| Team | Players | Year | Points | | |
| 1. |  Palmetto St |  Kevin Smith (208) Matt Forte (159) Felix Jones (63) Marcus Thomas (49) Rafael Little (27) | 2007 | 506 | | |
| 2. |  Betty White |  Maurice Drew (201) Michael Bush (169) Arian Foster (20) Toney Baker (14) | 2005 | 404 | | |
| 3. |  South Central |  Steve Slaton (192)Darren McFadden (154)  Ahmad Bradshaw (52) Hugh Charles (3) | 2006 | 401 | | |
| 4. | South Central | Darren McFadden (168) Steve Slaton (151)  Jorvorskie Lane (48) | 2007 | 367 | | |
| 5. |  Duff Beer |  Jerome Harrison (145) DeAngelo Williams (133) Taurean Henderson (88) | 2005 | 366 | | |
| 6. | Duff Beer | DeAngelo Williams (147)  Cedric Benson (96) Lendale White (46)Taurean Henderson (29)  Kenny James (25) | 2004 | 343 | | |
| 7. |  Gridiron Group |  Dontrell Moore (150)Mewelde Moore (82) Quincy Wilson (82)  Ibrahim Halsey (20) | 2003 | 334 | | |
| 8. | Betty White |  Ray Rice (166) LeSean McCoy (91)Anthony Allen (65)  Tony Temple (3) | 2007 | 325 | | |
| 9. |  Headbanger |  P.J. Hill (132) Mike Hart (106) Antonio Pittman (67) | 2006 | 305 | | |
| 10. |  Cincinnati | Jamaal Charles (137)  DeMarco Murray (122) Austin Scott (24) Mike Ford (17)Joseph Doss (2) | 2007 | 302 | | |
| 11. |  Peoples U |  Justin Forsett (107)Rashard Mendenhall (87)  Tashard Choice (78) Kory Sheets (11) Tyrell Sutton (10) | 2007 | 293 | | |
| 12. | Duff Beer | Rodney Ferguson (132) Chris Wells (113)  Cory Boyd (42) | 2007 | 287 | | |
| 13. | Headbanger | P.J. Hill (135) Mike Hart (123)  Anthony Dixon (24) | 2007 | 282 | | |
| 14. | Cincinnati | Lendale White (124) Marshawn Lynch (65) Jamaal Charles (48)  Thomas Clayton (43) Rudy Burgess (2) | 2005 | 282 | | |
| 15. |  Burlington |  Ian Johnson (152) Yvenson Bernard (116) Wynel Seldon (12) | 2007 | 280 | | |
| 16. | South Central |  Marion Barber (125) Chance Kretschmer (106)Kejuan Jones (46) | 2003 | 277 | | |
| 17. |  College | Reggie Bush (140) Laurence Maroney (137) | 2005 | 277 | | |
| 18. |  Pee Dee |  Anthony Alridge (158) James Davis (92) Lonyae Miller (8)Mike Davis (8)  Marcus Thigpen (3) | 2007 | 269 | | |
| 19. | Headbanger | Chris Perry (179) Anthony Davis (39) David Mikell (37)  Ciatrick Fason (14) | 2003 | 269 | | |
| 20. | Palmetto St |  Wali Lundy (114)Eric Shelton (84) P.J. Daniels (52) BenJarvus Green-Ellis (18) | 2004 | 268 | | |