Ummagumma (live album)
1- Astronomy Domine
Written by: Barrett
Running Time: 8:29
From:
The Piper At The Gates Of Dawn
Best Version: Ummugumma (live album)
Rating: *****
Comments:  From the very beginning of this four-track, incredibly short live album, you know that it is a very unique piece of music.  This song starts it off, a very different version from its original form, as far as Pink Floyd song variations go.  This version is without the heavy sound effects, and is softer than other versions, yet it is much more powerful somehow.  It's impossible to tell that there is an audience on this album, but the live versions here are the best versions of every song on it, and this song is the perfect example.
Lyrics:

lime and limpid green
a second scene
a fight between the blue you once knew
floating down, the sound resounds
around the icy waters underground
jupiter and saturn
oberon, miranda and titania
neptune, titan, stars can frighten

lime and limpid green
a second scene
a fight between the blue you once knew
floating down, the sound resounds
around the icy waters underground
jupiter and saturn
oberon, miranda and titania
neptune, titan, stars can frighten

blinding signs flap
flicker flicker flicker blam
pow pow
stairway scare dan dare who's there

lime and limpid green
the sound surrounds
the icy waters under
lime and limpid green
the sound surrounds
the icy waters underground
2- Careful With That Axe, Eugene
Written by: Waters, Wright, Mason, Gilmour
Running Time: 8:50
Best Version: Ummagumma (live album)
Rating: *****
Comments:  The first very haunting song by Pink Floyd is this epic instrumental, which is packed with power.  It starts off very mellow, with a great yet simple beat, then begins to build until it suddenly erupts into heavy drums and loud screaming.  Afterwards it falls back into a steady, mellow rhythm, and leads you out.  This is a very original song, hard to find anything else like it.  It definitely tells a story, but what that story is exactly is up to you.
(no lyrics)
Words:
careful with that axe, eugene...
3- Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun
Written by: Waters
Running Time: 9:12
From:
A Saucerful Of Secrets
Best Version:
In The Flesh
Rating: *****
Comments:  This is a very slow and haunting tune, much longer and deeper than its original version, and therefore a bit better.  There is an annoying hiss on this track though, for some reason, but it's easy to get past that and appreciate the beauty of this song and its very deep, almost philosophical lyrics.  The pace gets faster and the music more psychedellic, and then returns to its soft beat, while producing incredible images in your mind throughout.
Lyrics:

little by little, the night turns around
counting the leaves which tremble at dawn
lotuses lean on each other in yearning
under the eaves the swallow is resting
set the controls for the heart of the sun

over the mountain, watching the watcher
breaking the darkness, waking the grapevine
one inch of love is one inch of shadow
love is the shadow that ripens the wine
set the controls for the heart of the sun
the heart of the sun, the heart of the sun...

witness the man who raves at the wall?
making the shape of his question to heaven
whether the sun will fall in the evening
will he remember the lesson of giving
set the controls for the heart of the sun
the heart of the sun, the heart of the sun...
4- A Saucerful Of Secrets
Written by: Waters, Wright, Mason, Gilmour
Running Time: 12:48
From:
A Saucerful Of Secrets
Best Version: Ummagumma (live album)
RANKING: #19  ******
Comments:  This is an absolutely incredible instrumental, packed with power and emotion.  It is one of the best instrumental pieces ever recorded.  Starting off rather slow and with a choppy melody, then building and building and finally bursting into a powerful drum solo.  The drums solo continues until it finally gives way to a new melody, which is incredibly beautiful, and builds onto itself as well.  This version of this song is much better than its original form, mostly because of the very ending.  Instead of soft voices of a choir humming in the background near the end, you hear David Gilmour burst in with vocals, and continuing them through the end of the amazing song.  The vocals are highly emotional and inspiring, and they make this one of the best tracks Pink Floyd has ever produced.
(no lyrics)
Released: 1969 by Harvest Records
Running Time: 39:19
Ranking: #4 out of 5 live albums
Album Highlight: A Saucerful Of Secrets
Album Weak Point: (none)
Average Song Rating: *****
Comments:  This is a fabulous album, the only flaw being that it only contains four songs.  Each song, with the exception of "Set The Controls..." is the best version.  The album is consistent from beginning to end, without a single tedious moment to listen to.  The last two minutes of the album are the best, with a spectacular level of emotion and intensity.  It is worth buying the Ummagumma package just to get this amazing album.