|
|
HONOR ROLL
SITUATIONS
+ 1. PFC WILLIAM BEATTIE Jr.
, USMC
Having lived 20 (short) years - Died Nov.
14, 1992...Accident???
+ 2. CHIEF THOMAS RICHARD TRAYLOR
, USN
Born: October 14, 1961 - 37 (too few) years
- Died: December 6, 1998...Suicide???
+ 3. MSSR STEPHEN J. KILLIAN, Jr.
USN
Born: July 14, 1980 - 18 (short) years -
Died: May 30, 1999...Suicide???
+ 4. 2nd Lt KIRK C. VANDERBUR
, USMCR
Born: Dec. 28, 1967 - 24 (short) years -
Died: Feb. 16, 1992...Suicide???
PFC WILLIAM BEATTIE
Jr., USMC (Died Nov. 14, 1992)
In Nov. of 1992, Billy Beattie was a 20 yr.
old Marine, serving in Okinawa, Japan, when he notified
his family that he'd just spent $1,200.00 and bought
the stereo system of his dreams! Two weeks later he was
dead and the military ruled the death as an 'accident' during the
commission of a crime. According to the military, he'd
stolen a stereo and while going down the building's outside
rainspout, he'd fallen to the roof of the neighboring building
and was strangled by the stereo's speaker cord that he'd wrapped
around his neck to keep it out of his way while he made his
escape. (As Hm3 Scott Beimdiek's letter to his family would
later note, "Yeah, RIGHT!")
Strangely, though Billy's family was notified
and one 'official' listing of non-combat casualties
lists his 'manner' of death as an "accident", another
lists it as "pending". Either way, this is an awfully long
time to make a family wait for an explanation of what could have caused
Billy's knuckles to be bruised and why there were other bruises
on both sides of his body. Additionally, the family is still
waiting to hear:
-
Why
the statement by a 'black' marine, who reported being
warned that, 'the same thing that happened to the 'white'
marine could happen to him', has been ignored and
-
how
'officials' can justify ignoring the fact that of the 13
identifiable sets of the 50 plus sets of fingerprints found
on the stereo...NONE belong to Billy.
If you have any questions or comments
on this case, please contact MAMMA and we will make
every effort to put you in contact with Billy's family.
CHIEF THOMAS RICHARD
TRAYLOR, USN (October 14, 1961 - December 6, 1998)
By December of 1998, Chief Thomas R. Traylor,
was an E-7 with a 15 year Navy career of handling ordinance
and loading many of the bombs on the F-18s. For 13 months,
as a member of the teams called 'The Dust Devils' with
the Weapons Testing Squadron, he'd worked with top secret
and classified testing and bombing of new warfare missiles
at the Naval Air Warfare Center at China Lake, CA, one of the largest
Bombing Ranges in California.
China Lake Base is located in an isolated
and remote area of the Mojave Desert, 150 miles northeast
of Los Angeles, CA. The base covers 1,700 square miles
of land used for bombing and testing ranges underlying more
that 20,000 square miles of restricted air space. The base at
China Lake is a twin to New Mexico's Los Alamos Base in handling
highly confidential material for national defense. At
China Lake they developed and tested missiles, rockets and
other sophisticated ordinance weapons. From the Tomahawk
Cruise Missile, weapons used in the Persian Gulf War to
the Bat, the world's first operational homing missile used
in the final months of World War II. It was just off the base, a short
distance from the home he shared with his wife, that the
body of Chief Traylor was found, on Dec. 6, 1998, sitting
inside his vehicle with a gun wound to the upper chest...he
had been missing for two (2) days.
Due to the fragile nature of 'crime scene'
evidence, any unattended death, especially one where
the cause of death was violent, is to be considered and
treated as a homicide. Yet, the death of Chief Thomas
Traylor was ruled by the Kern County California Sheriff's Department,
at the scene, 'Suicide'. His hands were not bagged or tested
for resin, no fingerprints or blood samples were taken
and an internal autopsy was not done. Essentially there
was NO investigation.
