The Electoral College: Source of Inequality and Social Injustice in America
by
Gary Parish
WHY HAVE WE TOLERATED THE ELECTORAL COLLEGE FOR SO LONG?
GET THE FACTS

One Person One Vote Myth
Fundamentally Unfair!
See For Yourself!
Social Injustice
Football Analogy
Moral Arguments
EC Cancels Votes
Founding Fathers
Invalid Arguments For EC
States' Rights?
Reform Options
Conclusion
Inequality Maps
EC Cartoons
Postscript:Voting Power
References
Acknowledgements


TAKE ACTION

Action Center
Get Involved
E-mail White House
E-mail Congress
E-mail Newspapers
E-mail Political Parties
E-mail Networks
E-mail Media
Calling Cards
Teaching Notes



WHAT'S NEW?
EC REFORM LINKS




The Federalist Papers show the Founding Fathers great obsession with the amount of influence the states should have in the affairs of the nation. Two fundamental but opposing principles were widely advocated: proportionalism (whereby a state's influence would be calculated based on the number of voting citizens in the state) and equality (whereby a state's influence was considered equal to that of any other state). There was great concern about the tyranny of a majority of the population living in a minority of the states dominating the people in the other states. Unable to reach consensus on either of these principles, the Founding Fathers compromised by adopting both in the form of a bicameral legislature consisting of two houses-the Senate (based on the equality principle), and the House of Representatives (based on the proportionalism principle). Unfortunately, the same logic and compromise were uncritically applied to the selection of the President where it is not a question of state influence so much as a question of voter influence.

The Federalist Papers provide no indication that the Founding Fathers were aware that applying the compromise to the election of the President they were thereby creating inequality among ethnic and religeous minorities. Indeed, at the time slaves and women did not have the right to vote, and the voters were all male property owners. We now know that by creating the Electoral College to incorporate the same compromise between proportionalism and equality, the Founding Fathers unwittingly set the stage for a future elitist form of government in the 20th Century in which one group of voters (mostly white voters in the small states) was given greater influence over another (minority voters in the large states) in the election of the president. With the extension of the right to vote to African Americans and women in the 19th and 20th centuries, the instrument for protecting the minorities against the majority--the Electoral College--became an instrument for discriminating against the minorities in electing the president of the country.


PREVIOUS HOME NEXT


This site was established on 30 January 2001 and is updated weekly.

Sign Guestbook Your GB is private

Click Here To Visit
                        Top10Links