail parties or festive family reunions you can talk stocks,
bonds, and mutual funds without looking at the cue cards, and most
importantly, you know the basic approaches to valuing each one. Finally,
you can select an affordable broker that will allow you to transact your
investment decisions. You've learned the investing basics. Now what do you
do next?
Knowing how
to analyze and select stocks, bonds, and mutual funds is only half the
battle. How much of each should be in your portfolio? Complicated,
contradictory, and confusing asset allocation models abound in the
investment world. Many times these models appear to be designed by a
committee of dueling economists who have agreed upon adding a small dash
of every investment option imaginable rather than to give investors
guidance in how to divvy up their investment pie. What is a poor investor
to do?
Risk sounds like a
pretty serious problem. How can someone possibly assess his or her risk
tolerance? Variability of returns does not seem to be the answer. If the
main issue with risk is that stocks are riskier over short periods of
time, how can you compensate for this without creating overly complicated
asset allocation models? It is quite simple. Before you start buying, you
need to assess how much risk you are willing to take on and then select
investments based on that risk tolerance. This means deciding when you
need the money.
So, if you can lose money on
stocks, stock and bond mutual funds, and REITs over short periods of time,
why invest in them at all? Why not stick to the safe alternatives and let
it lie? Well, if you look at the long-term historical returns that
investment vehicles like stocks have generated, you should have second
thoughts about sticking with the low-risk, low-return vehicles that serve
as safe havens for parking your money.
Average Annual Returns
1802-1995
1900-1995
1950-1995
T-bills
-
4.19%
5.35%
Bonds
4.97%
4.05%
4.15%
Stocks
7.79%
9.78%
12.42%
Data from Global Financial Data
So you have bought some investments
and you are wondering when might be an opportune time to sell? As bonds
really end up selling themselves when they mature and you receive all of
your principal back, the real selling issues come up when you own stocks
or stock mutual funds.
The media pays an
awful lot of attention to the market, though quite often it only looks at
a particular index (such as the Dow) and considers that representative of
the market as a whole. The market is considered to be bullish if it is
going up, bearish if it is going down, and volatile if it is going up and
down in quick succession. Some investors, particularly those who use
technical analysis, like to look at charts of the market in order to
assess investor psychology to gauge whether or not the market can go
higher.
Investors need to keep in mind
that the real return on their investment is the return they have left
after they pay Uncle Sam and his cousins in the state and local tax
collection offices. The difference between a 10% gain taxed at 36% (one of
the highest income tax brackets) and a 10% gain taxed at 20% (the highest
long-term capital gains rate) is quite significant. Waiting long enough to
ensure that you get the most favorable tax rate possible when selling an
investment can often make a big difference.
Most important of all to the
long-term success of your investment portfolio is paying attention. Would
you buy a plant and never water it? Would you buy a dog and let him keep
eating the curtains after you've explicitly and patiently explained the
reasons he shouldn't? Of course not. The same is true, to a lesser degree,
for a portfolio of investments. Unless they are government bonds, any
investment needs to be checked up on regularly to see if it is matching or
beating the market and other substantially similar alternatives.
Congratulations! You've made it through
all of Investing Basics. As you continue to build upon the foundation you
have gained here, you'll discover the subtleties of building your wealth
through investing. We encourage you to make use of the many investing
tools and resources available here and add to your knowledge base.
^ back to top ^