As the Navy's JAG investigation only consisted
of 1-1/2 pages of references to other reports claiming
suicide and was full of erroneous details, the FBI was
contacted. The FBI claimed to have no authority to conduct
an investigation in the absence of an indication that a violation
of federal law within their jurisdiction had occurred. Jurisdiction?
Hadn't this man been 'federal property' 24 hours a day for
15 years?
A simple...'Suicide'? What a strange ruling
for a man, who all his life had been very vocal about
his contempt toward suicide. His widow quotes him as saying,
'Suicide is a cowardly act and a long term solution to a
short term problem'. The questions that surround this death are
numerous and include:
- Dr. R. Rohrlick, a counselor Chief Traylor
had sessions with weekly for alcohol and credit card
problems, has continually reaffirmed that Tom's mental
state of mind was normal on Dec. 3rd - the last day Chief
Traylor was seen alive. He further states that Chief Traylor was
never a candidate for suicide but his statement was never
taken by the authorities. Why?
- Thomas' shotgun was found on the passenger
side of the vehicle and it was assumed that he held
the gun out to his right side about the level of the dashboard
and pulled the trigger. Yet, photos taken at the scene,
but not developed until 7 months later, reveal that Thomas
was holding his glasses with his right hand at the time of death.
- The Sheriff's photographs from the scene
show bruising to the face and possibly as many as three
(3) wounds to the right chest and hip area.
-
The
external autopsy showed Thomas had a blood alcohol level
of 0.28. Would such an impaired man have the coordination
needed to hold a long gun out to his side, in the
manner suggested by the authorities, and pull the
trigger?
-
Thomas
was a large man of 6 ft. 2 ins. and weighed 210 lbs. He'd
grown up with and owned numerous guns during his lifetime.
Would such a man choose a gun with birdshot, which
is little more than a wad of BB's used to shoot small
birds, to commit suicide?
-
Chief
Traylor's body was found in his large red pickup truck
that was less than 1/4 mile out and in plain view of his house.
How can it be that search parties, sent to the Chief's home
when he failed to show up for duty, took two and a half days
to find the body? It was later learned that, just prior to
his death, he'd often parked a short distance from the house,
in the desert, in the evenings and on weekends where he could
watch the house and not be seen himself.
-
Thomas
Traylor's wife was in Pleasant Hill, CA visiting and arranging
for care of an elderly aunt, who requires full time care
due to Alzheimer Disease. A few nights before he disappeared,
he called his wife and noted that he'd overheard a conversation
concerning illegal activities taking place in and around
the China Lake Base. He seemed concerned that he may have
informed the wrong people about what he'd heard and told
her he didn't think he was going to live long, but would
not tell her anything more.
-
The
night he disappeared, Chief Traylor attended the Weapons
Test Squadron party. Efforts to learn who else attended the
party and trace the last hours of Tom's life have failed,
in part because Chief Traylor's friends were given
a 'Gag Order' - never to speak to Tom's widow. She questions
if Tom was purposely gotten drunk at the squadron party
and when his defenses were down, he was followed and killed
on his way home.
Chief Thomas R. Traylor's widow has this
to say, 'My husband had no enemies and was the most
kind-hearted and helpful man - this fact was known througghout
his naval career. My husband served to keep our nation
safe, safe from what? Instead he was beaten, murdered and it was called
a 'suicide,.' One of the cruelest things the military can do
to a family. It's obvious why the Navy and the Kern County
'Good Old Boys Club' don't want me to learn the truth.'
Tom's body was exhumed. The ensuing autopsy showed that the
shot that killed Tom entered from the upper right side of his chest with the
pellets ending up down at the waist on his left side. The ceiling room in
the vehicle would not have allowed Tom to hold the gun high enough to shoot
himself in that manner.
