I find it very hard to believe that GIs would ever talk to their Captain with so little respect -
particularly in a combat situation. Miller may have been a nice guy but he was still the C.O. Does anyone have any real life anecdotes about this kind of thing?
Msole
After Caparzo's death we see a distance shot of the troop
passing through the countryside as we had seen before. There are STILL EIGHT
troopers. Martin G. Schofield
Would not happen: All the gabbing and joking while
moving about the countryside. And in "The Dog Tag Scene": As
you see Capt. Miller walk among the walking wounded, calling out for Pvt
Ryan, in the background you see the Extras begin walking, as if they just
received their cue. ajliptak
The land behind the beaches was flooded by seawater
by locks by the Germans. This water swamped the land for a mile in some
places. It was deep enough to drown a trooper if he was dropped in it.
Yet, the Ryan Finders were just walking through quiet country. No water,
no distant gunfire, nothing. WRONG!! Blackltac
After the battle for the radar
station the team set about burying Wade and the 3 paratroopers who are
all from the 82nd Airborne. The helmets are placed on top of the rifles
and you can clearly see white Divisional markings on them. The 82nd (as
far as I know) didn't have markings on the helmets, this was an 101st trait.
G
King
Why is
the squad so mortified before they assault the radar site when Capt. Miller
informs them that they will be going up against an MG-42? After all, they
faced so many of them back at Omaha Beach & at this stage of the war,
an MG-42 was no a rarity! kingdoof
When Miller
and the rest of the patrol encounter the German Machine gun site they come
across two dead paratroopers, note Miller says the troops are 82nd Airborne.
After the machine gun is taken out they bury the dead paratroopers and
place their helmets on top of the rifles to mark the graves. These helmets
have a white ace of spades painted on the sides. This was the unit symbol
of the 506th Parachute Infantry which belonged to the 101st Airborne. 82nd
Airborne had no markings on their helmets. Richard
King
The squad
goes through several open fields at will. What about land mines? I thought
there were several million of them put in the fields to discourage paratroopers?
M.
Kuchar
Did anybody
notice the nice modern bungalow in the background as the patrol moved inland...
I think it even has a TV antenna on the roof. Ray
Rice
I wonder
how 8 men could go all the way through France. I mean they're was Germans
everywhere and Germans were excellent. If the Germans had a country the
size of ours, we would be Nazis now. The German sniper in the first village
had Jackson in his sites for 30 seconds before Jackson fired. Medics at
that time didn't serve as fighters. They usually were back lines and they
didn't fight.
Jesse Barnes (12 years old)
Please
Feel Free To Contribute To This List Of Errors in saving
private ryan