| Team | Players | Year | Points | | |
| 1. |  Palmetto St |  Colt Brennan (252) Chase Clement (97) | 2007 | 349 | | |
| 2. |  Duff Beer |  Tim Tebow (266) Andre' Woodson (77) | 2007 | 343 | | |
| 3. |  Betty White |  Graham Harrell (317) Adam Tafralis (14) | 2007 | 331 | | |
| 4. | Palmetto St | Colt Brennan (309)  Jeff Ballard (17) | 2006 | 326 | | |
| 5. |  Peoples U |  Paul Smith (299) John Parker Wilson (15) | 2007 | 314 | | |
| 6. |  Gridiron Group | B.J. Symons (264)  Chance Harridge (32) | 2003 | 296 | | |
| 7. |  South Central |  Pat White (191) Alex Brink (62) | 2006 | 253 | | |
| 8. |  Cincinnati |  Ryan Dinwiddie (172)Scott Rislov (46)  Derek Anderson (31) | 2003 | 249 | | |
| 9. | South Central |  Philip Rivers (163) J.P. Losman (78) | 2003 | 241 | | |
| 10. |  Pee Dee |  Brady Quinn (211) Stephen McGee (23) | 2006 | 234 | | |
| 11. | Duff Beer |  Rod Rutherford (118) Danny Wimprine (114) | 2003 | 232 | | |
| 12. |  Headbanger |  Brad Smith (214) John Navarre (15) | 2003 | 229 | | |
| 13. | South Central | Patrick White (201)  Jake Locker (18)Alex Brink (9) | 2007 | 228 | | |
| 14. |  Sam Adams | Cody Hodges (219)  Donovan Woods (8) | 2005 | 227 | | |
| 15. |  Slacker |  Vince Young (225) | 2005 | 225 | | |
| 16. | Gridiron Group | Chase Daniel (217)  Sam Bradford (6) | 2007 | 223 | | |
| 17. | Palmetto St | Sonny Cumbie (181) Reggie McNeal (41) | 2004 | 222 | | |
| 18. | Headbanger | Brad Smith (213)  Jamarcus Russel (9) | 2005 | 222 | | |
| 19. | Palmetto St |  Jordan Palmer (117)Reggie McNeal (78) Shaun Carney (17) | 2005 | 212 | | |
| 20. |  Burlington |  Brian Johnson (190) Bret Meyer (10) Kyle Wright (10) | 2005 | 210 | | |