If you have any questions or comments on
this case, or would like to send a note to Tom's widow,
you can e-mail her at: horselady@iglide.net
MSSR STEPHEN J.
KILLIAN, Jr. USN (July 14, 1980 - May 30, 1999)
Stephen joined the Navy in November 1998
and his family went to see him graduate from boot camp
in Jan. 1999. He subsequently attended A-school in San
Antonio, TX for Mess Specialist and as graduated at the
top of his class, he was able to pick where he wanted to be stationed.
He chose Oceana, VA. because it was close to home and would
make it easier to travel back and forth when he was on leave.
In April of '99, he went home for 2 weeks
and he shared all his stories about boot camp with friends
and family. He told his friends that all though he missed
them, he thought this was the best thing he'd ever done!
A couple of his friends even joined the Navy after this
and another friend joined the Air Force. Though Stephen had matured
so much in such a short time and looked a little older in his
uniform, his mother still found herself thinking, 'My 18yr.
old baby my little sailor'. His father and mother drove him
to the Airport on April 17, 1999, and this was to be the last
time they saw their son alive! His body was found in Las Vegas
May 30, 1999 and the circumstances under which he died were,
to say the least, questionable.
Prior to his death, he spoke with his family
several times. Though he admitted that he missed everyone
he was busy making friends and trying to get use to
the long work hours in the galley. During his last call
home, he noted that he'd just bought a TV, had gotten his
cable hooked up, had his own phone so family wouldn't have to pay
long distance phone bills, a new Sony Playstation with a
few video games and a clock radio. Two days later, he mysteriously
vanished off base and no one saw him again until his body
was found hanging in a hotel room in Las Vegas on Sunday,
May 30, 1999!
The LVMPD did not conduct any type of an
investigation. No fingerprints where taken, no one
was questioned, no videos of ATM machines were viewed,
and there was no explanation of where over $1200.00 of withdrawn
money had gone as only $19.80 was in his possession when
his body was found. The Navy refused to investigate the
death, claiming that he had been off duty, that his death
had nothing to do with the Navy and that it was out of their
jurisdiction!
One of Stephen's friends from the base attended
the funeral and told the family that he did not believe
their son was traveling by himself or taking money out
of ATMs by himself. Stephen's mother fought for a whole
year to have this boy questioned and then the only question
they asked him (by email yet) was...how well did you know Stephen
Killian? Officials totally disregarded concerns that this boy
knew something about possible illegal activity at their base.
Though they started a 'little investigation', within his unit,
2 months after his death, his mother waited until 2001 to
get a letter that stated how sorry they were and that this
was uncalled for. They told her that now they investigate such
things within 72 hrs. and have a report sent to the family within
30 days! Stephen's mother has said, 'Gee, am I suppose to thank
them! I think not! There are just to many holes in this case,
too many things that were overlooked and not done! My only
son took an oath to serve his country but yet in his death the
Navy did NOTHING to serve him or his family!'
A memorial for Stephen can be viewed at:
http://oocities.com/winkkks/ptmbeloved.html
and if you have any questions
or comments on this case, or would like to send a
note to Stephen's mother, you can e-mail her at: plaza1713@hotmail.com
.
2nd Lt KIRK C.
VANDERBUR, USMCR (Dec. 28, 1967 - Feb. 16, 1992)
Kirk was found Feb. 17, 1992 at a private
rifle range near Camp Lejeune, NC. He had been shot
in the abdomen with #6 birdshot by a Spas 12 and between
the eyes with a Ruger Mini 14 (.223). There was no homicide
investigation. The JAG investigation was questionable because
there was missing property and fingerprint and powder
residue tests weren't done. Strangely, the guns were about
10 feet apart and there were two (2) spent shells from
the rifle...does the military believe that Kirk missed
the first time?
Kirk's mother has belonged to "Until We Have
Answers" since January 1993. After reading the article
about the death of Scott Jakovic in the U.S. News &
World Report by Peter Cary in November 1992, several families
contacted Peter Cary, who put them in touch with each other.
Three of their stories aired on 20/20 in June 1993 under the "Until
We Have Answers" title. In May 1993 the families met in Washington
DC with the congressional oversight committee. Several of
the contested "suicides" rulings were written about and the
committee agreed that these investigations should be looked
into again.
After Kirk's funeral his body was taken to
St. Luke's hospital in Sioux City, Iowa, where Dr. Tom
Bennett, IA State Medical Examiner, had agreed to do a
second autopsy. His body was released for cremation without
examination. His family doesn't know why. Dr. Bennett was
a part of the 20/20 program. In January 1994 Dr. Bennett and IA Department
of Criminal Investigation agent, Dan Moser, went to North
Carolina without a representative of the family or their investigator,
Fredrick McDaniels, from Kansas City, MO, which was contrary
to a previous agreement. Instead, Dr. Bennett called Kirk's
family from North Carolina to let them know that their investigation
was finished.
Dr. Bennett, Agent Moser and Darwin Chapman,
head of IA DCI, met with Kirk's family in February, but
provided no new information. Dr. Bennett later wrote and
sent poor copies of crime scene photos. Unknown to Kirk's
parents, a letter to Sheriff Ed Brown, Onslow County, NC, went
out over Dr. Bennett's signature after the meeting. That letter
is cover for the sheriff but no more correct than the "suicide"
ruling and the spelling of Kirk's name [Kurt]. Kirk's mother
feels that Dr. Bennett was forced to participate in this
injustice. His correspondence with her and Kirk's father always
had Kirk's name spelled correctly. Kirk's parents were unaware
of the letter until after the 1996 Senate hearings when they
received the letter through FOIA. When they contacted the IA
Department of Safety they were told that nothing could be done
as Dr. Bennett was no longer an employee. Kirk's father wrote a rebuttal
letter which can be found at the PACC website. [Parents Against
Corruption and Cover-up]
Kirk's parents met with the DOD IG's agents
and a reinvestigation was turned down. They question
if that was because of the 'Dr. Bennett letter' they
hadn't seen. Will they ever know?
60 Minutes interviewed Kirk's mother for a
segment they did on Capt. Gordon Hess. Although her part
wasn't aired, the local CBS affiliate did a joint interview
of Kirk's mother and father. After the piece aired Thanksgiving
weekend in 1999, Kirk's parents received a phone call from
a former Marine, who told them that Marines had killed their
son and even knew what order the injuries were inflicted. The NCIS
will not look into the matter without his name. However, after
the deaths of others involved in cases like Sabow and Louthain
Kirk's family refuses to put the man's life in danger.
Kirk's father is a Marine and is very hurt
by the lack of espre de corps...as he believed in Semper
Fi. Kirk's mother has tried to uncover the truth and
prevent the continuing cover-ups, which result in damage
to the family and friends of the bogus "suicides". Kirk was "gung
ho" about life, family and the Marines. He wasn't able to
be an organ donor which was important to him. His life was
taken and his ability to help others was taken.
Kirk's mother says, 'Corrupt people are everywhere,
civilian and military. Looking the other way solves
nothing. Too many times it is the best and the brightest
that are lost.'
UPDATE
Efforts by Sandi Silarski, a student of the
Forensic Sciences at the University of Arkansas at Little
Rock, have uncovered 'physical evidence' that makes Kirkâs
death a matter of Îmurderâ! Ms. Silarskiâs report
is posted, in itâs entirety at:
http://communities.msn.com/IssuesinTodaysLawEnforcementandForensicScience/unsolv
edkirkvanderbur.msnw .
If you have any questions or comments on this
case, or would like to send a note to Kirk's mother,
you can e-mail her at: vanderbur@fbx.com
A
THOUGHT TO PONDER:
"I LOVE MY COUNTRY BUT I DON'T HAVE TO LOVE
MY GOVERNMENT"
...Mark Twain
|
|